4 ms·
>Emerging in its place is the mostly white, male-dominated, monied monoculture of the tech industry and there appears no end in sight. It's weird to flinch at
by scythe 12y ago
>Emerging in its place is the mostly white, male-dominated, monied monoculture of the tech industry and there appears no end in sight.
It's weird to flinch at reading this. What am I, a racist? But this sentence just isn't true for me. I mean, sure, as the demographic majority there are a lot of white people in tech, but my experience just hasn't been "mostly white". At some meetings I've been the only white guy in the room: how much more diverse do we need to get, exactly?
What is the case where I work is that white people are far more likely to live in San Francisco, whereas the nonwhite immigrants seem to be a little more responsible and live in places like Fremont, Dublin, and Sunnyvale, and tolerate 90 minute commutes to do so. Which is not an aspect of the tech boom that a publication like The Guardian would ever emphasize, because a story about entrenched old hipsters making life difficult for people from Bombay who worked themselves to the bone just to get into the country -- that just doesn't fit the prevailing narrative -- nor does the fact that they're doing so to preserve a culture famous mostly for its reputation among America's majority demographic.
I mean, I'm not gonna deny that being white gives some tech workers (like me) an unfair advantage in life, which also happens to be true in roughly every single other American industry, but I've been exasperated by this enough to point out that the people opposing expansion are generally shortsighted hypocrites -- bring on the evictions, so that the nonwhites who comprise 75% of my scrum team can live in the city where they work, maybe.
And I'd like to apologize apostrophically for stealing my coworkers' right to represent themselves.
- swatow 12y agoIn this context, Indians and Asians count as White. Why? Because in the narrative of the author, Whiteness is not a race, but rather a social construct designed to reinforce the privilege of Whites, and to enforce a uniform way of thinking and acting. Whiteness also serves to create and justify economic disparity. In this narrative, anyone who accepts this system, reinforces its values, and receives the benefits of Whiteness, is effectively White.
- a8da6b0c91d 12y agoThe tech industry is disproportionately asian relative to the population of the nation. So the whole thing is especially goofy.
- swatow 12y agoAsians play a doubly unfortunate role in the anti racist movement. On the one hand, they share the same guilt as Whites, since they cooperate with and benefit from White society. On the other hand, anti Asian sentiment is used as an escape valve, allowing people to "harmlessly" express their racist feelings. It also is a way to pretend to allow freedom of expression, by allowing racial jokes about Asians, and criticism of Asian culture (which I see a lot of on HN).