3 ms·
Ask HN: Why not criminalize unsubstantiated assertions made in public?
You could still hold opinions/beliefs, but you would need to explicitly say that something is an opinion/belief.
- tdoggette 17y agoIt's my opinion that you haven't thought your ideas through.
- amichail 17y agoIt's hard to think through something that would require an experiment to determine its effectiveness. It's pretty obvious that free speech without limits results in a lot of nonsense that many people believe.
- mbrubeck 17y agoAnd the government are just the people to decide which truths are actually true!
- amichail 17y agoReputable academics would decide whether someone is guilty of unsubstantiated statements. Even if this is limited to scientific matters, it could be an improvement over unrestricted free speech.
- jamesbritt 17y agoAnd "reputable academics" would be determined by ... ... turtles all the way down.
- amichail 17y agoPageRank-like measures would be helpful for this purpose: http://peterrohde.wordpress.com/2008/04/29/pagerank-in-academic-publishing/ http://peterrohde.wordpress.com/2008/04/29/pagerank-in-acade...
- jamesbritt 17y agoIt's also pretty obvious that free speech with limits results in a lot of nonsense that many people believe.
- andrewbadera 17y ago"thought experiment" -- happens all the time.
- jamesbritt 17y ago"You could still hold opinions/beliefs, but you would need to explicitly say that something is an opinion/belief." Or people could understand that everything anyone says is an opinion/belief unless accompanied by verifiable backing. There are unintended consequences of trying to guarantee something. For example, I know people who consume anything available for sale, because, you know, if it was bad for you the government wouldn't allow it to be sold. I'd rather not encourage people to be less critical in their thinking regarding the assertions of others. Also, debates over evolution tells me that getting people to agree on what "substantiated" means is a staggering challenge. Better to have the occasional PSA that tells people, "BTW, some people make shit up. Be skeptical of what you read and hear."
- amichail 17y agoThere is no debate over evolution if we restrict ourselves to reputable scientists. Most people are not capable of critical thought and should not be encouraged to think for themselves.
- jamesbritt 17y agoQED.
- ErrantX 17y ago> Most people are not capable of critical thought and should not be encouraged to think for themselves Can you hear yourself talk - seriously? That lack of capability and you stopping them are such different things. The second you deliberately discourage someone from individual thought your crossing an awful moral line. Even if a person makes a poor mistake at least it is their choice. Yes you might have made a better choice for them, in your opinion, but crossing such a line for genuinely helpful reasons just one time is a dangerous precedent to set. You comment is basically the basis for all justification of oppression in the history of the world. That's the kind of things that good critical thinkers should realise it it important to avoid (making me almost suggest your a victim of your own fallacy).
- russell 17y agoThe first amendment to the US Constitution pretty much covers that. There isn't anything much than the government deciding what is true and what isn't, what can be said and what cannot.