3 ms·
> the universe as a whole is skewed in the forward direction, because its past endpoint was highly ordered, and its future endpoint is highly disordered. This
by lisper 12y ago
> the universe as a whole is skewed in the forward direction, because its past endpoint was highly ordered, and its future endpoint is highly disordered.
This is highly misleading. The arrow of time is not thermodynamic, it's quantum. It's defined by increased entanglement, not increased entropy.
http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-arrow-of-time.html http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...
- rndn 12y agoDoes increasing entanglement explain the second law of thermodynamics?
- lisper 12y agoAFAIK this is an open question. My guess would be that yes, it does. I'm also guessing that the first person who actually does the math to prove it will win the Nobel prize in physics.
- dnetesn 12y agoThis is another Nautilus article, by Julian Barbour, on the arrow of time. http://nautil.us/issue/9/time/the-mystery-of-times-arrow http://nautil.us/issue/9/time/the-mystery-of-times-arrow
- dnetesn 12y agoand this from Paul Davies on the flow of time. http://nautil.us/blog/where-did-time-come-from-and-why-does-it-seem-to-flow http://nautil.us/blog/where-did-time-come-from-and-why-does-...
- kordless 12y agoI was reading about computation the other day and stumbled upon a concept where something can't be computable if it requires more operations than there is energy in the universe to do the operations. While reading the post you linked to, it struck me that the speed of light is a similar barrier to us. We can't travel the speed of light. We always like to talk about it and what we would 'observe', but it's theoretically impossible for us to do.
- tbrownaw 12y agoThis is highly misleading. The arrow of time is not thermodynamic, it's quantum. It's defined by increased entanglement, not increased entropy. That's not at all what I remember from physics class when I was at university, and would seem to imply (incorrectly) that non-QM models can't produce an arrow of time.
- krohling 12y agoSo if time is the result of increasing entanglement, what does it imply that massive objects (i.e. black holes) slow time?
- lisper 12y agoGood question. I don't know. I suspect that answering it would require (or lead to) the unification of QM and GR.
- dchichkov 12y agoI actually tried checking, to see if 'retro-casually', at around 1 us timescale, a more 'entropic' outcome of otherwise perfectly balanced source of physical randomness would show up more often than it should. Used a 2-mbit source of randomness, been running the setup continuously to get a few terabits of data. Fixed a bunch of imbalances in the state-of-the-art commercially available source of physical randomness. Nope. Source code/results are available here: https://code.google.com/p/reasonable-deviations/source/browse/trunk/qrng/?r=31 https://code.google.com/p/reasonable-deviations/source/brows...
- tmvphil 12y agoWhy be so dogmatic? You can define an arrow of time going away from some initial ordered state even in a purely classical universe. No QM needed. Although the relationship between entanglement and entropy is worth considering for sure.
- nilkn 12y agoIs this an accepted viewpoint? I've never heard this before, and though I'm not a physicist I've certainly been taught that the arrow of time is thermodynamic.
- lisper 12y agoAccepted by who? It's probably not the mainstream view (yet), but that's because there's a ton of misinformation out there about QM. For example, many people (even many physicists) think that the "measurement problem" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Measurement_problem) is still a problem. It isn't, and hasn't been for a very long time (decades). The reason people think it's still a problem is that the solution requires accepting the fact (and it is a fact) that classical reality isn't really real, it's just a very good approximation, and a lot of people are (understandably) resistant to that idea.
- jeffwass 12y agoSorry, your grand statement matter-of-factly dismissing thermodynamic arrow of time needs a much better source than some computer scientist's armchair blog about QM. I know it's been recently trendy for armchair physicists to post grand philosophical claims about the universe from some vague understandings of Bell's Inequality and/or entanglement, and blurring the line between philosophy of physics with physics. But your casual dismissal of entropic thermodynamic arrow-of-time time in favor of purely increasing entanglement ranks way high on the BS meter. For context - I have a PhD in experimental condensed-matter physics, and TA'd thermodynamics and statistical mechanics for several years. I left the field of physics many years ago so maybe there were some notable recent developments in quantum information theory that I missed. But I skimmed your linked article and can't take it seriously. Would love a better source of you can provide one, eg peer-reviewed (in a respectable physics journal) or written by an actual career physicist at a reputable institution.
- lisper 12y agohttp://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605002 This doesn't discuss the arrow-of-time directly, but it's a pretty straightforward corollary.
- jeffwass 12y agoCheers for the article, quite interesting. I'd still maintain the original comment in the original article is correct, that the arrow of time is still driven by 'thermodynamic' processes, where I'm allowing thermodynamic really means statistical mechanical process, and statistical mechanics includes (as it always has) quantum statistics of quantum processes. Ie, your arxiv link gives further quantum detail of the underlying macroscopic measurements (eg, the schrodinger cat example). But the irreversibility and arrow-of-time come from the enanglement of the particle with the 10^23 atoms of the macroscopic observer system. And in that sense the irreversibility is more due to the large size of the system, just like a classical example (such as shaking a bottle of originally separated black/white marbles) than the fact that there is quantum entanglement between the particle and the measurement system. So while Cerf and Adami identified interesting quantum processes to describe underlying interactions, the irreversibility still comes from a statistical consideration of the interaction with a macroscopically large system. Just like the traditional arrow-of-time statement that you had originally refuted.
- SilasX 12y agoWhat's the difference? I'm familiar with (and endorse) the Julian Barbour "time capsule" interpretation of time, and I just read the link. It cites the exact same facts, and provides the same explanations, that I do when demonstrating that the arrow of time is thermodynamic (ie time slices can only contain memories of "pastward" states as Gary Drescher puts it). The QM explanation is not contrary; it's just a special case of the thermodynamic explanation; entanglement is one way entropy can increase, but it happens in the classical world too, which also has time symmetric laws. So in what sense is someone erring when they call it a thermodynamic arrow of time?