2 ms·
It's a bit disingenuous to claim that you shouldn't pay back any of the debt incurred in earning your degree because the educational program was worthless when
by vinceguidry 12y ago
It's a bit disingenuous to claim that you shouldn't pay back any of the debt incurred in earning your degree because the educational program was worthless when you're still seeking a career in the field requiring that degree.
I agree she shouldn't have to pay all of the debt, but surely the degree isn't totally worthless.
- mattmanser 12y agoShe got ripped off by a school, so should now give up her dreams of becoming a nurse. Great argument.
- vinceguidry 12y agoNo, she should start a career in whatever field she's best positioned to start one in. Oh is that nursing? I wonder why.
- jessaustin 12y agoPresumably she had planned to become an LPN or RN. Her current position would not have required a degree, and to get to those other levels she must now still attend a different school. Corinthian wasted her time and her money.
- mikeash 12y agoPost hoc ergo propter hoc is supposed to be a warning, not a guide!
- whafro 12y agoOnly if the degree is the sole factor in getting the career she desired. If that's the case, I can send you a degree from WhafroU via PDF for a tidy sum within an hour. Get in touch, folks!
- vinceguidry 12y agoYou absolutely should start selling paper degrees if your 'students' can actually get jobs with them, as the person in the article was able to. I don't think people really understand what they're saying when they say that people shouldn't have to pay back these loans. The loans are going to get repayed, it's just a question of who. You can't take it out of the defunct college, those people, and that money, are gone. Basically you're saying that taxpayers should foot the bill. You want to pay the government back out of your own pocket? Because that's what this means.
- smtddr 12y agoIf paying money out of my own pocket means I've helped people who were _scammed_ into crushing debt while holding a near worthless degree that they've spent prime years of their life working for; time that they cannot get back.... then yes, I don't mind paying for that. I wish more people cared about society as a whole instead of jumping straight to the argument "If they don't pay, then the taxpayers will and that's you!!!" that supposedly shuts down all discussion. And anyways, we shouldn't even be debating this. University should be free, period. And yes, I know "free" = "we" = "our pockets". That's perfectly fine. Or we should start funding plane tickets and visas to send low income people to these countries[1] for study; requiring them to maintain a quality GPA or something. The world would be a better place for all of us if the "haves" weren't so adverse to paying for the "have-nots". 1. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2014/10/29/7-countries-where-americans-can-study-at-universities-in-english-for-free-or-almost-free/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2014/10/29...
- vinceguidry 12y agoWhat about the people who were just scammed a little? The people who just don't want to have to look hard to find a job after they graduate and so just want to call their degree worthless and get their loan canceled? Because as soon as you draw the line, people are going to challenge where it lies. It's really dangerous to allow someone to externalize all of the consequences of a particular bad decision. Altruism's great and all, but you need to think very hard about what it means to provide a benefit to everyone. It's not just the people who were legitimately scammed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Zigurd 12y ago> "...because the educational program was worthless when you're still seeking a career in the field requiring that degree" That doesn't follow at all. The program could have been deficient. The placement program could have been fraudulent. And yet the student could make up the deficiency with other training and compete, as hopeless as that might be, against others in the same boat. It isn't unusual for schools to defraud students by gaming placement by, for example, providing a pitiful amount of seed money for business majors to set off in a leaky lifeboat, or by forcing law students in lower-tier law schools to drop out before graduating. You also have to consider that debt repayment in constant payments pays down very little principle at first. A student may have paid a lot of interest, but their debt remains high.
- vinceguidry 12y agoSo what is the solution here? Make taxpayers foot the bill for the social costs incurred by awful colleges? Once you make that decision, then the line drawn in the sand about what an 'awful college' is and which costs the colleges and students alike can expect taxpayers to be liable for is going to shift over time. You're trading one enormous problem for another one. She should have known that for-profit colleges are bullshit before signing her life away to one. Now she wants to have her cake and eat it too by refusing to pay her loans, while still deriving benefit from the supposedly worthless degree she got. We need a better solution to higher education. But this isn't it. I'm glad she's raising awareness of this issue, but she and everyone else involved needs to pay back at least some of her loan. You can't just expect the government to absolve you of your bad decisions.
- Zigurd 12y agoThe other parties to the deal, namely the banks and schools, are far more culpable than the students. Let the banks and schools sue each other over the money owed. They are the ones that bought the laws and regulations than enable them to sell duff diplomas and finance those duff diplomas.
- vinceguidry 12y ago