3 ms·
Because anti-GMO is so often scaremongering. Nobody is terrified that every new app on your phone is skynet. Yet every new GMO food is poison. Its just silly.
by JoeAltmaier 12y ago
Because anti-GMO is so often scaremongering. Nobody is terrified that every new app on your phone is skynet. Yet every new GMO food is poison. Its just silly.
- tzs 12y agoWe do worry, though, that new apps might be sending our personal information and movements to advertisers and governments. My worry with GMO is not that EVERY such food will be poison, or even that SOME such food will be poison. It's simply that GMO is a much more powerful tool for modifying organisms than the current tools like selective breeding. More powerful tools allow for greater good, but also allow for greater harm (deliberate or accidental). Thus, more powerful tools require more wisdom to use than do less powerful tools. A great philosopher once observed, "With great power comes great responsibility". I am simply not convinced that mass market food producers have the wisdom to use the great power of GMO with great responsibility. To put it in phone app terms, when GMO shows up in my groceries or in my fast food drive-through take out bag, I want it to have come from an Apple-style market, not an Android-style market.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> It's simply that GMO is a much more powerful tool for modifying organisms than the current tools like selective breeding. Both inherently and due to levels of regulatory scrutiny (which may not be as much as some people like, but is still more than techniques of inducing genetic changes that are classed as "traditional" breeding) it is a much more controlled tool that other current tools like selective breeding. OTOH, I'm not sure its more powerful (in terms of greater potential for change) than modern "selective breeding" techniques; from talking in to people who do work with both GMO and modern selective breeding techniques, I think that a lot of the public impression along those lines is driven by an outdated, romanticized view about "selective breeding".