3 ms·
It's hard to make an analogy of what Magic is right now, other than to say it's sort of like "Siri with humans." But at scale, I envision it would basically be
by derefr 12y ago
It's hard to make an analogy of what Magic is right now, other than to say it's sort of like "Siri with humans." But at scale, I envision it would basically be a dynamically-allocated pool of secretaries, in the same way that AWS is a dynamically-allocated pool of computer hardware.
And we already have "dynamically-allocated pools of secretaries!" Magic is effectively a recreation of the concierge service attached to (some) credit cards, which does exactly that.
This is not to poo-poo the business model—far from it, it's something people want—but I'm guessing the true outcome of this battle will just be A. the credit card companies opening up their concierge services to lower cardholder levels; and B. AWS building a concierge-pool service to go along with (and possibly run atop of) their Mechanical Turk labor-pool service.
- CPLX 12y agoIt's a virtual assistant service. There are lots of those. The business model of such a service is they sell the labor of someone who solves problems for you, and charge you slightly more than it costs them to compensate the labor. Or in the case of this specific virtual assistant service called Magic, they have people who don't in fact solve problems for you, and charge some unspecified opaque amount of money.
- VLM 12y agoIts an outsourced operations department. Like a NOC or dispatch organization. The kind of place that needs some internal controls, policies, metrics, standards, demarcation points, escalation contacts, something other than "do your best". Observationally this seems to be an operations department without all those features. Once they add those features, they'll either be wildly successful, or no longer profitable, hard to say which. If you've ever wondered what service would be like at a big company help desk or call center without any rules, well, now you know. Some really good parts, some really bad parts.
- derefr 12y agoRight, the obvious comparison that everyone can understand is a call centre. But, of course, call centre employees (ops employees in general) do the things related to their line of business and which they're trained for. This is slightly different, in that a concierge or administrative assistant does a lot of things they're not trained for, just because it's what the boss/client asks for.
- VLM 12y agoYour analysis is correct at the lower level functions but I was thinking slightly higher level, you are correct there is no scripted procedure for example, ordering a pizza and diet coke, but where is the procedure or policy or anything, to handle "verification that something got delivered" "Follow up with customer to verify he's happy with his delivery" "company wide standards for tipping or including gratuity in the cost" "how to deal with a journalist on the internet complaining" "Documentation and analysis of failures"