11 ms·
Dear FCC: Thanks for Listening to Team Internet
- jasonjei 12y agoEven better, the rules will apply to wireless and wired broadband in the same way, so you don’t have to worry that your phone switching from Wi-Fi to a 4G network will suddenly cause apps not to work or websites to become inaccessible. Lots of people use mobile devices as their primary way of accessing the Internet, so applying net neutrality rules to both equally will help make sure there is “one Internet” for all. Does this mean Apple cannot enforce "must use over wifi restrictions"? As it stands now, I can't use LTE to download large apps, media, or stream on the iPhone or iPad. Would the FCC have any authority to force Apple to change these restrictions?
- cloudwalking 12y agoI hope so.
- tragic 12y agoPresumably it would apply only to your LTE carrier, not built-in device limitations. That is a very weird thing for Apple to build in to a phone/tablet though...
- Already__Taken 12y agoThat to me sounds like a decision apple made to protect all users from some massive LTE bill. Most people are already very paranoid their phone is going to rack up some huge bill without them noticing.
- tragic 12y agoI can't think of any other reason, but it should at least be optional, as it often is even at the app level - Spotify lets me choose whether to stream on 4G and even set a different quality setting. On Android, updates only happen automatically on wifi, but I can manually apply them on a data connection if I want. Unless it's a customisation as part of some deal with the carriers. I understand that this sort of thing is common in the States.
- mikeash 12y agoApple's philosophy is generally not to expose a setting when a good default will satisfy 90% of the users. For something like this, where most people should have it disabled (being clueless about app sizes and data uses) and some power users might enable it, but clueless people will enable it and then complain about it, Apple will typically not make it configurable. Not that I agree with their position, but that seems to be their approach.
- randomfool 12y agoJust wait for Comcast et al to tell us that implementing NN requires metered billing.
- lost_name 12y agoIt might just be leftover from the early days of the iPhone, where AT&T, the original carrier of the iPhone in the states, complained about network congestion and bandwidth issues in highly populated areas. I would think that AT&T may have asked Apple for some sort of limitation on non-essential services like this.
- gojomo 12y agoThere is less competition in smartphone OSes (2 dominant providers) than in most localities' high-speed internet (2 wired and 3+ wireless providers). So the same market-power rationales used for FCC regulation of ISPs could be used to justify strong federal regulation of the Apple & Google platforms.
- mikeash 12y agoThere's a major difference in that I can easily use a non-dominant smartphone OS if I want to, but if some ISP doesn't cover my area, I can't use them no matter how much I might want to. You're not necessarily wrong, but it's not quite the same.
- rhino369 12y agoApp and data neutrality should be next. Apple shouldn't be able to monetize the phone they already sold me by extorting 30% of all apps I buy. Google shouldn't be able to horde all the data. Make google a dumb pagerank index!
- biftek 12y agoIs this something Apple actually controls or is it tied in with the carriers? I seem to recall my old grandfathered unlimited plan on Verizon letting me download anything when ever.
- jasonjei 12y agoIt seems to be a software limitation. On an iPhone, if you try to download a movie from the iTunes app, you'll be prompted to switch to wifi--the download won't proceed. It isn't tied to carrier, I think, but at the iOS level.
- tashoecraft 12y agoIt's so careless users don't burn through their data plan in 3 minutes by downloading a multi gb app and movie. It's a safety net because the high majority of users do not have unlimited data plans. At least this is how I always interpreted this rule. I don't think that is what that rule does. It is mainly to protect the user who downloads an app to still be able to use it if they are on wifi and 4G, even if the app maker didn't pay to have "special access" to the 4G network that month.
- ethana 12y ago"But now we face the really hard part: making sure the FCC doesn’t abuse its authority." I just feel that the EFF didn't do a thorough check this time around. Also, the decision was made at 10AM and they still haven't release the 200+ pages ruling document. It's most likely that this will head back to federal court and the process will get more complicated and lengthy before the dust settle.
- couchand 12y agoWow, you're all over the place with this comment. EFF didn't do a through check? What did they miss? The "decision" made at 10AM was to adopt the rules that have been under public comment for months. If you haven't seen them yet, it's your own fault. Yes this will go to court. Do you expect any better from America?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- jamoes 12y ago> The "decision" made at 10AM was to adopt the rules that have been under public comment for months. If you haven't seen them yet, it's your own fault. From what I've read, the 322 page document wasn't released as of 3 days ago [1]. I'm not sure about the claim that it still hasn't been released, but regardless - the rules weren't really available for public review before the vote. [1] http://dailycaller.com/2015/02/23/republican-fcc-commissioners-ask-wheeler-to-delay-net-neutrality-vote-release-proposal/ http://dailycaller.com/2015/02/23/republican-fcc-commissione...
- warfangle 12y agoThe NPRM was published in May. If it had gone through another comment phase, it would have taken another 9 months... And then another nine months...
- godgod 12y ago"But now we face the really hard part: making sure the FCC doesn’t abuse its authority." This is my fear. We're celebrating government interference and more regulation. It may feel good now but beware. Now that the internet is under FCC rule, they can and will abuse it this power in a negative way. Mark my words. Also when do the peasants get to view the 332 pages hidden from public view?
- qwerty85344324 12y agoDoesn't Team Internet include Cisco, Intel, Broadcom, Qualcomm, and IBM, and other tech companies who came out against the NN regulations that were passed yesterday? Or does Team Internet just include Tumblr and Etsy?
- venomsnake 12y agoAll those are hardware companies if you notice.
- bhauer 12y agoHardware companies are involved in making the Internet work.
- danielweber 12y agoYeah, but they aren't cool like a car-sharing network. This reminds me of the power grid discussion on HN, where the cool thing is hooking up independent solar arrays, and the boring thing is running the existing grid that we depend on for life. Now, having your house connected to both the grid and your personal backup makes jobs more dangerous for linemen -- already one of the top ten most dangerous jobs in the country. That was waved away with "well, if I were working on power lines, I would just assume they were always live anyway" by people who have never had an outdoors job, and whose entry-level salaries are where linemen top off at the end of a career. People have abstracted away how much work it takes to keep society running. For the most part that is okay, because it gives them more time to specialize in their chosen field, but then they think because something has been abstracted away that it's easy to make some "minor change" without knowledge of the cost either in dollars or in lives.
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> Now, having your house connected to both the grid and your personal backup makes jobs more dangerous for linemen -- already one of the top ten most dangerous jobs in the country. That was waved away with "well, if I were working on power lines, I would just assume they were always live anyway" by people who have never had an outdoors job, and whose entry-level salaries are where linemen top off at the end of a career. Any home inverter that feeds power back to the utility is required by code to island itself when it detects a loss of utility power. Also, I have a close friend who is a lineman, and has worked in every state between Illinois and New York. He says (over the beer we're having right now) that all lineman assume lines to be live, and they routinely perform service on hot lines without removing power. Its not the newest fad we're after; we're excited by any prospect of the status quo shifting. History shows us technology getting cheaper and better at a constantly faster rate (I won't say exponential, but close enough). This is where the excitement comes from, perpetual destruction and creation with a higher quality of life the continual result.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- 300bps 12y agoAs a fiscally conservative technology person who got my first modem in 1985, I could simultaneously not be happier with how things turned out with the FCC and horrified how fellow conservatives seem to interpret it. It is disheartening how much FUD is being spread by conservatives on the anti-NN side.
- madman86 12y agoFUD seems to be their selling point for just about every policy...
- rayiner 12y agoWhy do you dismiss the anti-NN concerns as FUD? Conservatives are worried about what impact NN will have on infrastructure investment, and the fact that reclassification gets us one step closer to rate setting, etc, and other powers under Title II. Both concerns are more "real," more rooted in actual observable practice, than the specter raised by the pro-NN people of a tiered, pay-for-pay internet. The incentive concern is real. What incentive will telecom companies have to build the wireline networks that enable next-generation of web services if they can't make enough money to justify the investment? The liberal response to this point is either myth or fantasy. Myth, in that they assume that wireline is insanely profitable, and that fat Verizon shareholders will just have to squeeze their belts a bit. In reality, the operating margin of Verizon's wireline division is 2-3%.[1] Fantasy, because they alternatively posit that municipal systems will take up the slack. How states and cities that are broke, crushed under liberal public union pension obligations, will pay for these municipal networks is up in the air. The worry of further regulation is also real. Telecom is already a morass of regulation, largely to fulfill liberal concerns. For example, there is already rate-setting. Municipal governments require cable companies to offer basic cable at low regulated rates. Since it doesn't cost appreciably less to offer basic cable than more expensive packages, this sets an important constraint on the economics of the network. Huge amounts of wealth transfer from urban to rural areas are already baked into the system at the federal and state levels. And build-out restrictions, preventing upstart competitors from stealing away lucrative tracts of incumbants' service areas, are already stifling competition. The HN crowd acts like NN is being added on top of an otherwise pristine regulatory regime, but in reality it's just one more straw on a giant pile of hay. None of this is FUD. The fact that these points are also raised by the telecom companies, who have a monetary interest in avoiding NN, does not make them FUD any more than the pro-NN points are FUD because they're raised by web-tech companies. I'm not an ideologue. I'd be fine with, for example, the U.K. approach. But what that would mean, which most people on HN don't know, would be putting AT&T back together and letting them enjoy monopoly profits. Take a look at BT Openreach's financials sometime: http://www.digitallook.com/news/news-and-announcements/retail-and-openreach-stand-out-at-bt-margins-rise--update--dl20468319.html http://www.digitallook.com/news/news-and-announcements/retai.... Their EBITDA margin is a staggering 45%, double that of Verizon wireline, significantly higher than Comcast's whole operation, and higher than AT&T and Verizon's wireless divisions. [1] http://www.verizonwireless.com/news/article/2012/01/pr2012-01-24.html http://www.verizonwireless.com/news/article/2012/01/pr2012-0....
- joelgrus 12y ago"We won! A free tiger! But now we face the really hard part: making sure the tiger doesn't eat us."
- hexis 12y agoTIL if you've run a bootstrapped web business for ten years, but didn't support Net Neutrality, you've just been kicked off Team Internet.
- danielweber 12y agoDidn't you vote in the election that gave the EFF the right to speak for us?
- programmarchy 12y agoRegulation has a history of locking in incumbents, and locking out potential future competitors. It will be much harder for challengers to enter the market now because of the increased cost of compliance, something only the big incumbents can afford. What's worse is that the costs for Title II companies will be subsidized by government. So they may appear to have low prices, at least for awhile, but the real price will be hidden in a nebulous cloud of federal taxes. You won't even really know how much you're actually paying due to price distortions caused by corporate welfare. It's sad that people have such a short term memory about these corporate welfare cons, and just fall in lockstep with the propaganda. This will be very bad for consumers in the long run.
- bougiefever 12y agoNothing but FUD. This is a huge win for consumers.
- xname 12y agoIf ISPs lose, consumers cannot win.
- TheCowboy 12y agoWould you mind supporting your statement by explaining how this actually applies here? It comes across as generic anti-regulation-no-matter-what astroturfing, but would be more interesting if the details of your argument were fleshed out.
- programmarchy 12y agoWhat details would you like me to flesh out? Maybe I can offer an example. I'm sure you will be able to poke technical holes in this, but let's say a company comes up with a new technology (i.e. not cable) that can handle small packets very efficiently in a small locality. It's super cheap to do this, and it's great for networking small communities. But, video traffic really slows down the network so it's filtered out and thus it can't effectively treat all data equally. Instead of being able to quickly start up and offer their services, first they have to register with the FCC. Then they have to pay an inspection fee, and account for yearly audit fees. Plus, even though their prices are cheap, they're not much cheaper than cable because all the cable infrastructure is subsidized by taxpayers so their prices appear to be less competitive. All these extra costs to comply with the regulations add up to the point where the capital needed to even start this business is way too high and way too risky, so this technology just won't even have a chance of existing. It is effectively crowded out by the heavily subsidized and protected cable telecoms. For a real historical reference, take the railroads for example, where these types of regulations began. The railroad businesses got huge subsidies from the government in the form of land and tax breaks. This allowed the railroad companies to effectively cartelize the industry because it crowded out more decentralized forms of transportation like the small rail and networks of canal systems. Even though these localized, less capital intensive systems could have served people better than railroads, we'll never know it because of the opportunity cost of central planning: the railroads used the state to force the public to pay for and subsidize their infrastructure. These crowding out effects are the unseen consequences of regulation. Big business has a long history of using the power of the state to impose regulatory barriers on future competitors as a way to preserve their monopoly power. It started with the railroads, continued through the Progressive Era, and continues today with policies like "Net Neutrality". And they always use the same public relations con, too, appealing to the common good and fairness to get public buy in. They say that these policies will protect the consumers, but really in the end these policies will protect big business from competition. This creates artificial scarcity and allows big business to charge consumers higher prices. See my other post here [1] if you want a little more historical background on how this works. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8998958
- bougiefever 12y agoOne of the immediate benefits for consumers is that companies can no longer block tethering apps on your phone or make you pay an additional fee for it. Sprint wanted me to pay an extra $30/mo when I was with them to be able to tether. Of course, I just rooted my phone and tethered anyway. (now I have Ting -- so much better)
- programmarchy 12y agoYou'll still be paying for this, except it will be through federal taxes for corporate subsidies instead of a bill, so you won't know the real price. Usually things you pay for indirectly are much more expensive than they would be if you paid for them directly, so you'll probably be paying more in the end.