4 ms·
> You can transport value across the world instantly, with no intermediaries. This is a major efficiency gain. Only in a fictional world where my employer/clie
by Someone1234 12y ago
> You can transport value across the world instantly, with no intermediaries. This is a major efficiency gain.
Only in a fictional world where my employer/clients pay me in bitcoin.
In reality I need to go to an exchange, convert to bitcoin, then go back to either the same exchange or a different exchange and convert from bitcoin, all in all I've gone through two intermediaries and paid two fees.
For one example if I did that on CoinMill they would charge me $2.59 over market for 1 bitcoin ($252~254 in value) and the same again when I convert it back to dollars. $5.18, that's approx. a 2% transaction fee. TransferWise by contrast (who really are super hassle free) charge $2.88 for one end-to-end transaction, so less than bitcoin(!).
So yeah, your argument is completely broken in the real world. Only in a fictional world where everyone uses bitcoin does it work.
- moe 12y agoOnly in a fictional world where everyone uses bitcoin does it work. Why "everyone"? Wouldn't it be enough if a shop that has something that you want to buy accepts it? There's a great many shops accepting Bitcoin today already.
- Someone1234 12y agoStill costs me $2.59 to transfer into bitcoin even in that scenario. Certainly doesn't result in: > You can transport value across the world instantly, with no intermediaries. This is a major efficiency gain. Since (A) there is an intermediary and (B) it is not efficiency (which I'm assuming is a euphemism for cheap anyway).
- moe 12y agoI think you are unfairly generalising from your personal use-case. Efficiency can also mean "time" or "being able to do it at all". There's scenarios where TransferWise, MoneyGram, WesternUnion etc. either don't work or ask for extremely high fees. It can also be simply inconvenient to go to the physical pick up locations of MG/WU. Keep in mind most people in the world are not blessed with 3 different banks and a starbucks within walking distance.
- aminok 12y ago>In reality I need to go to an exchange, convert to bitcoin, then go back to either the same exchange or a different exchange and convert from bitcoin, all in all I've gone through two intermediaries and paid two fees. The intermediaries are domestic exchanges in this case, meaning only domestic transfers of fiat need to be made. The international transfer occurs through Bitcoin. Fees for large Bitcoin exchanges range from 0.25% (Bitstamp) to 0.38% (BTCChina). Coinbase currently has no fees, but it's a temporary promotion. That means it's less than 0.8% in trading fees altogether, when using major exchanges. Assuming Bitcoin becomes a little more widely adopted, this situation will only get better. I think the real opportunity is in the back end of the financial system. Banks can begin to use Bitcoin for international wire transfers, while enjoying much lower trading fees than retail clients when converting into and out of fiat currencies.
- grubles 12y agoYour fictional world exists already. A couple examples: [0][1]. [0]http://www.coindesk.com/companies-paying-employees-bitcoin/ http://www.coindesk.com/companies-paying-employees-bitcoin/ [1]http://rt.com/usa/vicco-kentucky-bitcoin-salary-725/ http://rt.com/usa/vicco-kentucky-bitcoin-salary-725/