4 ms·
>SMI Sam, please don't make up a new acronym. Especially if you aren't an AI researcher. Plenty of thought has gone into this and your statement about it not s
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
>SMI
Sam, please don't make up a new acronym. Especially if you aren't an AI researcher. Plenty of thought has gone into this and your statement about it not seeming "real" misses the history of AI.
There has been a lot of work in the AI community to try and steer our language towards a concrete nomenclature and Artificial General Intelligence has taken the helm at this point to represent machine instances that are equal to or greater than human level.[1][2]
Semantics matter, as you point out, so please be on the same page with the field.
Aside from that I hope that you and everyone else can, instead of just jumping on the Musk/Hawking/Bostrom bandwagon, actually pay attention to the AGI community. Maybe start attending our conferences (http://agi-conf.org/2015/ http://agi-conf.org/2015/) and publishing in our journals (http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/jagi http://www.degruyter.com/view/j/jagi). The field needs more money and more researchers. There were less than 100 attendees at last year's AGI - that is not nearly enough.
[1] In fact Ben Goertzel, Richard Loosemore and Peter Voss had an interesting exchange on facebook about this just this week
[2]http://wp.goertzel.org/who-coined-the-term-agi/ http://wp.goertzel.org/who-coined-the-term-agi/
- seiji 12y agoSam, please don't make up a new acronym. Seconded. I see people using it here in replies and it's a new unnecessary acronym burden. Plus, if anything, it should be NBI (non-biological intelligence). At least that can be fun to say. "Why can't you go outside today?" "Sorry, my super-nibby said I haven't been working enough." We have words, words mean things, use words to mean things. Half the business emails I get have new TLAs nobody has ever seen before (how about that MQ for DL DW and DMSA) and it needs to stop, don't we all agree?
- olalonde 12y agoWhat do you think of http://lesswrong.com http://lesswrong.com as a community?
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoFrankly, not much - but it's not like I think they are doing bad things it just seems like it's yet another philosophical forum. I was active from 2007~2010 when it was just transitioning from the Hanson/Yudkowski combined blog with a robust comments section to the beginnings of what you see now. I'm sure some of my comments are still floating around there somewhere. I think in the early days it was a pretty good place to bounce ideas off of each other about philosophical ideas/concepts WRT AGI, and probably still has that to some degree. It just became too cultish around Yudkowski for my tastes and ended up being very navel gazing around Bayesian probability and "rationalism" as religion. That's not to denigrate Bayesians or rationalism at all because those are great things. In the end the community is more interested in talking than they are doing and SIAI is somewhat of an offshoot of that ethos with roots in the original Future of Humanity core group, and continues that legacy. Don't get me wrong, there are a lot of really smart great people contributing interesting things there about rationality and optimization. I just moved away from their religion of rationality that boils down to these super hardcore utilitarian calculations which end up kind of defeating the populist goals of spreading rationalism.
- olalonde 12y agoThanks. I'm just an occasional lurker there but your opinion resonated with me (especially the "talking vs doing" and "cultish behaviour" parts). I remember once seeing a comment about someone who stated his intention to start working on AGI get heavily down voted and criticised (as if the rest of the world should stop researching AGI until LW figured out the Safe Way to do it).
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoas if the rest of the world should stop researching AGI until LW figured out the Safe Way to do it That's basically MIRI's ethos - basically, once they figure out how to build it safely then everyone will be permitted to go start building it. You can see how ridiculous this is on it's face.