7 ms·
A Story About ‘Magic' (1994)
- pothibo 12y agoThis is awesome in so many ways because it captured the imagination of the people using it. They just saw that switch and actually tried to figure out why it wasn't magic. Obviously it wasn't, but the way this is written really shows how dumbfound they were because they couldn't explain it.
- sparaker 12y agoI would love to have some of those in my office, just to have a psychological change with a flip of a button.
- rcthompson 12y agoYou can make your own: http://store-xkcd-com.myshopify.com/products/switch-and-button-stickers http://store-xkcd-com.myshopify.com/products/switch-and-butt...
- nanofortnight 12y agoOne of my favourite stories growing up.
- reitanqild 12y agoI liked the story because I absolutely love arguing with people who will tell me to trust the map over the terrain. :-|
- sthreet 12y agoWhat does "trust the map over the terrain" mean?
- beachstartup 12y agowhen the map tells you one thing, and your eyes tell you another thing, go with what your eyes tell you, because the map is full of shit. you would be surprised how often people trust "the map" more than reality. "the map" can be anything, i.e. an instruction manual, an authority figure, folklore, a rumor, whatever.
- david-given 12y agoI'd stop and get a third opinion --- because sometimes my eyes are lying.
- stefs 12y agoone more beer, please
- melvinmt 12y ago> go with what your eyes tell you, but your eyes are also part of the map…
- Intermernet 12y agoExcept if you're a pilot flying in low visibility. Then you trust the map, not the terrain (mainly as the terrain is invisible). VFR vs. IFR and all that.
- tlear 12y agoMy dad's friend destroyed film he took of his wedding like that. He developed it himself, water felt hot to his finger but thermometer showed it right. He cooked it.. thermometer was broken. His wife was not amused!
- jimklee 12y agogreat story, although the whole time I was thinking of the appended 1994 explanation. wouldn't that be reasonable? too bad no one thought to measure the magic...
- devindotcom 12y agoI love things like this. In my old Dreamcast, I found after I'd packed it up and moved it a few too many times that it wouldn't start, but would show signs of life when the lid would open and close. I found that there was a position you could put the lid in at which it would boot, and that position could be reliably reached if a SweeTart was placed in the tray near the edge of the disc. I licked the flat side of the SweeTart a few times and it stayed where it was, and it's there to this day. Of course, the lock doesn't engage so I have to keep something heavy on top of it. And on my PS2, I'd fiddled around with it too much trying to mod it, and messed up something in there, but not bad enough that it wouldn't boot and play a game. But about 3/4 of the way through Resident Evil 4, I found it would skip and eventually reset if you didn't tilt it up by 20 degrees or so. As I progressed in the game, the angle at which it had to be set increased, until eventually not only did it have to be tilted in a second direction as well. Believe it or not, it finally reached the point where no tilt could save it in the middle of the final boss, with my friend moving it this way and that like we were trying to get reception with bunny ears on an old TV. I never beat the game.
- mikeryan 12y agoWay back in the day I did EA Technical Support (on DOS games!) Anyway the PS2 had a known issue where turning it on its side or over would put the CD closer to the reading laser and "fix it" it was really the only tangible fix the guys in the PlayStation queue had.
- david-given 12y agoI've just carried a second hand mixer deck home on the bus. While waiting for my stop, I noticed that if I moved my hand near the left VU meter, the needle would swing. Not much, but a little. It only worked on the left one. I didn't have to touch the case. And no, it wasn't plugged into anything. I'd just ruled out random motion caused by me joggling the deck as I moved my hand when I had to get off. It doesn't do it any more.
- Johnythree 12y agoStatic Electricity. The meter movement is very delicately balanced, plus the plastic window can become charged. Waving your hand around affects the charge. You've just invented the Electroscope.
- peterwwillis 12y agoUh... How was this not obvious from looking at it? Every geek who's put together or taken apart a computer knows the metal frame is grounded, and most geeks have enough basic understanding of electricity to understand you only need one wire for a ground. The switch enables or disables grounding. Since that is literally the only thing it can do, that is what it does.
- myth_buster 12y agoI think we are talking late '60s here. Perhaps we are better off now with accessible electronics.
- kbob 12y agoI agree that it's great to be able to get a SBC for the price of lunch, and that just wasn't possible in the 1970s. But the AI Lab PDP-10s were extremely accessible. I walked right up to them several times, and I was never affiliated with the Lab. (I was an undergrad.) The Lab wasn't exactly open to the public, but they didn't actually keep anyone out either. The PDP-10 itself was mostly discrete logic, so you could see the components and their interconnections just by looking at them. In addition, DEC published full schematics for most of their products. (I never saw the PDP-10 schematics, but it would be unusual if they weren't available.) If that wasn't enough, Alan Kotok, the architect, came by TMRC every couple of weeks and was more than happy to expound on any part of the system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Kotok https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alan_Kotok https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tech_Model_Railroad_Club https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tech_Model_Railroad_Club
- snowwindwaves 12y agomost switches don't have one terminal internally connected to the switch body, which then may or may not be connected to ground (or some other potential) depending on what it is mounted on.
- tempestn 12y agoYou're close, but not quite there. The ground plane of the machine was almost certainly grounded either way. But this switch likely introduces a connection to a separate ground, resulting in a ground loop. When you disconnect that loop it's not surprising at all that you would get a bit of a voltage spike in the ground plane, hence the crash. (I was a power electronics engineer a few years ago, before getting into the web.)
- myth_buster 12y agoWas hit by the nostalgia of reading Hackers [0]. What a great prank but quite an extreme dike. [0] http://www.amazon.com/Hackers-Computer-Revolution-Anniversary-Edition/dp/1449388396 http://www.amazon.com/Hackers-Computer-Revolution-Anniversar...
- pimlottc 12y agoShould be tagged (1994), although it appears the earliest version of this story goes back to Dec 1990! http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-2.2.1.dos.txt http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-2.2.1.dos.txt
- sctb 12y agoThanks, we updated the title.
- syntheticnature 12y agoPretty sure it's older than that I recalled seeing it in this book, which Amazon gives a date of 1983 on (fits well enough with when I recall coming across the book in a public library): http://www.amazon.com/Hackers-Dictionary-Guide-Computer-Wizards/dp/0060910828/ http://www.amazon.com/Hackers-Dictionary-Guide-Computer-Wiza... Also, it's in the 1.5.0 file: http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-1.5.0.dos.txt http://jargon-file.org/archive/jargon-1.5.0.dos.txt
- pimlottc 12y agoInteresting, it seems to have disappeared between 1.5.0 and 2.2.1!
- syntheticnature 12y agoThat is interesting -- I didn't check the 2.x revisions, and it only seems to be in 1.5.0 -- though I didn't try to go through all the intermediate files, simply stopping at a failure to find it in the previous one.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mmastrac 12y agoMy favorite was "always mount a scratch monkey": http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/S/scratch-monkey.html http://www.catb.org/jargon/html/S/scratch-monkey.html
- rnprince 12y agoI love this story. It's mythology from the dawn of Computer Science - like a chapter from Genesis.
- caramelsuit 12y agoAhhh yes, the compulsive need of the reasoning mind to neatly categories all events, circumstances and situations. I just love exploiting that.
- billyhoffman 12y agoI was really really hoping this would be the background of the magic number file "magic", and the `file` command... oh well. Completely different, but still a fun story.
- slumos 12y agoI've been periodically thinking about a tattoo based on this story for actual decades. Anyone know of any art based on it?
- Orangeair 12y agoXkcd sells a set of stickers which includes a magic/more magic pair: http://store.xkcd.com/products/switch-and-button-stickers http://store.xkcd.com/products/switch-and-button-stickers