2 ms·
> As for what it is to be done, I think several things can help: > - Relax antitrust legislation Why do you think it is better to fund labs through monopoly r
by jjoonathan 12y ago
> As for what it is to be done, I think several things can help:
> - Relax antitrust legislation
Why do you think it is better to fund labs through monopoly rent (where shareholders, administration, and inefficiency due to lack of competition all take a cut) than by simply increasing the budget funneled into the brutally competitive NSF grant process? If you assume that private labs are 10x as efficient as public labs, maybe, but I'm not convinced of 1x let alone 10x.
> Any new venture is intrinsically hard to value, and even a global optimizer would be reluctant to invest in those.
> ...
> mason.gmu.edu/~atabarro/PrivateProvision.pdf
So... crowdfund science by asking people to compute the monetary value of an "unknown unknown" (which is what science produces)? I don't think you would have trouble convincing people that the aggregate returns on science are pretty great, but I do think you would have a hard time getting the consumer excess of one of these contracts to exceed the friction induced from reasoning about unknown unknowns. A very hard time. Hell, I'd be willing to bet you that scientists figure out the secret to eternal life before bean-counters figure out how to crowdfund science at NSF scale with rational contracts.
- murbard2 12y agoBecause even large trusts are still competing with each other. If the funding process within an organisation becomes too political, it will shrink. In general, a large corporate entity has good governance from the mere fact that it succeeded, it's good at allocating money to different projects and managing people. Governments are good at holding political power by playing through political alliance. Thus, I think they will tend to do a worse job in allocating grants. The process is likely to become more politicized than it would in a private organisation. There are of course exceptions, I am talking about general tendencies. No matter who funds science, someone, even if it is the government, has to reason about the unknown unknowns when deciding what to fund and to which extent. The amount spent by the NSF is about $7B, which is a blip on the budget, and a blip in the amount contributed to private charities. The YMCA alone gets about $5B. The problem is that people just don't care that much about scientific research, and capitalism is good at producing what people want.
- digi_owl 12y agoOr make people want what they produce...