3 ms·
"Now there’s a licensing exam for software engineering, although I don’t know how many states currently accept it. Each state has its own rules for the licensin
by mcguire 12y ago
"Now there’s a licensing exam for software engineering, although I don’t know how many states currently accept it. Each state has its own rules for the licensing of professional engineers, and some of those rules would probably have to be altered to allow programmers to get licensed, even with the availability of an exam.
"(I am, by the way, curious what programmers think of the topics covered by the exam[1].)"
Speaking a professional programmer for the last 25 years, my take on the topics is that they heavily over-represent things about software development and are rather thin on actually doing software development. I would really, really, like to see a similar document for mechanical or civil engineering.
A while back, I wrote some notes[2][3] for the references to the IEEE Computer Society's Software Engineering Body of Knowledge (SWEBOK), which I think is the basis of the exams.
As for engineering ethics in software development, I personally would be overjoyed if we followed even the old-school system[4].
[1] https://cdn.ncees.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SWE-Apr-2013.pdf https://cdn.ncees.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SWE-Apr-201...
[2] http://maniagnosis.crsr.net/2011/11/consolidated-reference-list-for-ieee.html http://maniagnosis.crsr.net/2011/11/consolidated-reference-l...
[3] http://maniagnosis.crsr.net/2011/11/consolidated-reference-list-for.html http://maniagnosis.crsr.net/2011/11/consolidated-reference-l...
[4] "Thou shalt not compete with another engineer on the basis of price."
- krschultz 12y agoI passed the FE exam in the mechanical engineering field, and I'm considering getting a PE in software. I have the same feeling you have that this test seems like it is tangentially related to software. The mechanical engineering exam tests your knowledge of the various sub-topics within the field. It covered thermodynamics, dynamics, fluids, vibration & control, heat transfer, etc. In addition to that there was a section on ethics, and a short bit on accounting/economics. I had imagined a software engineering exam might have sections such as algorithms, data structures, concurrency, cryptography/security, etc. Basically it should prove that you have a complete, broad, knowledge of the field. The questions in each subject matter are not particularly hard, but I can be sure someone that passed the mechanical engineering FE has a basic understanding of every topic covered in a bachelors degree.
- tjl 12y agoWas there a section on engineering law? In Canada, you don't need to take a topic exam if you go to an accredited program (as they audit the accredited programs regularly to ensure the programs cover the material sufficiently), but you do have to take an engineering law and ethics exam (at least in Ontario). However, a guy sitting in front of me when I took the exam was caught cheating (not very ethical). You then need to have 48 months of experience and they need to include things like leadership experience in addition to just domain expertise. It then is sent to a committee which decides if your experience meets all the criteria.