11 ms·
There are two problems, and the FCC has solved one of them perfectly. Problem 1: ISPs trying to charge to (de)prioritize packets. Problem 2: The two biggest I
by grecy 12y ago
There are two problems, and the FCC has solved one of them perfectly.
Problem 1: ISPs trying to charge to (de)prioritize packets.
Problem 2: The two biggest ISPs suck, and should be broken up, and/or it should be mandated that competition is much easier.
Would you be happy if they solved problem 2 without solving problem 1?
Leave problem 2 for another day, and celebrate that problem 1 has been dealt with.
- bduerst 12y agoTotally agree. We can harp on the FCC for their performance with a wide range of issues, but at least here we have them [finally] taking action on one of them.
- chaostheory 12y agoWouldn't drastically increased competition solve problem one over time?
- codyb 12y agoPossibly but it hinges a lot on drastically increased in an often prohibitively expensive commercial sector and it would take a lot longer than enforcing one, and then encouraging competition to bring speeds up and overall cost of bandwidth down for consumers. And there's been lots of no compete agreements among these ISPs and I'm sure there's other examples out there where the "competition" makes it better for all of them at the expense of consumers.
- chaostheory 12y agowell there was one attempt by Clinton to have the gov fund increased capacity... and the telecoms just ended up taking the money without doing anything http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/2007/pulpit_20070810_002683.html http://www.pbs.org/cringely/pulpit/2007/pulpit_20070810_0026... I believe the Obama admin tried it again. I don't know the full result, but I wouldn't be surprised if the same thing happened.
- bduerst 12y agoOriginally the answer is No, because shaping reduces costs for overburdened (older) networks, and these these are infrastructure-heavy regional markets so the entry cost is already very high for competition. But then you have companies like Google who can come in an put in Fiber because they're a tech conglomerate who can subsidize these costs in other ways.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Anderkent 12y agoProbably not; ISPs don't do traffic shaping because they're evil, they do it because it saves them money. The average customer probably cares more about the price of their broadband and the big number in front of it, not whether they get full utilization.
- xiata 12y agoThis is a bad assumption that any new competition would act differently than the status quo. More competitors would make it harder to have a solid argument of "pay me, or else", but that wouldn't stop some behind-the-scenes collusion.
- plaguuuuuu 12y ago'Competition' isn't the panacea solving all problems that some make it out to be.
- yarou 12y agoNo, because telecom specifically has very high barriers to entry (infrastructure, licensing, etc).
- tlb 12y agoQuite possibly the opposite: new entrants wouldn't try to compete on general-purpose internet service but would deploy a service that's cheap because it's sponsored by large content providers, and those content providers would get preferential treatment.
- smokinjoe 12y agoOh wow, that's a great point. I've always tried to compromise with opponents by agreeing that increased competition should alleviate many of my fears but now that you've mentioned it - I could absolutely see a HULU.net come in, sponsored by various content creators.
- cubano 12y agoBut perhaps that price is all they could afford, and in that case, something is a lot better than nothing.
- abalone 12y agoNot necessarily. Consumers would prefer the probable lower prices of tiered services. Yet in the long run this would hurt consumers by throwing up barriers to startups and competition among internet services. This is an example of how markets favor short-term interests (lower ISP prices) over long-term. Another example: advertising-subsidized media. Used to be (100 years ago) newspapers didn't necessarily runs ads. There was a rich working-class press. Then the ad-subsidized model came out and it slashed the price of newspapers, but on the condition that the content was generally business friendly. (Otherwise they wouldn't get many advertisers.) So nobody bought the working-class newspapers anymore because they were too expensive. This had a massive impact on the tone and perspective of published media that persists to this day.
- bobbles 12y agoThe headline could say that world hunger was cured but the top comment on HN would still be something like "yes, but X people are still dying in car crashes every year"
- ChrisAntaki 12y agoThere does seem to be a bias towards overly worded critical comments.
- brink 12y agoI like reading the counter argument so that I can feel like I looked at both sides of the matter. What can I say?
- ertdfgcb 12y agoI think at least part of it is because the people on HN enjoy solving problems so much. When there's a post that says "we solved this problem", a lot of people here (me included) think "great, what's the next problem to solve". The focus is on "the next problem to solve" more than the "great", sometimes to the degree that the "great" is completely ignored. I don't think this is necessarily a bad thing, but it can get grating. It reminds me a lot of a part of the essay "How to ask questions the smart way"[0] by Eric Raymond: > Much of what looks like rudeness in hacker circles is not intended to give offence. Rather, it's the product of the direct, cut-through-the-bullshit communications style that is natural to people who are more concerned about solving problems than making others feel warm and fuzzy It's not quite the same, but it comes from the same cut-through-the-bullshit attitude. [0]: http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html
- nsxwolf 12y agoDid problem 1 really need 700 distinct new regulations to be solved?
- dragonwriter 12y agoI have yet to see any basis for the "700 distinct new regulations" claim, and given the parallel claim, often from the same posters, that the Order is only on the order of 300 pages, find "700 distinct new regulations" to be highly suspicious, and suspect that if it is even loosely tied to fact, its tied to a count of the number of numbered sections, not the number of things that are in any sense distinct regulations.
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI suspect this is a reference to the number of regulations that current apply to other entities regulated under Title II. Of course, there is more than one category of entity under Title II, each of which faces a different regulatory burden. Broadband ISPs are sure to be yet another category, with different regulatory burdens. In fact we know this, because the FCC has been quite clear that it will use its authority to "forbear" from subjecting broadband ISPs to many of the requirements that typically apply under Title II. So you're exactly right: there is no support for the "700 regulations." It's total nonsense.
- jcrawfordor 12y agoAs far as I can tell, the 700 regulations is complete nonsense from people who did not read the release thoroughly. I have the news release sitting right in front of me, and on the 3rd page under the heading "Legal Authority:..." it says: "the Order refrains - or forbears - from enforcing 27 provisions of Title II and over 700 associated regulations that are not relevant to modern broadband service." That's your over 700 right there. This is the only place that I can find that number anywhere. The people who are talking abuot "over 700 new regulations" are party to a misunderstanding of hilarious proportion, making it clear that they have not RTF(news release).
- guelo 12y ago
- alexqgb 12y agoWorth noting: the FCC also struck down laws in two states that had barred municipalities from setting up their own broadband networks. The widely covered ruling (Title II) stops the major ISPs from getting worse. The less noticed ruling is what will put the screws to their executives, and make them actually perform. For their customers, I mean. More on the muni. ruling here: http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2015/02/fcc-did-lot-more-just-approve-net-neutrality-today http://www.motherjones.com/kevin-drum/2015/02/fcc-did-lot-mo...
- randyrand 12y agoBut it's almost a catch-22. To solve problem 2 after solving problem 1 with regulation, you have to introduce more regulations. As a general rule of thumb, the more regulations you introduce, the more lobbying is used to stifle competition. The companies get in bed with the government, time and time again. Were now increasingly dependent on the goverment for internet progross. That's not what we want. We want progress to be a freebie. A natural by product of real competition. We've effectively gave up on the pure solution, and elected for the long politically complicated "government mandated progress" solution. History shows it's unlikely to end up in our favor in the long run. Damnit.
- BorisMelnik 12y ago...I'd be so happy if we could just cut through all the political tape and see Google Fiber come into our neighborhoods
- MarkMc 12y agoIf Problem 2 is solved, I don't see why Problem 1 is any more of a problem than allowing FedEx and UPS to charge different prices to different customers.
- webXL 12y ago> ISPs trying to charge to (de)prioritize packets I'm still not getting it. Isn't this like saying restaurants are charging to provide more flavorful, healthier food? The cost burden may appear to fall on the suppliers in the ISP case, but they just pass that onto the consumer, just like the price you see next to the menu item. Problem 1 only appears to be a problem because of problem 2. It's a competition issue. Are we really closer to solving problem 2 now? How so?
- Golf_Hotel_Mike 12y agoBut there already is legislation in place to deal with problem 2. Antitrust law exists and has been successfully used in the past. If the political will is created it could be used just as well against the ISP duopoly. Problem 1 on the other hand is a brand new problem that is peculiar to the medium of the internet. Unless the legal framework for it is laid down as early as possible, the service will always be vulnerable to political agendas. Simply put, net neutrality legislation is essential for the future of the internet, while shitty competition is a temporary problem that can be solved. We're already seeing progress (albeit very minor progress) in solving problem 2. The entry of Google Fiber in the market is more significant than most people realize, because it shows that companies that rely on efficient internet service for their revenue are willing to expand into ISP roles in order to ensure reach to customers. Who's to say that Apple, a massive corporation with deep pockets that lives and breathes user experience, won't invest in ensuring that their customers have the best experience with the internet possible? Call me optimistic, but I don't think the ISP duopoly in is going to last forever. The stakes are just too high for other large companies to not enter into the field. Eventually, I believe we'll see a bunch of walled gardens ISPs instead of the current duopoly, with Apple, Google and maybe even someone like Facebook acting as ISPs for their own subset of customers. When that does happen, we need to make sure that the playing field for all websites stays level and independent of economic or political interests. Strict net neutrality laws are exactly what we need in a situation like that.
- belorn 12y agoRestaurants can't prioritize white customers over black customers. They can't provide more flavorful, healthier food for white customers only, while giving rotten, old, bad food to black customers while charging the same price. ISP's can however charge a higher price for faster speeds, same as a restaurant can charge a higher price for more flavorful and healthier food. competition solve problems when every actor acts rational, and everyone competes fairly with the same moral and ethical values. As soon one of those two assumptions are wrong, competition stops to solve problems in the market.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- amikula 12y agoPersonally, I think that solving problem 2 is the most important, and problem 1, if it is truly a problem, could be solved by a competitive free market. If it's truly possible for new competitors to enter the market, then if problem 1 really matters, market forces will handle it.
- nitrogen 12y agoif problem 1 really matters, market forces will handle it. Market forces didn't handle seat belts, air bags, fuel efficiency, racial discrimination, taxation without representation, etc. We cannot rely on the market to solve all problems.
- zo1 12y agoAs always, these items are only presented as "problems" because of the presence of government. So when government steps in and solves them, all pro-state individuals shout a glorious "Hurray, take that free-market!!'. >Seat Belts: If individuals wanted them, the car companies would have followed suit. You forget that not only were seat belts mandated to be installed, but people were FINED if they didn't put them on. >Air Bags: If there wasn't a state, I'm sure you'd have safety organizations putting out reports/studies about effectiveness of air bags. Rich people would buy them in their cars, poor people wouldn't, and they don't do that now anyways. Not sure how you see this is as something "government" fixed as it's different to seat belts, which are mandated? >Fuel efficiency: Ah yes, another environmental tax meant to incentivize good behavior. Let me know how that's working out. All this does is drive up the cost of cars unnecessarily under the pretense of environmental benefits. Again, if people wanted it, you wouldn't have to force them to do it. This is the basic basic difference that most pro-market, and anti-market sentiments boil down to. >Racial discrimination: This was enforced and perpetuated by state laws. Some would argue it still happens today with certain mandatory sentencing laws, minimum wage, etc. >Taxation without representation. What? You want the market to solve a problem that solely exists because of the state, revolves around the state, and is absolutely not subject to any market forces at all? Perhaps if I could "choose" where my tax money was spent, then there would be some sort of market force driven by individuals. But that's nowhere near the case. Now, a little more on-topic. You are absolutely right that we can't rely on the market to solve all problems, but in the presence of a state. The temptation is always there to "correct" or "slightly nudge" the market in directions we want it to go, rather than what the collective unconscious has decided. The free-market is more democracy than democracy is right now, and people fundamentally can not accept that.
- MRSallee 12y agoThere is a reasonable argument that if Problem 2 is solved, Problem 1 is no longer a problem.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Problem 2: The two biggest ISPs suck, and should be broken up, and/or it should be mandated that competition is much easier. While its not a complete solution, the FCC decision -- on the same day as the open internet vote -- preempting state laws prohibiting municipal broadband efforts (which laws prevent one potential alternative to the incumbent providers) at least addresses Problem 2.