5 ms·
So KPCB is retaliating with a civil lawsuit, claiming: >“lacked the ability to lead others, build consensus and be a team player, which is crucial to a success
by mc32 12y ago
So KPCB is retaliating with a civil lawsuit, claiming:
>“lacked the ability to lead others, build consensus and be a team player, which is crucial to a successful career as a venture capital senior investing partner.”
I won't pretend to know who did or said what, but language such as the above, is so broad as to mean nothing.
It's typical HR verbiage used when they want to pressure someone to quit, or get them outright fired. Whosoever presides over this, I hope they seek and drill for specifics, and demands comparison with other partners' specific performance, because on its surface, you can use this as an excuse to fire anyone. And it's a particularly maddening symptom, which may not have an easy solution. One person's "exceeds expectations", is the other person's, "failed to meet expectations", it's totally arbitrary. With that filter, I can see how one moment she's a star partner, the next she's accused of the above, as retaliation.
- mathattack 12y agoThe reality is it's very hard to have objective performance. Salespeople somewhat have it, but even then you don't know the performance of the deals until many years later. You can somewhat come up with it for VCs, but it takes many years to sort out talent vs luck vs good or bad markets. Observing the quality of decisions is by it's nature extremely subjective.
- tptacek 12y agoThat's their claimed reason for (constructively) terminating her, right? It's not the basis of an actual claim against Pao, but a defense of their own actions. It reads like standard HR speak for an exec termination.
- mc32 12y agoYes, that's correct, it's their defense. I think my claim is that this claim is so broad as to be meaningless. It can retroactively apply to anyone because it's very unspecific. My subtext is that because the language is so broad, it can be used to excuse any firing, with or without cause. And they may cite specifics, but in reality, they could come up with similar specifics and cause for people who have not been fired. It's somewhat similar to when there are explicit rules one must live or work by, but then there are implicit rules to follow, which allow skirting of the explicit rules. This then allows the implicit rules to be used against a transgressor of choice, since they broke the explicit rules. And that aspect makes it arbitrary.
- tptacek 12y agoReasons for termination usually are that broad. A broad explanation for a constructive termination isn't a strong signal in any direction. A person could be fired for gross incompetence, or for exploiting a conflict of interest, or for a grave personal indiscretion, and if the company was forced to announce that termination, they'd probably still be similarly broad. Real companies are extremely cautious about publishing reasons for letting people go. Remember as well the real goalposts: US companies are not required to document cause for terminating employees. The plaintiff in a discrimination suit bears the burden of proving that they were terminated for a legally prohibited reason. The defendant does not bear a burden of proving cause for termination. Employees are routinely terminated without legal cause, and (controversial but I think true) we're all better off for that.
- mc32 12y agoYes, but rightly or wrongly, the published reasons are broad so as to minimize exposure to lawsuits. Meaning that if they had to be specific, they would have less ability to fire people arbitrarily. They would have to have detailed records on why someone was not up to par, rather than the nebulous, reasons which are in common use these days and pass muster. Many times people are singled out retroactively, ie., in retaliation, or simply not being of same mind with new management or philosophy, irrespective of performance.
- tptacek 12y agoIt is explicitly acceptable in the US to fire people for nebulous reasons. We have a "default allow" policy here for firing, which (among other things) makes it much easier to start new companies, by lowering the stakes on hiring people. We all want the same good thing: the elimination of unfair employment actions. But we should take a long view on how we obtain that good. Considering a more Franco-European policy on employment, it's natural to think employment would be more "fair". But employer policy wouldn't be static given that change; they'd drastically alter both the way they accept new employees and the way they track performance to compensate for it. All that is just to say once again: you can't read too much out of a vague explanation for why someone was terminated (or, in this case, "managed out").