4 ms·
People are getting mad at Lenovo for making people's laptop vulnerable to MITM attacks. But what I don't get is why people are not even more mad that Lenovo is
by baby 12y ago
People are getting mad at Lenovo for making people's laptop vulnerable to MITM attacks. But what I don't get is why people are not even more mad that Lenovo is injecting ads on their private computers.
Since when is it a thing that some laptop brands would put advertisements on your softwares? How come people still buy Lenovo if they do that?
- mwfunk 12y agoWhy would they be even more mad about the ads? Injecting ads is sleazy and deceptive, enabling MITM attacks is actually dangerous. You're right though, the ad injection by itself is still pretty sleazy even if it were perfectly safe. I think it just got overshadowed by the security concerns. Heck, it's insane to me that most PC manufacturers slap a bunch of big ugly stickers on most of their laptops so they can make some absurdly small amount of extra revenue on a product that costs hundreds if not thousands of dollars. Willfully endangering users for a similarly marginal profit boost is so much worse. I have no idea why anyone would buy stuff from such a company.
- themartorana 12y agoProbably because the MITM vulnerability is horrible sloppiness, but the ad serving is done with the malicious intent of continuing to extract revenue from users that just ponied up a couple thousand dollars for the laptop to begin with. I've read people saying there's no way developers didn't know what they were doing WRT the MITM vulnerability. To them I say "you've never worked for a giant corporation." Security holes are second in volume only to spent Keurig pods. However, the choice to turn someone's entire computer in to an adware mechanism was explicit and just really sleazy.
- Rapzid 12y agoI believe the possibility that a developer capable of understanding and creating this local MITM not being aware of the wider security implications is near zero. That would be like a scientist understanding nuclear fission and bomb making not knowing that detonating it in the middle of a city would cause a lot of deaths...
- vertex-four 12y agoThe MITM framework was created by a separate company from the company that developed the specific piece of software. Just like you don't actually have to have a clue how a web server works to write a Rails app, the Superfish developers bought an off-the-shelf MITM framework and used it, which doesn't require much thought.
- nugget 12y ago<< Since when is it a thing that some laptop brands would put advertisements on your softwares? How come people still buy Lenovo if they do that? >> For more than a decade, and almost all OEMs do this. Norton anti virus was the most widely distributed software in the late 00s, paying close to a dollar per install to OEM partners, and then aggressively advertising paid upgrades to users.
- mschuster91 12y agoBack in the old days, Norton was the first thing I killed off of customer's PCs. Funny how much faster the machines were even after installing another antivirus.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIndeed. And not that it was easy to kill; I'm pretty sure it had some hardcoded delays in it, because I can't think of another program requiring so much time and annoyance to remove. And in my books, this is clearly malicious behaviour from a corporation - think of all those productive hours in the entire world wasted because someone decided to ship some crap that then customers had to remove themselves to fix performance. I know it's capitalism, that people are allowed and encouraged to fight with each other (er, compete) for money, but at least let's be explicit about it. It's funny how a company can punch you in the face and make you think it is normal. It's not. You just got punched in the face, you have a right to retaliate.
- maxerickson 12y agoIf you believe what Lenovo is saying, they started removing the software 6 weeks ago (4 months after they added to their images) because people were complaining about it injecting ads. I think they had also already turned off that behavior, the 'it no longer talks to the server' in their statements.