8 ms·
Residents in faster places tend to report feeling somewhat happier
- lettergram 12y agoI know I enjoy making a large salary, then I can (for example) hire a maid to clean my apartment, saving my time. That's more-or-less my rational for money improving happiness.
- graeme 12y agoMoney, to an extent, buys time. That's the main reason I pursue it. The issue is that most people seem to leverage their money to the hilt. They earn $10,000 more, they spend ~$10,000 more. I can see money making you less happy in that situation, because you now face more downside risk if the money goes away. Whereas if you earn $10,000 and only spend $0-$1,000 more, then you have options, including the option to not do anything to earn money at some point in the future. The above is a version of the Mustachian philosophy, but you don't need to cut spending to a bare minimum to pursue time. Nassim Taleb argues for "fuck you money", and has written skeptically of the "money doesn't lead to happiness" idea. For him, self-ownership and independence of money is the key. The main purpose of money is not to spend most of it, to have a reserve. People often ask how my business is going by asking if it keeps me "busy". They're using the wrong metrics.
- willis77 12y ago> People often ask how my business is going by asking if it keeps me "busy". They're using the wrong metrics. Or just being polite? Or following norms about not asking about money? Or just using "keeping busy" as a construct for "not unemployed"?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- reasonattlm 12y agoAnd we are entering an age in which money can buy time in a much more useful sense, via medical means of treating the consequences of degenerative aging. At the moment that means funding the research, but later it will mean buying the therapies. If you have money, better to put it into stage 1 (research) now rather than waiting around for a stage 2 (treatments) that will only show up after enough is done in stage 1, though.
- grecy 12y ago> Money, to an extent, buys time I think spending money is the wrong way to go about getting the things you want out of life. Earning money is very inefficient - You have all your costs of education, of finding a job, of getting to work and the biggest one - the taxes you pay. Then spending money is inefficient too, because whenever you spend money someone is making a profit, taking their bit off the top. So rather than using the inefficient money-as-a-middle-man I think you're much better off to just go straight to what you want - time in this case. Just go to work less, have less money, and you'll magically have more time - and in fact it will be more time that if you tried to earn/spend money to "buy" that time.
- lfowles 12y agoI'd love it if the work I'm interested in wasn't generally a boolean 5*8hrs/day/week or unemployed. Most people don't have the luxury of a work/free time slider. (I could freelance, but I don't think that would end well for me.)
- grecy 12y ago> I'd love it if the work I'm interested in wasn't generally a boolean 58hrs/day/week or unemployed. Most people don't have the luxury of a work/free time slider.* I think you'd be surprised if you asked your boss for unpaid leave. Start with a few weeks a year and slowly ramp it up. You boss will be happy because it will be easier for her to make budget. I took about 10 weeks unpaid last year, Likely it will be 12 or 15 this year.
- lfowles 12y agoThanks, I've actually _never_ seen that suggested anywhere! Would be a great idea for when my wife and I both have jobs.
- withdavidli 12y agoThere are assumptions here. >Earning money is very inefficient - You have all your costs of education, of finding a job, of getting to work and the biggest one - the taxes you pay. In the states you're forced to attend school until a certain age, you can also skip grades if you're ahead of the pack. Finishing high school / college might relate to long term potential income, but that's statistics. For instance, I was selling online gold for a few months and easily made what my first full-time job was in half the time. >Just go to work less, have less money, and you'll magically have more time - and in fact it will be more time that if you tried to earn/spend money to "buy" that time. While this is likely to be true, think about what money affords. It's the ability to have experiences easier, with less stress financially. Seeing plays, movies, traveling, dining at famous restaurants. This will depend on what a person wants to do with their time and what they enjoy, but money makes some of these experiences accessible or cuts down on time needed. Think about traveling to certain countries. People have made trips never using planes, but the time it takes is magnitudes longer (again, maybe some people rather boat the entire way).
- dschiptsov 12y agoMoney does buy happiness - just spent them on someone else. It is not a mutual recursion, not of a single process.) You will get happiness in a feedback loop.
- dschiptsov 12y ago,$s/is\ not/is/g
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Red_Tarsius 12y agoMoney buys time buys happiness, especially when it's a byproduct of the value you give to the world.
- PhoenixWright 12y agoLevine’s work raises the intriguing possibility that an individual’s feelings about their use of time contribute as much or more to their happiness as does economics. This seems like common sense. I know I wouldn't mind working or even not having as much financial freedom as I'd like as long as I found my work fulfilling and important. The problem is most jobs are unfulfilling and pointless. That's why you see a deluge of applicants for jobs at Google and Facebook while others go the startup route. Here's where money comes into the picture. If you don't want to move to SV or start a company you don't have any other option than to trade your time for money. The key is to minimize that amount of time.
- zackmorris 12y agoThe three levels of hacker mastery F.U. Money F.U. Time F.U. Zen
- yason 12y agoHappiness is a metric of internal success. Money is a metric of external success. If money (i.e. the external, material success) played no part and it was all about time you could just retire to a cabin in the forest to have all the time and none of the money till the day you die. That's because you already have time and you get more every day. But happiness and money aren't necessary orthogonal. If you're unhappy then money can't make you happy but if you're happy, money can amplify that and make you more happy. Money first gives you more options to do what you want but ultimately it gives you power. And power gives you leverage to change the world: first your own world and then the whole world. In other words, with money, you can do more and you're happier for that. However, that doesn't work if you don't know what you want and you only want things to become happy. You first need to be happy with what you have in order to be in the position where you can want more. Then you can use money the right way, almost as a beam of power to change things around. But in order to be equipped to do that you need to be on clear yourself: you already need to be happy not because of money, and you can no longer need the money to validate yourself at that point. You must have had accepted who you are because if you haven't, you can't be happy either.
- collyw 12y ago>Money first gives you more options to do what you want but ultimately it gives you power. And power gives you leverage to change the world: first your own world and then the whole world. In other words, with money, you can do more and you're happier for that. Sort of. So does time. If you have plenty of time you can learn anything. Most people have to get on with real jobs so can't devote the time to being the best guitar player in the world or whatever they would rather be.
- Swizec 12y ago> Most people have to get on with real jobs so can't devote the time to being the best guitar player in the world or whatever they would rather be. If only they had enough money so they wouldn't have to worry about those pesky jobs ...
- PSeitz 12y ago>Money first gives you more options to do what you want but ultimately it gives you power. And power gives you leverage to change the world: first your own world and then the whole world. In other words, with money, you can do more and you're happier for that. That's not how happiness works. You don't become happier because you can do something or change something with money.
- pyrrhotech 12y agomoney === time. If I had 20 million dollars, I could spend all day doing whatever I wanted to without having a care in the world. If anything is happiness, that is happiness. The distinction is meaningless.
- PSeitz 12y agoI sense javascript here. Happiness is a feeling, not an action or a plan.
- pyrrhotech 12y agoI think it's a state of being. Pleasure and pain are temporary feelings. Perhaps it's achieved differently by different people. I don't care how other people achieve it or even if it's irrelevant to their goals. To me, happiness is freedom from stress and control of my own time. It really is that simple, and money buys it. Others may not be like that, but I am. As someone who nearly has enough money to live the rest of my life without stress or need of a job of any kind, I can say I have gotten happier and happier every day that I've gotten closer. In the next year or two I should be totally free and happy to live the rest of my life without a worry in the world. Perhaps in 5 years I'll report back on how I'm doing.
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoMy personal definition: when you are getting paid to do essentially the same as what you would be doing if you had 20 million dollars and no obligations.
- bizarref00l 12y agoBut, I've always been told that "Time is Money". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Is_Money http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_Is_Money
- mcguire 12y ago"...also had more robust economies (as measured by GDP per capita, average purchasing power, and average caloric intake)..." Wait, what? What has caloric intake to do with a robust economy?
- gregstoll 12y agoI assume it's a measure of the amount of malnutrition.
- mm_throw2015 12y agoI don't agree that more time == more happiness. I grew up poor, so it was pounded into my head from an early age that you should acquire money to free yourself from the hassles and stress of poverty. So, by virtue of hard work and a lot of luck, I did so. Now, I 'work' about 5 hours a week from home for an insane salary. I sleep in every day, and have no real schedule to keep. I want for nothing material, but I struggle to fill my time so that I don't get bored. There are only so many books you can read, so many musical instruments you can become proficient at, etc, before keeping yourself busy becomes a job in and of itself. All my friends work typical 9-5 jobs, so I can't just call someone up and ask them to meet for lunch/drinks somewhere. I thank my lucky stars for my wife's company, otherwise the isolation would be too much to bear. I've been doing this for years, and what I've learned is that for me, happiness == other people. Not time, not possessions, not fast cars, people. Specifically, people that I like (of course). Because people bring continual novelty to my life, and that is what my brain craves. Now if I could only start a business with people that I admire. Too bad no one else has any free time.
- lucidrains 12y agoComing from a wealthy family, can tell you this is the truth.
- graeme 12y agoYou should check out the fourth part of the four hour workweek: filling the void. What you're experiencing is a common issue, and that section has some useful ideas. You might also consider relocating to a place where people live as you do. In the neighborhood of Montreal I live in, it's very normal for people to work irregular hours, and the streets and cafes are full of people during the workday. I'd feel incredibly isolated in a typical neighborhood that emptied during the 9-5.
- mm_throw2015 12y agoThanks for the tip, I'll check out that book and its suggestions.
- Devthrowaway80 12y ago
- jotux 12y ago"If money doesn't make you happy, then you probably aren't spending it right" http://www.wjh.harvard.edu/~dtg/DUNN%20GILBERT%20&%20WILSON%20(2011).pdf http://www.wjh.harvard.edu/~dtg/DUNN%20GILBERT%20&%20WILSON%...
- Swizec 12y agoI think money is a tool. Tools don't make you happy by themselves, it's about how you use them. If you're using money to buy more and more stuff that you don't need, then no, it won't make you happy. But if you're using money to off-load tasks you don't like, so you have more time to spend on things you do like ... well then. Money can suddenly make you happy. Yes, it's about time. Sort of. But time is a finite resource. You only get so much. Money, however, is a renewable resource. Which means you get to leverage it against the finite resource. But while this is painfully obvious to me, I have always had a hard time explaining the concept to others.
- crimsonalucard 12y agoThere's really no point in thinking of the question of happiness from this perspective. Everyone tries to logically plan out a path to contentment, happiness and satisfaction whether it be through making a lot of money or other means. The reality is... we're not biologically programmed to ever reach that state. As humans we're creatures of natural selection. Our physical bodies are competitive machines built through eons of evolution. For the same reason our minds have also been honed into competitive machines, designed to never feel satisfied and to always aggressively seek and want more. There is no competitive advantage to a mind that is perfectly content or happy, that is why you will rarely find a person who has truly reached this state. Simply being aware of this fact will also not lead to happiness. Too many people feel the solution is as simple as changing their state of mind. Simply changing your life philosophy and telling yourself to want less and to lead a simple life is not a viable solution. In the end doing this is just trying to force your mind to deny fundamental biological imperatives. It's like telling yourself to not be hungry. It is imho fundamentally impossible to remove your desire for money if all your peers are making 10 times more money then you. The last sentence in the previous paragraph is the key to happiness. Your biological drive to compete is actually tied to the people/environment around you. Your environment and culture dictates not only your drive to compete but the nature of the competition itself. In the corporate world people compete for money, in the military, they compete for ranks. As a result, the key to happiness is really simple. If you're not happy, change your environment. Move to an environment where people don't compete as much. By being in a culture that is not that competitive your drive to be compete will also fall proportionally. Changing your environment changes your nature. You cannot live in a competitive environment and change your nature through sheer willpower alone, you have to change your environment and that in turn will change your nature; and possibly increase your capacity to be happy. The perfect example everyone can relate to is the shift from student life to corporate life. As the nature and intensity of the competition from student to employee metamorphosed into another form, your capacity to feel satisfied and happy also dropped significantly (at least it does for most people).
- wallflower 12y agoThe classic dissonance lies in self-selection. If you are a maximizer, you tend to want to live in a place like the City that has the best of everything. By definition, if you are searching for global maximums (at least in that city), you will be missing out. You can never be (always) at the best restaurant/party/social scene/conference/park. However, if you are willing to be more chillaxe and relax your guidelines, you can be more happy. A party at a chill lounge with friends. A picnic in the park surrounded by people of all ages having fun. Likewise, people who tend to move to the suburbs tend to maximize for their kids, rather than themselves. It is ok to go to Chuck E. Cheese or T.G.I. Fridays' on a Friday night (or the modern equivalent) since there are limited options. It is ok for the kid to start crying in public. You are where you are now.
- powertower 12y ago> Among individuals in a society, busyness—or the feeling of busyness—seems to be an important factor in well-being. Busyness keeps your mind off things you'd rather not deal with. When things slow down, you are forced to look at yourself, which often shows you just how insignificant and miserable you really are, and how repetitive, ultimately pointless, and totally egotistical everything in your life is/was (not to mention all the mistakes you've made and all the opportunities you let go). But when you are constantly preoccupied with work, entertainment, ideologies, conflicts/resolutions, problems/solutions, identity building, validation, success, social status, drugs/sex/food, going out, having lots of options and avenues, etc, you tend to feel otherwise - as you are operating in a mode that is somewhat oblivious to the mess your inner core really is.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 12y ago> Perhaps the higher reported rates of happiness simply reflect the fact that faster places have more robust economies. But the relationship between income and reported happiness is far from obvious. According to the “Easterlin paradox” (named after economist Richard Easterlin), once people have enough money to meet their basic needs, having more money is not necessarily correlated with higher self-reported happiness. This is pretty thoroughly debunked. I don't think there is any debate on this. Even lighter interpretations that it taps out at quite high figures ($80,000+) I'm pretty sure are also found incorrect. Last I saw happiness slows a fair bit around $80,000 but still continues to increase with wage. Places that are faster also allow more experiences. Experiences are known to be linked to happiness. Throw in better economies I think this is more logical.
- salmonellaeater 12y agoThe article doesn't mention anything about age. Age predicts happiness[1] as well as walking speed. I suspect it predicts economic performance, although I don't have any references. It's certainly common for young people to migrate to large cities with strong economies to find work [2]. Were there controls for the average age of residents? The original paper[3] doesn't mention controls or age at all. This seems like a major issue to me. 1. http://www.euro.centre.org/data/1207216181_14636.pdf http://www.euro.centre.org/data/1207216181_14636.pdf 2. Interactive US map here: http://www.netmigration.wisc.edu/ http://www.netmigration.wisc.edu/ 3. http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.389.6823&rep=rep1&type=pdf http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.389...