7 ms·
As Republicans Concede, F.C.C. Is Expected to Enforce Net Neutrality
- higherpurpose 12y agoStill disappointed they didn't unbundle the last mile. It seems to me that's where the biggest pain-point is right now, and doing that would've been far more effective in getting ISPs to play nice in the market, since then they'd have actual competition.
- warfangle 12y agoIn that way, it kind of is like Obamacare for the internet.....
- rayiner 12y agoAny large-scale unbundling proposal, which would necessarily target the cable networks, would be fairly unprecedented. To date, unbundling has been applied where the government had a stake in the networks to begin with. The POTS network was constructed by AT&T, a government-sanctioned monopoly. In the U.K., the phone network was built by BT when it was a public corporation. The modern cable networks were built mostly after cable companies lost their local monopolies in 1996.
- f3llowtraveler 12y ago> As Republicans Concede... Do they ever do anything else?
- gz5 12y agoaccess competition, please, pretty please... anything else isn't satisfactory and may have worse unintended consequences (or intended consequences, depending where you sit)
- gojomo 12y agoThe FCC fines people for broadcast obscenity. It requires the 'v-chip' censorship technology in televisions. The FCC enforces telecom system wiretap rules (CALEA). The FCC's decisions on mergers and spectrum auctions often amount to giant handouts to politically-favored corporations. Had the 'Clipper Chip' been a mandated encryption technology in the 90s, the FCC would've enforced its use. The national internet blacklists of the UK and Australia are maintained through their local equivalents of the FCC. Title II regulation was designed for the plain-old-telephone-system monopolies, where there was even less choice (one provider!) than the very worst of current local broadband markets. The internet, without any FCC rules, thrived and completely eclipsed that slow-moving regulated market. But after this 'reclassification', new federal rules will limit what ISPs can offer and charge, regardless of what paying customers prefer, under the 1930s telephone/utility model. Upstart services offering novel cross-subsidized speed/latency improvements will require federal pre-approval or risk outright prohibition. ISPs will have to keep a DC commission staffed by loyalists of the two national parties happy, or else discretionary interpretations will go against them. This is not a victory for either the internet or the "little guy".
- paulhauggis 12y agoI've been saying this since it was announced. The FCC has a 332 page plan to regulate the Internet (which the public does not have a chance to even look over before it is passed). What else is in there? Even if the current administration doesn't use the power they will now be given, whose to say it won't happen in the future? Doesn't this bother anybody? We need more transparency, especially in something as important as this.
- tzs 12y ago> The FCC has a 332 page plan to regulate the Internet (which the public does not have a chance to even look over before it is passed) No, the FCC does not have a 332 page plan to regulate the internet. Tom Wheeler has a plan, although it is much much shorter to 332. The 300+ pages is for a document that includes his plan, a long explanation of the reasons and the authorities for each part, and a long look at the large number of comments that were received after last years FCC plan. The FCC will have a plan if the Commissioners vote in a couple day to make adopt Wheeler's plan, at which point it will then be available for public comment so that we can all see it and comment. After that, the FCC decides to adopt it or not. > Even if the current administration doesn't use the power they will now be given, whose to say it won't happen in the future? Doesn't this bother anybody? Adopting Title II with forbearance now does not really make it significantly easier for a future FCC to use the powers that this FCC is forbearing. If this FCC does not adopt Title II, all that changes is that future FCC would have to adopt Title II.
- paulhauggis 12y ago"The FCC will have a plan if the Commissioners vote in a couple day to make adopt Wheeler's plan, at which point it will then be available for public comment so that we can all see it and comment. After that, the FCC decides to adopt it or not." 300+ pages is not "much shorter" than 332. "The FCC will have a plan if the Commissioners vote in a couple day to make adopt Wheeler's plan, at which point it will then be available for public comment so that we can all see it and comment. After that, the FCC decides to adopt it or not." Which means the people don't really have a say in the matter. We can see and comment on it after the proposal is already pretty much a done deal. Would you like to be able to comment on the new president (rather than vote) after they are being sworn into office? I think not. "all that changes is that future FCC would have to adopt Title II." Once new FCC powers are in place, do you actually think we have a chance at getting rid of them? History says no. Taken from this article: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2015/02/23/house-chairman-urges-fcc-transparency/23882079/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2015/02/23/house-chairman... "Also today, FCC commissioners Ajit Pai and Michael O'Rielly too asked for Wheeler to release the proposal to the public and postpone the Thursday vote to allow for 30 days of public comment." There is a reason the FCC doesn't want the public to go through the proposal..and it is most likely not good. Again, why are we trusting the same government that has been spying on us for so long. Did the Snowden leaks teach us nothing? I'm still waiting for an argument as to why more transparency, especially when it comes to something as important as regulating the Internet, is not important.
- remarkEon 12y agoAnybody have a link to the actual text of the rules?
- Shivetya 12y agono and that is what is so damn infuriating about this process. Republican's concede? Really, they failed to make the rules public before we are subject to them and suddenly people crow victory? this is the same nonsense the haters did when the ACA was passed, a bunch of irrational hate because those who complained were "EVIL REPUBLICANS". Sheesh. Love being a libertarian but damned if both sides aren't dumb as rocks.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Anybody have a link to the actual text of the rules? Members and staff at the FCC have copies of whatever current drafts are circulating (which, by reports that there may be active discussions on at least one key point, there may be more than one), no one else does except as an unofficial leak (and any version that exists now may or may not be the version that gets voted on.) Otherwise, no. FCC orders are not released in preliminary form before they are approved. This is consistent with regulatory agency decisions in general, there is a formal process for release of orders, that involves approval. Certain orders are released as proposals for comment before being finalized -- this is called a "Notice of Proposed Rulemaking" (NPRM). The FCC did, in fact, issue an NPRM on its open internet rules, which (along with the public comment on the NPRM) got plenty of notice here, in the mainstream media, etc. After comment on an NPRM, the agency reviews the comments, conducts further policy discussions, and can either abandon the effort, revise the policy and issue it as an order or issue a new, revised NPRM. All of these -- except abandoning the effort entirely -- require the agency to conduct a vote. Regulatory agencies don't release draft orders prior to vote of the agency (as distinct from NPRMs, which, while they aren't final orders, are final products of the agency, not pre-vote drafts) much the same way that courts don't release draft opinions before the judges have voted on them.
- remarkEon 12y agoI had a feeling. So just to be clear, this is not unique to the rule making surrounding Net Neutrality - this is the general process for federal agency rule making.
- guelo 12y agoIt is Comcast, Verizon, et al.'s heavy-handed, deceptive, anti-customer business practices that will decide this debate. Anti-government ideologues always used to talk about how awful the DMV is but people love the DMV compared to the telecom monopolies. They're universally despised. Despite all their lobbying money there is luckily still some democracy remaining in our government.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- TallGuyShort 12y agoInstead of being anti-government, people should be pro-individual-freedom. Corporations can inhibit individual-freedom as easily as government if government doesn't actively support individual freedom.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 12y ago> Despite all their lobbying money there is luckily still some democracy remaining in our government. Yes, because nobody in the triple-digit billions revenue web tech industry lobbied for net neutrality. Whether you think neutrality is a good idea or not, you can't ignore the conflict at play here. There's a lot of money distributing bits over wires to consumers. The net neutrality and copyright debates boil down to a fight between companies that make the bits, the ones that aggregate and distribute the bits, and the ones that build the wires about who gets how much of that money.
- guelo 12y agoSure. But I guess my point was that money, on either side, doesn't matter when one side has white-hot mass passion.
- qwerty853490 12y agoIntel, Cisco, IBM and a host of other large tech companies also oppose net neutrality regulations. Why is this always painted as a good and evil issue?
- dustin1114 12y agoIt seems to just be more federal regulation from DC. I'm as much of a fan of a free and open internet as anyone, but why risk the FCC getting involved? Also, can anyone honestly see rates being reduced because of this? Sure, all of us would love to see more competition (I actually only have one choice where I live, sadly), but the truth is, the companies that invest the capital to build the infrastructure deserve to reap the profits. I'm not quite sure what the solution would be to having more competition. What worries me the most is the bureaucracy of it. Are we the people really getting a say? The FCC is made up of unelected officials (appointed by the Executive branch, Republican or Democrat) plastering on their views. Why not let our elected representatives take care of this? You may say that they would just block it, it would never move, etc. Perhaps it's not as much of an emergency as we think, then? I guess this is just the same old federalism versus statism argument. Good ol' American politics.
- mikegioia 12y agoThis comment is as if it's straight out of 2009. Have you followed anything related to TWC/Comcast/Verizon over the last 5 years? We've TRIED to let the Executive Branch handle this and they produced SOPA/PIPA. We TRIED to let the ISPs work on their own with little regulation and we get 3 Mbps speeds in areas with no competition.
- wwweston 12y ago> why risk the FCC getting involved? In national communications policy? > Also, can anyone honestly see rates being reduced because of this? Prices are pretty much an orthogonal issue to net neutrality. If you don't have a source/destination neutral network, it's possible you won't be able to buy the services such a network supports at any price. > The FCC is made up of unelected officials I think it's reasonably clear that doesn't mean they're unaccountable. Congress or the President can heavily influence policy if they screw it up. But strangely, at the moment, they seem to be doing policy better than most elected officials. :/
- dustin1114 12y agoI agree, it is national communications policy. But why not try getting a new statute passed that isn't based on telephones from the switch-operator era? It just seems to me that it's being pressed so hard because it's such a "fad" issue right now. Most people honestly don't even have a clue what the FCC or "net neutrality" is. Sure, the FCC is accountable to the President (ultimately), and to congressional oversight committees, but they don't have to worry about being thrown out of office for any decisions they make.
- raintrees 12y agoWarning in advance: The following musings are not positive, you may wish to skip this comment. The last references to the proposed text I read still had "lawful content" as a phrase, one I consider to be a key phrase. In order to allow lawful content, a definition of lawful (and therefore unlawful) will be required, as well as inspection of content to allow enforcement. I am inquisitive, this leads me to questions: What words will I be disallowed from using to keep a website online? What speech will I need to silence? Will this be similar to free speech zones? Will I be allowed to run a webserver as long as I put up certain warnings/guarantees? Or carry a specific type of rating in a revamped website rating system? This inspection: Will my ISP be required to perform packet reconstruction to analyze my content to decide whether it should be given a pass or not? Should we be looking to products like Comodo's PrivDog as a model of how the government should set this up? Assuming they address the invalid cert part, maybe our government should take over all CAs, to make sure they can read all encrypted communications to confirm they are lawful? I am deeply disappointed that I feel like I can start quoting George Orwell to make my points... On a positive note, with all of this extra traffic and the subsequent requirements, maybe the US will have to invest in faster network infrastructure without having to rely on Google Fiber threatening the local monopolies. And since the FCC is involved, rather than this being a market-driven cost approach, it will likely be more a tragedy of the commons-based cost approach - My fellow tax payers and I will all foot the bill. At least we won't be as likely to notice that it is much more expensive than it needed to be. And it can be passed on to more than one generation. Depending on who I listen to, there are rumoured to be quite a few people out of work who could benefit from more job creation, maybe we will get a new governmental organization, similar to the DHS, to oversee this. There seem to be so many ways this does not end well.
- wmf 12y agoThis looks like an example of pretending there's no precedent and using that as an opportunity to invent an arbitrary strawman that supports your hobbyhorse (in this case extreme paranoia). Internet copyright laws (NET, DMCA, etc.) don't work anything like what you've proposed and there's no evidence that the FCC is trying to use net neutrality as a backdoor to reverse that precedent.