4 ms·
I'm going to focus on textbook (because it makes my point easier). To me there are three distinct issues with digital books: - Backlit displays give you eye st
by Someone1234 12y ago
I'm going to focus on textbook (because it makes my point easier). To me there are three distinct issues with digital books:
- Backlit displays give you eye strain and make reading less pleasant. This can be solved with eInk but then you lose colour diagrams/graphs and even the largest eInk device is smaller than a single textbook page (and the layout within textbooks is key to understanding in some cases).
- Saving multiple pages is very painful. Almost all ebook readers (both apps and devices) allow you to save your current page, close the "book," and then continue later. Very few allow you to tag multiple pages with "sticky notes" and then jump back to any of them.
- Some people like to highlight their $100 textbooks or to write notes on the pages. I am not one of these people, however that is a legitimate argument against buying the digital book. You rarely can do this type of thing.
Unfortunately eInk was here to save us, and I think as a technology it hasn't really succeeded. It gained popularity for a brief period, but then the iPad got popular and people just decided to read on the device they already own (and then give up, and buy paper copies because it was so unpleasant).
So unless someone invents an RGB eInk device, I think we'll be stuck with either paper books or terrible backlit flicky displays forever. Too bad if you ask me.
- stdbrouw 12y agoHm, I'm going to guess that the Kindle is probably the most popular e-reader, and it has the ability to add notes, highlights and bookmarks, both with the hardware device and in the apps for tablets and computers. It also doesn't have the eye strain issue. Actual remaining issues: * complex layouts get messed up, as you mention * it's not very easy to leaf through an ebook and to quickly jump from section to section That said, I still read 90% of my course materials on my Kindle, Kindle app for OS X or Mendeley. For all its disadvantages, having a digital overview of all of your annotations is a godsend when doing research or studying for an exam. For that same reason, I don't take paper notes anymore: while convenient, often they get lost, you can't search through them and you can't edit them.
- mszyndel 12y ago> it's not very easy to leaf through an ebook and to quickly jump from section to section This is available on Kindle for quite some time now. Tap on top to show menu and then slide you finder on bottom bar - preview of pages will show and you can look back and forth without changing your current position.
- stdbrouw 12y agoIt's an improvement, but not nearly as easy to use as leafing through a physical book. I'm thinking of the use-case where you're solving exercises in one place but also want to sometimes go back to the theory or to a reference section in the back.
- taeric 12y agoThis is probably as easily solved by just having multiple ereaders, honestly.
- lione 12y agoHave an ereader for every book! It's flawless!
- taeric 12y agoWithin reason, it probably is cheaper and more workable for many people to just have two or three ebook readers than the myriad of physical books and shelving necessary for them. Additionally, for textbook style things, it was already common to have "student handbooks" that go along with the book.
- drzaiusapelord 12y ago>Backlit displays give you eye strain Switching to a black background with white or gray text has pretty much eliminated this for me. Especially if you read at night or at least have auto-brightness enabled. The problem I'm seeing is that we're treating digital devices as paper books. We use a bright white background which is shooting a lot of photos into our eyes and wondering why its an uncomfortable experience. I just don't think we've figured out the best way to make this stuff work. I doubt emulating books is the wisest choice here. I also don't see eink as our savior. The text always looked grainy and unfocused to me and the loss of color is inexcusable.
- freehunter 12y agoDo you use an OLED screen by any chance? A lot of Android phones have these, including some of the Samsung Galaxy phones. In OLED, the black pixels actually emit no light. With LCD, black pixels are just colored black, but the backlight is still emitting light. The reason I ask is because in the case of white-on-black with OLED, there actually is significantly less light coming out. With LCD, it's really only the appearance of less light (obviously that's simplified, there are ways to make LCD panels emit less light when it's showing black).
- mortenjorck 12y agoWith LCD, it's really only the appearance of less light (obviously that's simplified, there are ways to make LCD panels emit less light when it's showing black) Whoa, hold on there. It’s not “the appearance of less light” - it is less light because the backlight is being occluded by the LCD subpixels. The subpixels aren’t perfect at blocking the light, thus the varying grays of LCD blacks versus the pure blacks of OLED, but a black LCD screen is most assuredly emitting (if not producing) less light than a white one.
- freehunter 12y agoMan you even quoted the part where I said "obviously that's simplified". Black OLED pixels emit no light. Black LCD pixels emit > 0 light.
- lambdacore 12y ago> Backlit displays give you eye strain and make reading less pleasant This claim is certainly common, but what is the actual mechanism for a backlit display inducing more eyestrain than e-Ink? I think it has more to do with screen brightness relative to environment more than screen technology.