3 ms·

How much did you have to dig to find a detective with homeopathy in their bio? ;) One quack in the crowd doesn't mean that they are all quacks. PS If you actu

How much did you have to dig to find a detective with homeopathy in their bio? ;) One quack in the crowd doesn't mean that they are all quacks. PS If you actually believe you practice science-based medicine, you may be part of the problem. Medicine is mostly a guessing game, and will stay that way until we have genome-specific-personalized-medicine with real-time biofeedback mechanisms from sensors in the body.

the_af 12y ago
Um, Daniel Auer is one of the 3 listed in the front page, so I guess he didn't have to dig much.
zck 12y ago
He's one of three doctors listed on the homepage, which was the submitted link here. There's a difference between "we don't know everything" and "we have good reason to believe homeopathy is useful". Sure, maybe eating raw duck poop will cure asthma, but I'm not going to try it just in case it works.
CatDevURandom 12y ago
I know it's unpopular to stick up for physicians but... > Medicine is mostly a guessing game Can you be more specific with that sweeping generalization? > and will stay that way until we have genome-specific-personalized-medicine with real-time biofeedback mechanisms from sensors in the body. And why do you think that? Again, by what study, authority, knowledge or reasoning? > you may be part of the problem. Actually no, it's the other way around. You are part of the problem. I'm so tired of people who have zero training or background in medicine or science half-haphazardly proselytizing without any data or evidence to them up. Please stop pretending like you know the answer to something this important if you aren't in the position to do so.
Kurtz79 12y ago
"Medicine is mostly a guessing game". Seeing a comment like this, on HN, in 2015, just boggles my mind. I'm glad that very good "guesses" from people that have been studying medicine all their life, benefits from centuries of accumulated scientific knowledge on the subject, and used cutting edge diagnosing equipment were able to completely heal my crucial ligament when it broke, or were able to save my mother's life when diagnosed with breast cancer.

the_af 12y ago

Um, Daniel Auer is one of the 3 listed in the front page, so I guess he didn't have to dig much.

zck 12y ago

He's one of three doctors listed on the homepage, which was the submitted link here. There's a difference between "we don't know everything" and "we have good reason to believe homeopathy is useful". Sure, maybe eating raw duck poop will cure asthma, but I'm not going to try it just in case it works.

CatDevURandom 12y ago

I know it's unpopular to stick up for physicians but... > Medicine is mostly a guessing game Can you be more specific with that sweeping generalization? > and will stay that way until we have genome-specific-personalized-medicine with real-time biofeedback mechanisms from sensors in the body. And why do you think that? Again, by what study, authority, knowledge or reasoning? > you may be part of the problem. Actually no, it's the other way around. You are part of the problem. I'm so tired of people who have zero training or background in medicine or science half-haphazardly proselytizing without any data or evidence to them up. Please stop pretending like you know the answer to something this important if you aren't in the position to do so.

Kurtz79 12y ago

"Medicine is mostly a guessing game". Seeing a comment like this, on HN, in 2015, just boggles my mind. I'm glad that very good "guesses" from people that have been studying medicine all their life, benefits from centuries of accumulated scientific knowledge on the subject, and used cutting edge diagnosing equipment were able to completely heal my crucial ligament when it broke, or were able to save my mother's life when diagnosed with breast cancer.