4 ms·
It exists for one reason and one reason only: Because the professors, department, and college cause it to happen. They choose to assign a $150 textbook instead
by Someone1234 12y ago
It exists for one reason and one reason only:
Because the professors, department, and college cause it to happen. They choose to assign a $150 textbook instead of picking something else, they choose to likely get kickbacks from the publisher (e.g. free lesson materials, free teachers edition, free grading, etc) and they choose to ignore their duty as guardians to educational access. They're sellouts.
Publishers and authors are designed to make as much money as possible. It is their legal and moral imperative. It isn't even the publisher who forced you to buy that $150 textbook, they didn't assign it, they didn't fail to include it in tuition, they just sold it in the open market.
I want John Oliver to do a bit on this topic. However as long as people continue to blame the publishers it will never get fixed. If people started [correctly] blaming the schools/professors/departments/etc and actually started to complain in that direction, things would change for the positive.
Think about who actually forced you to buy that book, and that is the answer for who you should be mad at. I'd honestly like to see legislation that forced public colleges and universities to include all books in the tuition, that way students can compare the relative cost because two classes (e.g. one assigning $150 books, and one assigning $50 books).
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoSometimes the schools' hands are tied. The publishers use planned obsolescence to force the newer editions on students. If you can't buy new copies of older, cheaper books then there is no alternative but the shiny new wallet gougers.
- Someone1234 12y ago> Sometimes the schools' hands are tied. You haven't explained a scenario when that is the case. I will fully admit that sometimes individual professor's hands are tied (by the department, school, or college) but I won't conceded a school cannot find an alternative if they had any desire to.
- rokhayakebe 12y agoHas anyone tried to make it easy for teachers/others to create and sell their own digital textbooks? That may be a solution.
- Someone1234 12y agoFor some classes there are "open source" (free) textbooks which they could be using. These are readily used in Europe and India. They just choose not to because the publishers are literally helping professors with lesson plans and grading in some cases.
- bsder 12y ago> Because the professors, department, and college cause it to happen. They choose to assign a $150 textbook instead of picking something else, they choose to likely get kickbacks from the publisher (e.g. free lesson materials, free teachers edition, free grading, etc) and they choose to ignore their duty as guardians to educational access. They're sellouts. I'm offended ... I'm still waiting for my kickback from the publishers for the books I choose for my classes ... anyhow ... If I choose that expensive textbook for my class, it's probably because I think you need the book even outside of my class. Cormen, Leiserson, Rivest--"Introduction to Algorithms" is about $100. Yes, it's expensive, but it's an important book for your professional reference. A programmer better have a copy of that on the bookshelf. And before you get too huffy about your lecturers, you might want to consider that anyone lecturing in your class who isn't full-time, tenure tack is probably getting about $5,000 for one class for the semester (I know this to be true for UCal system and Stanford). Given the amount of time it takes to teach, working at McDonald's probably pays better.
- Spooky23 12y agoBack in the 90s, a big controversy on my campus was the Barnes and Noble takeover of the school bookstore, which had previously been run by the university's auxiliary services (3 old ladies + work/study students). Part of the deal was something like $5 million annual pledge to the university's struggling athletic program. (Ie. The kickback) In other cases, the corruption was more blatant... Like the department where all books were authored by professors in the department. In my example, I used the accounting textbooks as an egregious example, because accounting 101 is pretty cut and dry, and a professor time traveling from 1980 could teach it today. Engineering is a little different, and the textbooks tend to be more niche and have more lasting value. There's a difference between a technical reference and s $75 "Mercury Reader" that may largely consist of public domain works.