6 ms·
I’ve Just Seen a (DNA-Generated) Face
- hackuser 12y agoThere's another story about the technology's accuracy and its application in law enforcement, here: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/24/science/building-face-and-a-case-on-dna.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/02/24/science/building-face-and-...
- orta 12y agoThis happened to me, an artist took the DNA from my github and created my face back in 2013. Cool stuff. https://github.com/orta/dna https://github.com/orta/dna
- jessedhillon 12y agoDo you have a photo of your face in roughly the same pose for comparison? Also, why does the nose look so faceted?
- ap22213 12y agoI wanted to do something similar last year, but I figured that I'd need a lot of input data to classify on facial features. Where do people get the input data?
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoThe article notes that they used data from 23andme, a commercial DNA profiling service that is $100.
- grandalf 12y agoThose are the results with a training set of 7000, I imagine it would get spookily accurate with a 50K training set.
- iopq 12y agoProbably not. There's diminishing returns with higher samples. If your extra 43K samples follow the same general pattern (without adding some outliers that will give new patterns) it won't look any different. You'd have to capture some gene that gives a difference in appearance that the 7K didn't.
- dvanduzer 12y agoWhere'd you get that number?
- grandalf 12y agoJust a guess. The faces were pretty close but for a few angles here and there.
- dvanduzer 12y agoI couldn't figure out what a training set of any size would even mean. Taking X number of DNA sequences paired with real photographs, and then extrapolating to DNA sequences without a photograph? That might do something interesting if someone tried it, but I don't think it's that kind of technique at all.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- dogma1138 12y agoQuite interesting however the portraits really have almost no resemblance to the subjects. Yeah they look kinda "similar" but virtually every facial feature other than base racial feature is incorrect. All of the renderings attempt to pretty much render a racially correct "grey face" which can pretty much fit almost anyone. Everything else from the shape and position of the eyes, nose bridge, cheekbones, lips etc. doesn't match the real photographs. I really hope that this doesn't reach law enforcement because those sketches will fit every "average" person in their respective racial group, and it even seem to get the ethnic group wrong in at least 1 out of the 3 renderings...
- heurist 12y agoAgreed. It seems like nutrition, illness/disease, and random developmental quirks would all drastically affect the actual shape of a human's face between birth and adulthood. You might be able to predict a range of faces to account for these differences, I guess, but then you have a broad range of faces that might match a broad range of people...
- kyberias 12y agoWHAT? No! Have you forgotten the fact that identical twins actually look...well, identical? Face features clearly have a very very very very high heritability.
- excuse-me-sir 12y agoTwins share the same environment in the 1st 9 months, when their faces are formed.
- kyberias 12y agoUsually yes but that doesn't change the fact that face features are highly hereditary. I find it very hard to believe that someone could try to deny this. It's basic biology really. What are you suggesting here exactly? What exactly is the environmental trigger in the womb that forms the faces if not genes? May I kindly remind you about the concept of dizygotic twins, that is, twins that share the womb but do not share an identical genome. Please explain why they don't look identical.
- rl3 12y agoImagine people with stunted growth or disfigurement as a result of non-genetic circumstance, using a more accurate form of this technology to see what they would have looked like otherwise. Profoundly sad to think about. On the other hand, one possible use for such renderings could be to guide reconstructive medical procedures.
- personjerry 12y agoI've been waiting to see something like this, it's very neat (if somewhat unrefined). Now apply OldBooth and we'll be able to see what our babies will look like. Brave New World here we come!
- sparaker 12y agoI think it will need another 5 years of development before we can get even near that.
- pimlottc 12y agoSilly me, I thought everybody's face was DNA-generated...
- balabaster 12y agoMy gut reaction to this was so what we've all seen DNA generated faces our whole lives... and nobody finds that in any way remarkable...
- TaylorAlexander 12y agoThe old way took tens of years and a couple hundred thousands of dollars in food and board. Plus there is no way in nature to take a DNA sample left at a crime scene and turn that into a rendering of a face. Now it can be done with $100 worth of DNA analysis and a few minutes of compute time.
- jqm 12y agoEnvironment plays a large role in facial appearance. Weight, diet, habitual emotional expressions, facial hair, to say nothing of acne, injuries, facial exercises (for the muscles in the face) or reconstructive surgery. Maybe they could divine how close the eyes are or how big the nose is... but even that doesn't seem terribly accurate from these picture. I suppose the technique will get better soon enough, but I doubt anything approaching publicly recognizable accuracy will be achieved by this method alone.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoThe inaccuracy can't be solely attributed to environment. Many identical twins who share identical DNA that are separated at birth still share remarkably similar facial features. If two faces generated by identical strands of DNA in the real world remain identical, despite being grown in different environments then an accurate simulation of DNA should reproduce an accurate face regardless of environment. The inaccuracy arrives from the black box statistical process they use to generate the face. They don't know the full story behind how billions of strands of DNA can scaffold a physical face made out of billions of cells, nerves and blood vessels. Instead they just measure a bunch of faces relate it back to certain known attributes in the DNA and then generate a face. This process will always be inaccurate. In short they treat the system like a black box and build a simulation of the black box by only establishing correlations between input and output. Imagine if some alien race used this type of process in attempt to analyze the linux operating system running on a computer. They measure the electrical output of each pixel in the monitor and they find statistical correlations between pixel configurations in the monitor and the arrangement of bits in the cpu register. Using this process the Aliens can only gain a very flawed understanding of what's actually happening.
- dvanduzer 12y agoThere isn't really room for anything between this method and outright cloning, is there?