5 ms·
Can this be used as a standalone 3d Engine without it being scene based for iOS applications? That is the big issue with Unity - and most engines actually - whi
by AndrewKemendo 12y ago
Can this be used as a standalone 3d Engine without it being scene based for iOS applications? That is the big issue with Unity - and most engines actually - which keeps us from using it.
We can't find a robust (UE/Unity level) mobile 3D Engine that is not scene based or just built for level based games.
- Jare 12y agoEngine-supported scenes are a convenience, you don't need to use them if their cons outweigh their pros.
- ChrisClark 12y agoI only have one scene in my Unity games. I load and do everything I want with my own custom code. The feature to use scenes is there, but I don't bother to use it. Just like Minecraft clones built in Unity, the scene is empty, the code does all the work dynamically loading and displaying the level.
- philtar 12y agoWhy is that an issue on iOS? Genuinely curious.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoDepends on the application. For us we just need an open 3D rendering engine that allows for good lighting and textures.
- moron4hire 12y agoI believe the issue is that scenegraphs tend to make spatial partitioning more difficult, which means culling objects that are out of view is more difficult.
- Impossible 12y agoNot sure what the exact ask is here. Are you building an open world or virtual world game? Do you just want a 3D renderer without the game engine? Both Unity and Unreal 4 can be used for non-level based games, and Unreal has some special facilities to support that (world compositor specifically - https://docs.unrealengine.com/latest/INT/Engine/LevelStreaming/WorldBrowser/index.html https://docs.unrealengine.com/latest/INT/Engine/LevelStreami...).
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoLooking for an open world/3D renderer for AR rendering that can handle a lot of Polygons, textures and lighting. We don't need a game engine with physics and all that as it is but down the line, physics might be handy. A lot of the renderers like Ogre3D do too much file handling - we need something more bare bones. OpenGL is what we are using but we would like something more powerful.
- nailer 12y agoSurely AR would be scene based? You've recognised an object through VR, you want to display a note near it, it would be much easier to specify that relative to the object (scene based) than relative to the bottom/left/close corner of the image (world space).
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoNot in the same "scene" sense that you have dedicated levels like in a game that load statically. With AR, you are generally putting an arbitrary model into the 3D rendering environment and then using different sensors to "place" it accurately. Traditional game engines want you to build levels/scenes inside of their editors like Unity, as opposed to being an open engine that you can feed in real time from a separate library. So yes, AR is based on the scene you are "shooting" at the time, but not the same way that game engines are built to be generally static at the time of loading.
- nailer 12y agoI understand what you're saying - you need dynamic environments. Minor terminology quip (which might make discussion easier in future): that's a very different concern with being 'scene based', which is a specific term the 3D industry uses to mean 'items are located relative to their parents in a tree shaped data structure called a scene graph, and not absolutely positioned in world space'.