3 ms·
As a developer who spent the last few months trying to get a website with touch events to work on the surface 3, I need to get this off my chest. Microsoft, ma
by munsoji 12y ago
As a developer who spent the last few months trying to get a website with touch events to work on the surface 3, I need to get this off my chest.
Microsoft, make up your mind. Do you want a browser that websites 'just work' in or do you want to keep implementing broken standards and forcing other browsers to adopt them? Pick one and don't try to find some weird middle ground where you implement webkit touch events on ie11 mobile but not desktop even though you want us to treat them as the same browser. I'm also looking at you, pointermove events that don't ever give you x and y values other than 0. You tell us you want us to do feature detection instead of browser detection, but how am I supposed to do that when window.pointerEnabled is true for all instances of ie11 even though I don't want to register touch events when I know the user is using a mouse? Before you respond with "you should just be listening for pointer events and not worry about type", you've just asked me to make my site incompatible with every other browser on the market instead of making it slower on ie11 by registering lots of unnecessary event listeners.
Microsoft, it's over. I'm moving on, and don't try to pretend like you can change with project spartan.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoA bug, and an extra event listener? That's enough to drive you mad? Sorry, that seems pretty mild. I understand getting wound up after spending too much time figuring out an issue. Maybe walk away from it for an hour, get a cup of something, vent on HN. Oh! That's what you're doing.
- taf2 12y agoHere's the thing this is just one example of one issue of thousands. And at the end of the day the difference is with Mozilla and Chromium I can jump on irc and talk directly to the people working on those browsers and get their advice for the best way to work around a current issue. I can get insight into whether a fix is in progress and I can vent my frustrations. I can also rest easy knowing that in 1-3 months a fix is likely to arrive... For IE this is all none- existent. The original comment is spot on IMO about the state of Microsoft and IE. Safari, has it's issues and I wish Apple would innovate faster but at least the core of Safari is open via Webkit and similar to Mozilla and Chromium I have someone to reach out to... I have nothing from MS/IE - I don't even target that browser anymore. If a customer complains about the site not working - it means either. a. they're on Window XP and no worth the trouble. b. they just need to open chrome. And yes - this is a much better web than we had with MS/IE
- cssmoo 12y agoHave you ever raised a support case with MS properly I.e. Not via feedback/connect? Your can speak to someone who knows their shit pretty sharpish and get a fix to you. Most of the time this is same day stuff. As for Chrome, the open web is much better now we have NaCl, sign in nagging and dubious privacy and no support even if you're a paying customer (google apps I'm looking at you).
- taf2 12y agoI think conflating privacy with quality/security is a bad idea... especially if you're trying to say MS is better a customer privacy than Google... http://rt.com/usa/yahoo-microsoft-campaign-political-862/ http://rt.com/usa/yahoo-microsoft-campaign-political-862/ - just saying...
- munsoji 12y agoMaybe not enough to drive one mad on an intuitive, functional device, but enough to push one over the edge when debugging on a surface. I feel like I'm being tasked with drawing an idyllic landscape on a grain of rice with only a box of crayons, in that while it will be impressive to the .01% of users that might see it the other 99.99% will never notice nor appreciate the effort.