2 ms·
Yes, but rightly or wrongly, the published reasons are broad so as to minimize exposure to lawsuits. Meaning that if they had to be specific, they would have l
by mc32 12y ago
Yes, but rightly or wrongly, the published reasons are broad so as to minimize exposure to lawsuits. Meaning that if they had to be specific, they would have less ability to fire people arbitrarily. They would have to have detailed records on why someone was not up to par, rather than the nebulous, reasons which are in common use these days and pass muster. Many times people are singled out retroactively, ie., in retaliation, or simply not being of same mind with new management or philosophy, irrespective of performance.
- tptacek 12y agoIt is explicitly acceptable in the US to fire people for nebulous reasons. We have a "default allow" policy here for firing, which (among other things) makes it much easier to start new companies, by lowering the stakes on hiring people. We all want the same good thing: the elimination of unfair employment actions. But we should take a long view on how we obtain that good. Considering a more Franco-European policy on employment, it's natural to think employment would be more "fair". But employer policy wouldn't be static given that change; they'd drastically alter both the way they accept new employees and the way they track performance to compensate for it. All that is just to say once again: you can't read too much out of a vague explanation for why someone was terminated (or, in this case, "managed out").
- mc32 12y agoI understand what's acceptable and normal. I just question why it's not questioned from time to time to see if it merits change. I'm looking at this from two sides. I've been an employee all my working life, one day I would want to run a business, so I have that in mind too. And I understand that sometimes one might want to fire someone 'just because'. It's just that in principle, 'just because' rubs me wrong. What I find ironic is that today's HR pretty much says "The reason we fired you is we have no reason" And it's totally acceptable. Do you see how perverse it's become. You can't state a reason for firing someone, because giving a reason exposes you to lawsuits, so, giving no reason, has become a good reason to fire people with. PS. I've been fired once in my life, while working to put myself thru college. Driver and I were making deliveries, it was late, he decided to skip the last delivery. Upon arrival at the workplace "insubordination". Which was great, got a better part time job after that.