4 ms·
Light is weird! Here’s an essay from a dilettante with too much time spent in Lightroom… Everyone (including the Wired people in the submitted article here: ht
by majormajor 12y ago
Light is weird! Here’s an essay from a dilettante with too much time spent in Lightroom…
Everyone (including the Wired people in the submitted article here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9117137 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9117137) seems to be trying to white-balance the image as if it has only a single light source. "He saw blue in the highlights, telling him that the white he was seeing was blue, and the gold was black. And when Harris reversed the process, balancing to the darkest pixel in the image, the dress popped blue and black. “It became clear that the appropriate point in the image to balance from is the black point,” Harris says."
I don't understand why. The blown out highlights of the background (which seems to be people carrying bags outside a window?) seem to make it clear that whatever's hitting the dress is a different light than what's filling in the background.
The hardest question I feel remains, then, is: if the dress is white, why is the foreground light blue-cast? Generally indoor lighting is yellow than outdoors... possibly a flash? The quality of the image is so poor that it appears that there was still not nearly enough light hitting the front of the dress, but on the other hand I don't spot anything on the front of the dress that I'd say was definitely a flash highlight... my best theory is that it's a 100% crop of a bigger image and the flash isn't sufficient because the photographer was actually quite a bit further away (and had a poor camera/cameraphone).
But that light temperature question is a problem the other way too: if it's a blue dress under warm indoor lighting (hence the yellow/gold-ish tinge to the 'black' parts), what's up with the particular shade of blue the light part of the dress is rendering as? That doesn’t look like blue in warm light to me. That's a really weird shade for blue to render as, I see that shade far more often when looking at white objects in cool light.
People also tracked down (don't have original source, just people reposting on Facebook) this site which sells a very-similar-if-not-exactly-the-same dress in both a blue and white variant (hard to be sure of the details with the poor quality of the original pic)! But neither secondary color (seems to be untinted black in both cases): http://www.romanoriginals.co.uk/invt/70931?colour=Ivory http://www.romanoriginals.co.uk/invt/70931?colour=Ivory - and in none of the “corrected” blue images I’ve seen does it look like that shade of blue, without clearly crushed shadow detail indicating underexposure. But if that is exactly the same dress, than I honestly can’t say, since there are weird things about both color rendering options! (Why wouldn't the dark lace be blue-cast too? Alternately, why is the blue less gold-cast than the lace if the dress is really blue?)
EDIT: another option for how the exposure got so weird in a blue-dress scenario: there could be another item in the hypothetical uncropped original photo that is not overexposed that explains how both the dress and the background are overexposed? If just the dress was the original subject of this photo I'm surprised by how poorly the camera picked the exposure/white-balance.
- mmastrac 12y agoI created the blue image myself by guessing at the color of light that was hitting the image and subtracting it using GIMP (#524922 FWIW). It's not entirely scientific, but the resulting blues match very closely to the picture of the dress on Amazon [1], despite the image feeling a bit too dark. [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Roman-Womens-Detail-Bodycon-Dress/dp/B00SJEUCWU http://www.amazon.co.uk/Roman-Womens-Detail-Bodycon-Dress/dp...
- majormajor 12y agoThe yellow one in your simulation is the one I feel is off, and was referring to with the blue removal. That's not how I perceive it when doing my mental white-balancing attempt (and I can't speak to how blue-dressers perceive it originally). I see that the pixels are light blue, but assume that the material is white. Lightroom does a much more convincing blue-cast removal -- looks pretty similar to this, where the gold is preserved but the white doesn't become yellow: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B-0WdySWwAEqiDR.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B-0WdySWwAEqiDR.jpg (I would upload my version from lightroom, but I didn't bother to save it and I've spent far too much time on this subject for one night :) ).
- mmastrac 12y agoI'll see if I can figure out a good color to subtract to get a better yellow one. IIRC, it was cribbed from one of the news articles on this that showed up tonight, but I'm not sure which one. EDIT: I'm thinking that the right move might be adding #392c00 (rather than subtracting!).. And I've updated the final image with that instead of the one from before.
- tofof 12y agoIt is clearly the ivory dress; the negative and positive of the original image will show nearly the same colors simply swapping places ('gold' stripes become 'white' and vice-versa) which is only possible if the two colors are opposite each other. Black and blue are not. Black and near-white are.