6 ms·
Deleting Geocities was a horrifyingly destructive act by Yahoo. They took thousands of sites that had been built by other people and just deleted them all. And
by sp332 12y ago
Deleting Geocities was a horrifyingly destructive act by Yahoo. They took thousands of sites that had been built by other people and just deleted them all. And this isn't an isolated incident. The industry seems to think that taking gobs of user data and trashing it is fine, and it happens on a regular basis.
We need to change the culture of the tech industry to view users' data as belonging to the users. Until then, consider donating to the Internet Archive https://archive.org/donate/ https://archive.org/donate/
- yurymik 12y agoThat's an awful move by itself, but what I personally cannot get over is their decision to rick-roll every user who clicks on the outdated link. That simply insulting. Here's a random example: www.geocities.com/scythemantis
- tsomctl 12y agoWhat the fuck. They are literally rick-rolling people. And Yahoo is a publicly traded, supposedly reputable company. Also, I thought the Internet Archive was mirroring Geocities. Why don't they redirect people there, with a legal disclaimer, or just give the Internet Archive the domain name. There is so much additional baggage with the name, Yahoo could never reuse the name for something else.
- slg 12y agoYahoo gave plenty of warning and allowed users to export their data (I didn't use it so I can't say how complete or easy the export process actually was). What else would you like them to do, keep the sites up indefinitely?
- res0nat0r 12y agoAre they just supposed to keep the servers and infrastructure which costs them money running forever, no matter how unprofitable?
- calpaterson 12y agoI think the grandparent would argue that they shouldn't solicit user data unless they're prepared to pay reasonable costs of archival
- sp332 12y agoYou should tell your users upfront if you're going to delete their data. Something like "Upload your photos, share them with the world, then never see them again after a few years." https://web.archive.org/web/20140810180036/http://www.fotopedia.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20140810180036/http://www.fotope... That one was grabbed by the Archive Team, who gave the data to the Internet Archive so you can still browse it. 2TB of photos, information, discussion, nearly deleted forever. Edit: fixed link
- res0nat0r 12y agoAccording to this post it looks like they were given notice: http://www.businessinsider.com/yahoo-final-notice-geocities-is-closing-2009-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/yahoo-final-notice-geocities-... Generally shutting down a service means you won't have access to it and the data on it anymore.
- sp332 12y agoHaving notice is better than not having notice (like the AOL Hometown shutdown). But it's not an excuse. It's not your data. It would be one thing if you literally ran out of money, which Yahoo obviously didn't. And many startups that delete user data are "exiting" or "pivoting" and don't have that excuse either. In addition, you should be transparent with your users if it looks like they might lose their data in the forseeable future.
- 12y ago
- lelandbatey 12y agoThis series of concerns is close to my heart. Some time ago, I built a toy site that lets people make Gifs out of YouTube videos[0]. I put no limits on the service since I'm lazy and limits would have required extra work. This means there's no limit on the size of gifs created, nor any limit on their length. Additionally, a user can make as many gifs as they like. I think one can imagine where this is going. Since it's inception, people have made tens of thousands of gifs, and now I have hundreds of gigabytes of gifs I have to host. Recently, to save space I had to go through and delete pretty much all the gifs that had been created before a particular time. I downloaded them to my personal computer to ensure that some record of them remains, but still, I potentially broke tens of thousands of links. In the future, I'll be putting all sorts of limits on user creations, but I'm curious how bad action like this is? [0] - http://gifmachine.xwl.me/ http://gifmachine.xwl.me/
- sp332 12y agoYou could join #archiveteam-bs on efnet and talk about it? Also if you want to send me a copy, my email is in my profile :)
- lelandbatey 12y agoActually, I'd love to!
- brandon272 12y agoI have cherished, fun and nostalgic memories of learning HTML as a kid and building sites on GeoCities. It seemed so amazing at the time. Breaks my heart to think back on it and know that it's all been deleted.
- astazangasta 12y agoPlenty of people archived Geocities; if you google for it you can find a couple. A friend of mine made some effort to do this, I don't know if his version is still up, but I'm sure he has the tarball somewhere.
- sp332 12y agoPlenty of people got partial grabs of Geocities. No one knows how much was lost. This is the most complete single collection I know of, pieced together from several people. https://thepiratebay.se/torrent/6353395/Geocities_-_The_PATCHED_Torrent https://thepiratebay.se/torrent/6353395/Geocities_-_The_PATC... If you just want to browse, Reocities is probably the best interface. http://reocities.com/neighborhoods/ http://reocities.com/neighborhoods/