4 ms·
They are (possibly) doing something right, and they certainly have gotten lucky, so yay for them. But this isn't 1994. Launching a service now without thinking
by wpietri 12y ago
They are (possibly) doing something right, and they certainly have gotten lucky, so yay for them. But this isn't 1994.
Launching a service now without thinking about scaling is an amateur move. It is the kind of thing that can kill a company, or at least wound it severely. At best, you are wasting a zillion first impressions in the hope that you will do well enough that they'll eventually come back for a second chance. There are plenty of well-tested approaches to prevent that from happening, and they're not particularly hard to implement.
It seems pretty reasonable to me that people have put the time in to learn how to do this right are critical when it is done wrong. It reminds me of the tension between a person who has worked their ass off to get into a good school and the one who got in because he won the ovarian lottery and his family's name is on a building. Sure, we should be happy every time somebody gets a good education, but I think it's asking a lot for skill never to resent luck.
- chm 12y ago> Launching a service now without thinking about scaling is an amateur move. I don't think they were shooting for the stars with Magic. It seemed a hack from day one. My impression is they didn't intend it to grow as it did.
- wpietri 12y agoSure, but so what? Not saying, "What will happen if this works?" is an amateur move. In an industry where the whole goal is wild success, it's not a good sign if you are totally unprepared for wild success. But for the sake of argument let me grant that some people in YC somehow a) thought something was so important as to take time away from their startup, and b) never even considered that it might work. Once it started working, there were a number of things they could do other than the "make a complete hash of things" strategy that Wired's experience apparently suggests they are pursuing now.