3 ms·
When I was in graduate school, I was somewhat involved in the process of hiring a few professors. Whoever we would have hired was probably going to get tenure a
by twblalock 12y ago
When I was in graduate school, I was somewhat involved in the process of hiring a few professors. Whoever we would have hired was probably going to get tenure and remain in the department for decades. Intangible personal and interpersonal aspects of the candidates were therefore about as important as the quality of their research, because nobody wants to be stuck working for 20 years with someone they don't feel comfortable with. Naturally, this has a tendency to perpetuate the gender and race imbalances in academia.
- tsotha 12y agoGender and race imbalances are much less important to me than ideological imbalances. What's the point of having different sexes and skin colors if they're all part of an echo chamber?
- daughart 12y agoWhat fields do you find having an academic "echo chamber"?
- tsotha 12y agoNearly all the soft sciences, including economics.
- carlob 12y agoI've seen it in theoretical physics as well. There are 'schools of thought', for example at my alma mater most of the professors doing theoretical particle physics are phenomenologists and tend to regard people doing say string theory as cranks. This means it's very hard for those people to get hired, and there is also the effect of them not wanting to apply to a university that doesn't have a strong tradition or a strong group in their subfield.