2 ms·
I can't say enough good things about VLC. It has its quirks (the glitch when switching between videos in a playlist is annoying as hell), but when it comes down
by SwellJoe 12y ago
I can't say enough good things about VLC. It has its quirks (the glitch when switching between videos in a playlist is annoying as hell), but when it comes down to it, there is nothing comparable, at any price. I use it professionally in an audiovisual company I started a few years ago, for screening films on huge screens outside, and I've tried several alternatives (often to address problems that turned out not to be VLCs fault, like the fact that Apple ProRes format literally cannot be played back reliably on a laptop computer at high resolutions, including in Apple's own players) only to be horribly disappointed in them.
The playlist features are great. It's smart about multiple displays, and can be configured in such a way that it always get's the right display...we have two different types of projector (one is 1920x1200 resolution the other is 1280x800), and VLC is the only player that can be configured to always open the video fullscreen on the projector and put the controls on the primary display. I can't say enough about how important this one is. It's incredibly configurable...it's kinda stupid how busy the display is, by default, and it can be a little tricky to find all of the various OSD options, but once the configuration is right, it's perfect. It looks as good as any player I have for nearly every format, including DVD and Blu-ray, so even if the client brings me a film the day of the event, I can pop it into a playlist and expect it to Just Work(tm) (with the exception of high res, lossless, ProRes, which has to be converted to a compressed mp4 or similar, first).
I've often considered making a custom version just for my kind of use case...it wouldn't take much to make it perfect for professional cinema usage (well, maybe there's the DCP question which I haven't researched lately), or at least for low and mid-range type cinema options, for indie film events and such. An automatic compression option for loading files that are in lossless formats, no glitch on switching between videos and images in a playlist (assuming the video mode doesn't have to change, the import step could normalize videos to one resolution and color depth, as well), and maybe some built-in auto-calibration options (with a video input). Would be amazing.
- jbk 12y ago> the glitch when switching between videos in a playlist is annoying as hell Are you sure those are still present?
- SwellJoe 12y agoNot entirely sure, as we haven't done any big video screenings since last summer (we mostly do outdoor screenings, and it's been too cold for that), and I haven't tried the new version, at all. But, it was an issue that was present for a long time, and I found a discussion on the mailing list from maybe three years ago when the problem first surfaced. Someone explained that it was an intentional change, but my understanding was that it was only supposed to happen when the video mode changed (i.e. to a different resolution or bit depth). But, we tested it extensively with videos that were identically processed (same container, same compression/encoding, same resolution, same color depth) and it would still glitch. We minimized its visibility by setting the background of the OS to black and hiding all icons and toolbars, which made it close enough to invisible that our clients never noticed it. But, I could spot it, and in an otherwise flawless and reliable experience it was always really annoying. I'll check the new version out as soon as I've got some free time. We'll need to prepare for the new summer season in a few weeks anyway (we're in Texas, where it gets warm early), and I've been planning to switch to running our videos off of a Linux system, instead of Windows, since I'm finally seeing acceptable audiovisual performance as of the past year or so.
- jbk 12y agoIf resolution (and even that) and mostly chroma are similar, VLC should recycle. If it does not, please file a bug. As for using Linux, try the OpenGL module, instead of the default.