4 ms·
I’m so confused. Is it people looking at the dress in person that think it looks white? Someone looking at this photo on a reasonably standard (or reasonably w
by jacobolus 12y ago
I’m so confused. Is it people looking at the dress in person that think it looks white?
Someone looking at this photo on a reasonably standard (or reasonably well characterized) LCD display which their eyes have adapted to is going to pretty much see all of the three versions falling between “pale blue” and “dark blue”. Given the yellow background, proper “white balance” would make the dress look even bluer (see example below). Either way, seems like the photo was taken with a pretty bad-quality cellphone camera. Maybe people have just learned to predict color in pictures from some specific cellphone cameras with awful sensors and processing? Or maybe someone spent 20 minutes staring at something bright blue, and then switched quickly to looking at the photo?
What am I missing here? Does anyone here think the image makes the dress look white?
(Also, there’s not much “science” in this wired post at all. Edit: in response to the below comment, the businessinsider post is also pretty shoddy “science”.)
Edit:
One of the nicest online sources about this topic is http://handprint.com/HP/WCL/color4.html#chromainduct http://handprint.com/HP/WCL/color4.html#chromainduct ; the rest of that site is in general the best online source about human color vision. (There are better sources, but you’ll need to go to a university library to read them.)
I wouldn’t claim to be a professional color scientist, but I’m about as much an expert on this topic as you’ll ever find among amateurs. If someone wants a 3-hour lecture in person about the science of human color vision, I’d be happy to oblige (but you have to come to an SF coffeeshop for it; could also be a shorter or longer lecture, depending).
Here’s the original image vs. one I “white balanced” to make the obviously white & black dress in the background appear neutral. Does the foreground dress still look white + gold?
orig: http://i.imgur.com/g461GBr.jpg http://i.imgur.com/g461GBr.jpg
; white balanced: http://i.imgur.com/jtjECtR.jpg http://i.imgur.com/jtjECtR.jpg
(and I actually cheated a bit toward leaving the blue less intense than I would typically make it if color correcting this image)
In any event, I still can’t explain why people are seeing this dress as white. I now think that it’s likely to be unfamiliarity looking at digital photographs and/or some weird adaptation effect, e.g. looking at a dim phone screen while outside in the shade on a sunny day. Or maybe perception is being colored by a general expectation of white dresses (people often substitute colors in this way when they look at e.g. fire hydrants, human skin, clouds, or grass, interpreting the color based on past experience despite weird lighting conditions).
- callmeed 12y agoYes, to me the dress looks gold and white. Granted, we're looking at a side of the dress which is in shade (thus there's a tint). But, in my mind, the dress is clearly white and gold. My wife, on the other hand, first saw it as blue and black. Later it seemed to change for her.
- mod 12y agoThat's strange, the 20-or-so people I've read that had it changed all had it change in the other direction--white & gold first, then blue & black later. FWIW I read that the real dress, as observed in person, is blue & black. EDIT: Girlfriend reverted. If nothing else, this is good for a giggle.
- peteretep 12y agoHere's the real dress, from the supplier's image of it: http://s3-ec.buzzfed.com/static/2015-02/26/22/enhanced/webdr02/enhanced-1984-1425006448-3.jpg http://s3-ec.buzzfed.com/static/2015-02/26/22/enhanced/webdr...
- mod 12y agoI think this is supposed to be another picture of the actual, specific dress in question: http://media.tumblr.com/ec387ec0bb03230268a9e905d74097d9/tumblr_inline_nkeezsjAuH1svicb3.jpg http://media.tumblr.com/ec387ec0bb03230268a9e905d74097d9/tum...
- jacobolus 12y agoThe only way you’d get a “tint” like this on a white dress in the shade, indoors, in a room with yellowish lighting (look at the background) is if you shone a bright blue spotlight at it.
- koliber 12y agoIn real life, you are right. However, this picture was taken with a camera, which did some auto white balancing internally. Perhaps the camera chose to use the yellow background as the reference for white-balancing, causing the less "white" dress a bluish tint. You cannot just consider the natural image here. I am sure that if we got everyone to examine the dress in real life, there would be a lot less confusion. I bet a good part of the confusion is caused by faulty in-camera white balancing.