3 ms·
It is hard for me to get riled up over a TLD. Haven't they been decreasing in relevancy for years, first with the growth of search engines and then again with
by slg 12y ago
It is hard for me to get riled up over a TLD. Haven't they been decreasing in relevancy for years, first with the growth of search engines and then again with the growth of social networks? No one really searches for sites anymore by typing random words with a .com at the end. At this point, I just don't see that much difference between controlling a specific domain or a top level domain. I would have no problem if Google bought app.com, so why should I care if they buy .app? There are countless other TLDs to use anyway.
- nvader 12y agoYou do get a boost to your search-engine result page rankings if your domain name matches the search term, for example. If your customers are searching for "find bee mortgages fast", then owning "findbeemortgagesfast.com" will be a valuable competitive advantage to your business.
- Jack000 12y agoeverything I've read suggests exact match domains have been declining in SEO-potential, I don't think they have any merit now in 2015. Google changes it's algo pretty frequently so it's hard to get a fix for what exactly works and what doesn't.
- strgrd 12y agoWell perhaps then you can get riled up about a nonprofit regulatory organization bending its own rules to serve the interests of The Biggest Fucking Company Ever? Downplaying this because you don't care isn't what the comment section is for. "I would have no problem if Google bought app.com, so why should I care if they buy .app?" I'm not even sure you understand what TLDs are. Perhaps you should Google it?
- narrowrail 12y ago>to serve the interests of The Biggest Fucking Company Ever Going by market cap, I thought that was Apple, no? Not that it really matters. Also, I doubt the parent commenter doesn't know what a TLD is, and it is kind of rude (and snarky) to write such things.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rabbyte 12y agoSo you're not bothered by this behavior because there are alternatives, but there are only alternatives because this behavior was previously rejected. The ease with which you would give control over public concepts to private institutions without restriction is terrifying to me.
- slg 12y agoIn what way is it a public concept and why is it a priority to keep it that way? I just don't see the real and non-technical difference between app.com and .app. We have gone from a world with a select set of TLDs to a world were almost anyone with a couple hundred thousand dollars can create their own TLDs. With that change, domains went from a relatively limited resource to an almost unlimited one. I think that allows us to be less dogmatic and loosen the rules on how they are managed. I am completely open to other opinions, but I would need a better reason than just appealing to the philosophical superiority of openness.
- astazangasta 12y agoThis is exactly how every commons is spoiled, by fencing it off into private lots, which is exactly what's being talked about here with DNS. It's akin to saying, "This portion of the electromagnetic spectrum is now private, and can only be used by Google."
- slg 12y agoExcept you are comparing a nearly limitless resource with a very finite one. If we are all about the common, why not force Google to allow me to register slg.google.com? How is that different than forcing Google to allow me to register slg.app?