5 ms·
White House Doesn't Want You to Know the TPP's Effects on U.S. Copyright Laws
- shmerl 12y agoGreat overview of what's going on behind such "trade" agreements: http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/ http://economixcomix.com/home/tpp/
- rayiner 12y agoThis is what I think about whenever someone talks about "international law."
- eplanit 12y agoIndeed, and a similar shiver down the spine when they talk abstractly about "reform".
- mark_l_watson 12y agoAfter contributing money to Obama's campaign and voting for him twice, this is annoying. At the risk of boring the few dozen family and friends I am closest with, I have been SPAMing them with emails about TPP and links to complain to their Congress-critters.
- maisutton 12y agoAwesome, we need all the help we can get to make more people aware about this since the mainstream media isn't covering it all. If only John Oliver did a take on this for us... :] - author of this blog post
- smackmybishop 12y agoWhy would this surprise you after ACTA? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Counterfeiting_Trade_Agreement#United_States_2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Counterfeiting_Trade_Agree...
- HopeyChangey 12y agoI'm being serious when I ask this: how did you not see stuff like this coming? Especially the second time around? I mean no offense by this, but I may never understand how so many intelligent, thoughtful people managed to become so fully convinced of such a naive narrative.
- prawn 12y agoWouldn't this be one of those things poked through by either side? We have the same TPP secrecy and issues with copyright in Australia under a conservative government. I'd expect the situation to be largely similar whichever of the major parties were in power.
- HopeyChangey 12y agoOh, yes, absolutely. I don't believe for a second that had 2008 or 2012 turned out differently, commercial forces would have any less influence on those who write the laws, ratify the laws, or he who signs them. It's the nature of the beast. But that isn't what I was getting at. There was this mass euphoria surrounding one candidate, in which his supporters seemed to believe–despite all evidence to the contrary–that their candidate would somehow represent a kind of messianic deliverance from the status quo–at long last!–as if he would somehow be magically exempt from the forces that created the status quo in the first place. I understand how people could bring themselves to believe such a thing once, but how they largely came back for more in the reelection, and are now shocked–shocked!–to discover there is gambling going on in this establishment, is beyond me. Registering disappointment this late in the game says more about the voter than it does the politician, frankly. I just want to understand how people who aren't lacking in intelligence came to, for lack of a better term, fall for it. The thinking of lot of highly rational people became more emotionally-driven than I've ever seen.
- krapp 12y agoDo you think Mitt Romney would have been any better on this issue? Because that is essentially what that choice boiled down to, Kang or Kodos.
- anigbrowl 12y agoBut Obama has always been broadly in favor of more trade - he was never one of those candidates promising to dismantle NAFTA or use protectionist tariffs. Much as he always made it clear that he was no peacenik and would deploy US military power where he felt it would advance US interests. I'm not saying you should like or agree with these policies, but I can't sympathize with your expressions of surprise. I'm hawkish enough (as a classical economic liberal or 'neoliberal' if you like) that I broadly support the policies mentioned above, and it was part of why I decided I'd prefer to see him in the job back in 2007.
- WildUtah 12y agoThis isn't about free trade, though. It's about raising trade barriers together to protect incumbent industries at the cost of consumers and competition. They want to lengthen copyright, invade privacy, regulate internet services while empowering gatekeepers, strengthen licensing and reporting and taxation demands on small business, expand and unify patent regimes, and the like. Canada, Mexico, China, Australia, and Japan are already reciprocal Most Favored Nation trading partners. We're not going to be getting any more access to their markets. They're not going to be selling us anything new, either. The contents of the deal are still an official secret, but we've had leaks. It looks like the worst kind of big cartel, Disney, telecom monopoly, NSA, surveillance state, patent troll plan to terrorize consumers and innovating businesses. In fact, it's probably exactly what you might expect powerful insiders to negotiate in secret at the expense of the public. Free trade is something different.
- anigbrowl 12y agoMake sure that straw man is well and truly dead before you stop beating him.
- shmerl 12y agoTPP has nothing to do with freedom of trade, the name is misleading on purpose.
- walterbell 12y agoLast week's TPP discussion with 80+ comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078954 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9078954
- PythonicAlpha 12y agoThe trouble with TPP and other such "advances": Big corporations are pulling strings in the background, to annul democratic control. With bigger institutions (e.g. Washington, Brussels, ...) it becomes simpler and simpler to find people that are far enough from the voters and corrupted enough to support such endeavors. The result are secret proceedings and parliaments that become pressed to vote for big legislation where the effects for democracy and nations can not be foreseen. In effect, those lobbies have their way (at least oftentimes in the last decades) and destroy democratic control and control of the big corporations. So it comes, that big corporations have a "free hand" to do what they want but are liable for nearly nothing. The worst thing about this is, that when one "advance" is rejected by democracy -- no trouble, just give it a different name, make it a little different and give it an other 3 or 4 letters acronym ... and bring it back next year!
- mindslight 12y agoOur lazy friends who give money to (Netflix, iTunes, etc) are directly supporting this.
- happyscrappy 12y agoSome people's time is important. Teenagers with lots of time and little money can futz around with being a pirate.
- mindslight 12y agoVideo entertainment is inherently time-wasting, so for the majority of content that argument doesn't have legs. For someone technical, there's little "futzing" - one time setup, and ongoing maintenance will take less time than when "cable company 2.0" is (down, showing advertisement, changing selection). I do agree that piracy UI needs to be a lot better so that anybody can setup something that just works with a minimum of effort. But none of these pragmatic considerations invalidate my original point, which is that those who give money to the old style media companies are directly funding this corruption.
- dublinben 12y agoProjects like PopcornTime are just as easy to use, if not easier to use than Netflix/Amazon. It doesn't require a credit card, and has no region/platform restrictions.
- sroerick 12y agoOut of curiosity, do you know what it would take to make a PopcornTime for ONLY Creative Commons and Public Domain material? Just a CC/PD tracker?
- sroerick 12y agoI've released two films, one feature length, and one an oscar-nominated short. They're now in the Creative Commons. You can download them for free. Bitcoin and Dogecoin addresses are included in the torrents. http://sportsteam.link/~lexialex/ http://sportsteam.link/~lexialex/ http://sportsteam.link/~mariagiese/ http://sportsteam.link/~mariagiese/ Support Creative Commons, BitTorrent, and BitCoin content.
- anigbrowl 12y ago1. I'm not aware at any especial effort of secrecy about the TPP. It's normal to negotiate treaties behind closed doors; the time for public debate is when they come up for ratification in the Senate, which is in accordance with the Constitutional design. 2. This has little or no effect on US copyright law, but seeks to promote that standard elsewhere: * What they want is the most restrictive interpretation of U.S. policy to become the international "norm" by which all other TPP countries will be forced to conform their national laws.* 3. All TPP negotiating coutnries are already signatories to the EBrene convention and in principle are alsready signed up to these terms as fr as foreign works are concerned. 4. The US copyright regime got to be the way it is largely as a response to changes in European law (specifically the Sonny Bono copyright act extending it to life + 70). I'm heartily in favor of copyright reform but until such time as it takes place it's entirely understandable that international trade negotiations would be based on the law as it currently stands rather than some hypothetical future version. Furthermore, the TPP copyright rules as discussed are basically just an affirmation of the existing copyright regime rather than some drastic change. The normal thing in any kind of trade deal is for the parties to try to get theri commercial marketplace rules onto the same page so that they can minimize the legal barriers to selling goods in each others markets.
- walterbell 12y agoWhat's your take on TPP's proposed criminal enforcement provisions which would criminalize noncommercial activities such as fanzines, even when rightsholders have no complaint? https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/10/latest-tpp-leak-shows-us-still-pushing-terrible-drm-and-copyright-term-proposals https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/10/latest-tpp-leak-shows-... http://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2014/10/17/latest-tpp-leak-shows-even-harsher-copyright-rules/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/emmawoollacott/2014/10/17/latest... http://japanitlaw.blogspot.com/2013/01/tpps-effect-on-fanzine-environment.html http://japanitlaw.blogspot.com/2013/01/tpps-effect-on-fanzin...
- anigbrowl 12y agoOVerblown, when was the last time you heard of anything like that inside the US? Of course there's no way to make definitive statements unless and until an official draft is presented to the Senate for ratification, but the reality is that authorities are much more interested in going after obvious knockoffs of commercial property (fake DVDs, t-shirts or whatever) than obviously fan-driven projects that do not represent themselves as 'the real thing'. If anything, the trend in US courts is towards expanding the boundaries of fair use. I think you might be interested in this recent case: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cariou_v._Prince http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cariou_v._Prince
- collyw 12y agoWhat happened to democracy? I know no absolutely one that is in favor of this, yet it seems like it will happen.