8 ms·
I think the main point of the story is not to convince us that he has a good proof. But rather to document how we convince ourselves, and how we latch on to sma
by rdtsc 12y ago
I think the main point of the story is not to convince us that he has a good proof. But rather to document how we convince ourselves, and how we latch on to small things and head down a path. Once we are on a path we become commited to it and it becomes hard to turn back.
Notice how he talks about the "crazies" on the forum. How they would use aliases, log back in and mention their stupid "lightning" theory, and he had to kick them out.
However, he then carefully proceeds to discribe how he did pretty much the same. Spent his own money and time building this complicated theory of super smart and efficient russian spies hacking into a satcom of a flying aircraft, also somehow, incapacitation everyone else on board, etc. In the meantime he is dropping clues how his own wife doesn't even believe him.
I think many people here, judging by the comments, misunderstood the goal of the article and took it too literaly.
But, there is a good lesson here. This stuff happens if you program and design software. There are lot of moving parts and lot of imperfect knowledge -- market needs, tools, langauges, platforms, APIs, architectures desicions, etc etc. Sometimes if you start to "just write code" too early. You end up committed to a bad path and it becomes hard mentally to throw it away and restart. Or, alternatively, you spend so much time picking the right combination of tools or redesigning the system that it becomes too later to do anything (someone else already built the system or there is no need for it anymore somehow).
- viraptor 12y agoSounds similar to how the extended rocket car story from cDc was written (http://www.cultdeadcow.com/cDc_files/cDc-0363.php http://www.cultdeadcow.com/cDc_files/cDc-0363.php) - it's a long story with a lot of background, including friends, past friend/family reactions, current as-author-writes-it friend/family reactions, technical details, diagrams, step-by-step ideas as they were developed and worked/failed in testing. There's also a lot of "this is a story of how I acted as a silly teenager, it was not a great idea" kind of self-mocking. It shows how much a good story-telling can go with convincing others that you know the truth.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoThere is another side to this lesson. I cannot count the amount of times I've read about scientists in the past getting ridiculed for some "crackpot" theory only to be vindicated later. A perfect example is Ohm's law: "Ohm's initial publication was met with ridicule and dismissal; called "a tissue of naked fantasy." Approx. twenty years passed before scientists began to recognize its great importance." The site here has a whole list of these "maverick scientists": http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html#j9 http://amasci.com/weird/vindac.html#j9 I think the other lesson we need to consider is, just because an idea appears to be crazy, doesn't mean it is... The Author, by presenting his theory in a way that also illustrates his awareness of the possibility that he himself is also crazy, was able to get it published by the New Yorker as a symbolic piece on the dangers of getting sucked into a conspiracy theory. If this was his plan, I think it's a good one as there's too many technical summaries, pictures and diagrams for this not be an article that is in part promoting a conspiracy theory.
- tbabb 12y ago> I cannot count the amount of times I've read about scientists in the past getting ridiculed for some "crackpot" theory only to be vindicated later. People love to point to underdog scientists who were later "vindicated" and then compare their own pet theories to them. 1) That's incredibly arrogant. 2) That disregards the 10^n other theories that are discredited correctly every day. 3) The scientists who "nobody believed" were right because they did an incredible amount of very careful, thorough research which bolstered their case well past the point where it could be ignored. They weren't wild hunches. > published by the New Yorker New York Magazine. Big difference there.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoLets make it clear. I'm not vindicating his theory I'm saying it's equally ignorant to not consider a theory because it just seems improbable.
- tbabb 12y agoA theory being improbable is probably the best reason not to give it credit. A theory should be accepted only when the null hypothesis is more improbable.
- crimsonalucard 12y agokeywords: "seems improbable" Just because something SEEMS improbable doesn't actually mean it IS improbable.
- gjem97 12y agoWhen the probability describes the likelihood of our data matching a particular theory, there is only "seems improbable". E.g. it seems improbable that there are other yet undetected Pluto-sized objects in the solar system. Is it improbable? No, it's either true that there are such objects or not. As opposed to events that have not occurred. E.g. it seems improbable that ten flips of a fair coin will yield ten heads. Is it improbable? Yes by most definitions of improbable, it is improbable.
- kevin_nisbet 12y agoThis was also the part I found most interesting. Over the past several months, I've been putting an increasing level of thought into how people reach conclusions and investigate technical problems, and looking at things like confirmation bias, and I see it happen in myself and others. The best example I have, is a vendor I work with had an outage in their platform, and we spent weeks going through the data, where the vendor jumped to a conclusion about the cause of the outage, even though it poorly or in no way explained the data we had compiled. No matter how hard I tried, I was not able to convince this vendor that the conclusion they reached was incorrect, every piece of evidence, was manipulated in a way to explain their theory. That is until they developed the fix, applied it, and had another outage occur after they thought they fixed it. It troubles me, to know that we wasted so much effort, due to these biases. While not 100% related, one story I like to remind myself of to try and disrupt my own biases, goes something along the lines of: - A little girl was helping her mom make banana bread one day, and asks her mom, why do you cut the ends off before you serve it. - The mom replies, I don't know, that's the way my mom always made it. - Next they ask the girls grand mother, why did you cut the ends off the bread - She replies, I don't know that's the way I always made it. - They manage to ask the great grand mother, why did you cut the ends off... - The response was, my serving plate was too small, so I used to cut the ends off so it would fit on the plate. If anyone knows the attribution for that story, it would be great, I'm unable to find it so my recollection is probably wrong. However, I still really like this story, as I use it as a way to remind myself and others, that we need to be ready to question everything, when it comes to understanding a problem. It doesn't mean that we can afford to question every bias, but it does mean that we need to gain enough evidence to corroborate any theory that may come up, or if necessary, invalidate it. Where I work, I believe it's something we need to spend greater effort on, is questioning our biases and make sure we're reaching the right conclusions.
- TheSpiceIsLife 12y agoThe first time I read that story it was about roast beef, so I'm guessing there's a number of variations and adaptations.
- imron 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gfdgh54yhgf 12y agoWell said.
- tbabb 12y agoI don't think the average reader is going to interpret this as subtle irony, and I have doubts that it was intended to be taken that way. I think an average reader going to see that an airplane expert smells something fishy and has a bunch of technical "knowledge" to back it up. This is how conspiracy theories get started, and if this guy really understands how unlikely all this is, it is arguably irresponsible of him to put it forward. What kind of journalism gets published with such little substantiation? Nobody, not even the tinfoil hat-wearers in his own forum take him seriously, but because he's a cable news expert, his credibility means a million people hear his shitty pet idea. And plenty of people are going to take it at face value.
- Klinky 12y agoI think a large portion of the conspiracy theorist population probably has a mental illness that makes them susceptible to delusional thinking. Delusional people can lead very normal fully functioning lives, but mix a certain topic that offers patterns which make their brain go down a certain path, and they suddenly become very adamant about believing something that is illogical and irrational. There is probably little someone can do to really stop conspiracy theories. People certainly shouldn't censor themselves.
- Potando 12y agoI don't think it counts as a disease if the majority of people, including most successful people "suffer" from it without any negative consequences for themselves. For example religion.
- Klinky 12y agoA mental illness does not have to result in major negative side effects to be considered an illness. People can live very normal looking lives, while also having delusional thoughts.
- scrollaway 12y agoOr maybe this obsession with calling absolutely everything that doesn't fit the everyday-narrower definition of a "normal person" a mental illness needs to stop. Next thing you know, "People who don't want to be snooped on by the government have a mental illness and don't understand why it's a good thing."
- joepvd 12y agoI took this excellent story the same as you did. For me, this is the central point: My gut still tells me I’m right, but my brain knows better than to trust my gut. This is a nice phrasing of one of the things one has to come to term with while becoming a computer professional.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoBeware, there are many times where my gut has been right over my logic. Don't deny the intelligence of your gut. Your brain has subconscious processes that are just as intelligent as your conscious processes. Your gut often does follow some kind of logic, it's just you don't have access to what it did to arrive at that uneasy feeling in your stomach. Though you don't realize it but our ability to see in three dimensions is a subconscious process. If you look at a cube you cannot choose how or when you process that image. In fact you don't even have a choice, once you look at a cube your brain forces you to know what you're looking at. Additionally, you don't even know what your brain did to interoperate that image as a cube. Yet you do know that there is some powerful subconscious calculation going on that derives that analysis. In short, don't underestimate your gut.
- ghshephard 12y agoI thought that he was being pretty clear throughout the article that this was a description of his personal journey into becoming a "believer" - despite how ludicrous what he was believing in. I'm hoping that nobody seriously believes the NYT published this article backing the belief that MH 370 didn't crash. I mean, it starts with the title of the story - the key line in this entire story is this: And yet, once I started looking for evidence, I found it. And, just in case people hadn't picked up on his actual thesis, he explicitly states it near the end: "Still, it occurred to me that, for all the passion I had for my theory, I might be the only person in the world who felt this way. Neurobiologist Robert A. Burton points out in his book "On Being Certain" that the sensation of being sure about one’s beliefs is an emotional response separate from the processing of those beliefs."
- lobster_johnson 12y agoNew York Magazine, not NYT. NYMag is not affiliated. Someone else here confused it with the New Yorker. NYMag is a light entertainment/gossip magazine with NY coverage. Nobody takes NYMag seriously.
- sebastianavina 12y agoas a true geek, if someday something wrong happens to me, I hope that at least, someone jumps in and invents a story about how smart and bad ass I am, that I invented a teletransportation device, and translated the entire airplane/car or whatever to the anothe time and space, just because. truly, those poor folks are probably dead now, and now there is this guy saying that they kidnapped the airplane and buried it just because they had this evil master plan "???".