8 ms·
Google and tech’s elite are living in a parallel universe – John Naughton
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoErr, maybe it's me, but this seems to be a unfocused rant with no redeeming traditional features like sarcasm. Yeah we know there is a Great Hollowing Out. We know that some lucky talented people start to rationalise their success through "doing good works must be the reason for success" And we know that Piketty is right about capital beating out labour. But I was hoping for some insights - some idea of what to do about it.
- buro9 12y ago> But I was hoping for some insights - some idea of what to do about it For that, you'd need to read Marx.
- sgift 12y agoOr Piketty (quoted in the article). The book also contains ideas how to solve the phenomens described.
- jnbiche 12y agoIs the book readable, as in well-written? Edit: I just read a detailed synopsis of the book (I know it's not the same as the book). I strongly agree with his diagnosis, but not his cure. I think two things have gotten us into this mess: (general commentary, my remarks are not aimed at parent comment) 1) Corporations (as in the legal construct) and all the legal and financial benefits they enjoy, which allows capital to accumulate at a rate much faster than it would otherwise, and (on a related note) 2) Regulations. The more Washington tries to legislate us out of this mess, the deeper we descend into inequality. As one example: regulatory concerns are keeping the brightest, most innovative, and most honest among us out of the fintech sector, and so now I see mostly dishonest or reckless players. If there's ever a sector that needed disrupting, it's consumer banking, but the banks have erected so many regulatory barriers, that small players can't get in. And please spare me any pleas about how banking is "serious stuff" that requires major regulations, several million dollars for regulatory compliance, and an anal probe to enter the field. I see exactly who that's keeping out, and it's not the nimble dishonest companies, who steal people's money and seem to almost thrive amid these kinds of regulations.
- sgift 12y agoIt is well-written from a scientific point of view, but not easily readable. It is a dry, fact-driven book without any humour or "light attitude" (for lack of a better phrase) to help the reader.
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>The more Washington tries to legislate us out of this mess, the deeper we descend into inequality. As one example: regulatory concerns are keeping the brightest, most innovative, and most honest among us out of the fintech sector, and so now I see mostly dishonest or reckless players. If there's ever a sector that needed disrupting, it's consumer banking, but the banks have erected so many regulatory barriers, that small players can't get in. I have to disagree. "Financial technology" does not need to be "disrupted". It needs to be boring. Finance is supposed to be boring, because all the real action is happening elsewhere and its only job is to channel money from savers to borrowers. Consumer banking is a point-A-to-point-B delivery service with some risk attached (the risk of a loan not being repaid). It's as boringly statistical and actuarial as insurance (to which it is rightfully closely related). I mean, frankly, the USA consumer banking sector just doesn't need more cryptography-fueled gold-standard imitations, nor more ever-so-clever statistical models for mutual funds that blow up and die when their basic assumptions are violated by that chaotic monster of chaos known as "Reality", nor more ways for a banker to write a loan he knows won't be repaid and then escape the responsibility of eating his own damn losses when the borrowers can't repay. What it needs is to finally catch up with the rest of the world and let people send money via online banking, and receive their paychecks each month via direct deposit without two weeks' delay, and to not charge so many damned ATM and debit-card fees. I can easily think of a list of sectors that really do need disruption. And here they are: 1) Housing and energy. We can (re-)nationalize education and health-care like a sensible country, but out of Elizabeth Warren's Four Big Expenses that are beating up on the average family, that still leaves housing and energy in severe need of disruption. Passive houses, solar panels, electric cars, selling my excess energy back to the grid, micro-houses, high-quality urban housing: I, as a prospective customer, want more of all of these, and yet few to no "disrupters" are trying to provide me with that for which I might part with my money! 2) Public transit. Yes, this one would often be a public service, but I've heard good arguments in favor of the way Japanese train companies combine real-estate development arms with train arms to build whole neighborhoods around the public-transit network. Implementing that would be a double whammy. Or work on self-driving cars and buses. Or invent new ways to get through watery or mountainous terrain for transit purposes, to go where cars can't. 3) Food. The food system is appallingly wasteful and damaging while also delivering an inferior product. Why, in the largest single breadbasket nation in the entire world, is a tomato so damned expensive and yet so flavorless? Not an organic, artisanal, locally-grown tomato specially treated by elves for the most wonderfully tomato-y taste you'll ever get, just a regular tomato grown with all the pesticides and artificial fertilizers Monsanto can provide, then ripened artificially with ethylene gas and shipped in cold storage. Where are my super-techno-greenhouses and hydroponic farms that can provide fresh, tasty crops throughout the year and the continent? Where is my lab-grown meat, with an order of magnitude improvement in the energy-and-ingredient efficiency of turning plant matter into deliciousness? 4) Prosthetics and other curative medical technologies. Holy crap, it is actually difficult to conceptualize the amount of productivity lost each year to disability! A half-decent economic system should know, in the bones of its accounting procedures, that every disease left uncured is free money left on the table, productivity left unmobilized. And so on and so forth. Want to disrupt something? Just look around with your eyes open and find a sector that seems to run the way it does for no reason greater than historical accident. You'll find dozens of them, the world is full of stuff like that. Where there's no rational reason for the sector to be the way it is, there's little to stop you from disrupting it, using greater efficiency to deliver higher quality to the consumers and higher wages to the workers. Go for it! Or at least make me a decent video game. Or better yet, an ebook that's comfortable for full-color textbooks and reference works, so I don't have to purchase and store tens of kilograms of heavy dead trees just to hold things I want to know. But please don't come complaining about how "disruptive" bankers are just trying to do God's work by merging consumer banking with investment banking, until the Big Bad Government came in and regulated them all to death. Because what it looks like to me, is that too many people just want to get their VC cash for making "an app", whereas most of the big inventions and innovations we need require some form of actual, physical-and-biological engineering expertise.
- hownottowrite 12y agoPiketty's TED Talk. IMHO, a bit dry, like the book. http://www.ted.com/talks/thomas_piketty_new_thoughts_on_capital_in_the_twenty_first_century http://www.ted.com/talks/thomas_piketty_new_thoughts_on_capi...
- raverbashing 12y agoYes, because it worked great in Cuba, the USSR, Eastern Europe, etc "But nobody was unemployed" sure, and if you live in a hut by the Amazon river you'll never be in need of water, but it pretty much sucks otherwise.
- sgift 12y agoDid you read Marx, so we can have a discussion about his theories here or do you just talk in platitudes to disrail any serious discussion?
- raverbashing 12y agoSome of it, yeah, and I don't blame him for what came to be, in theory everything is nice and should work, in practice, it's been shown what can be done in guise of it.
- buro9 12y agoActually my point is to read Marx to realise one possible (and the most popular at that) scenario that will come about. Once that is fully understood, then we can return to ask the question: "Why hasn't this fully happened yet?" and look to history to provide the answers of the failures of the attempts, but more pertinently the techniques the West applied to avoid the scenario from playing out. As my other comment states, the thing to do... given that everyone on here is in the top 5%, and a few in the top 1%... is to realise that it is actually up to us as those in positions of influence, power and wealth to re-engineer the system to help make it a sustainable one. Inequality, or specifically the symptoms of inequality, are an issue that we need to address.
- Qwertious 12y agoCuba's doing pretty well, except for the fact that the USA has put an embargo on them (due to political reasons), making it extremely hard for them to trade with anyone, and massively driving down the value of their currency.
- revelation 12y agoWhy would the tech firms be responsible for jobs lost to technology? They are the ones having to hire people to create all that neat technology. The blame falls with the firms that use technology to cut out whole job titles from their operation. It is upon them and primarily politicians to ensure that the gains from technology benefit all people in less time spent working and a guaranteed base level of living that is certainly well above what we have now in social security.
- sgift 12y agoI didn't force someone to use the gun/atomic bomb/Sarin/..., I just produced it. A simplistic defense often used in such circumstances.
- jnbiche 12y ago> The blame falls with the firms that use technology to cut out whole job titles from their operation. That's just passing the buck. It's on both parties, creator and user, to find a solution. Did you think no one would use the technology that allowed them to cut jobs?
- gaius 12y ago... Except that they are specifically not hiring people. An Uber driver is not an employee with all the protection and rights afforded employees. An AirBnB host, is not an employee either. This is not just about tech automating jobs away, it's about it facilitating a race to the bottom.
- swombat 12y agoDr Schmidt’s smart creatives work all the hours that God sends, and then some. They are, to use his term, “overworked in a good way”. The concept of work-life balance can, he thinks, “be insulting to smart, dedicated employees”, for whom work is an important part of life, not something to be separated. The best corporate cultures, he thinks, “invite and enable people to be overworked in a good way, with too many interesting things to do both at work and at home”. A very good philosophy, that I also discussed here: http://danieltenner.com/2014/11/19/work-and-life-balance-and-imbalance/ http://danieltenner.com/2014/11/19/work-and-life-balance-and... I had not read Eric Schmidt's book at that point, though. The author continues, however: But it also highlights the extent to which our world is bifurcating into parallel universes. No it's not. It's evolving into a new universe. There's no reason why everyone, yes, everyone, can't be in that new universe where they work on what they're passionate about. And when we figure out how to fix our screwed up economic systems to enable that (one possible solution is the Basic Income idea), we will derive, as a species, productivity benefits that we can't even begin to comprehend right now. At this point in time, the majority of humanity toils for subsistence. A sizeable minority work to pay for their lifestyle (aka the work-life balance level), and they are a bajillion times more productive than the subsistence workers. A tiny slice of us are now able to work with passion, on what we want to do. Like artists working on a song or a painting or a book, they do not draw a clear line between work and play. They're always working and always playing. With this they achieve a level of enjoyment of life and of productivity that the work-life balance crowd cannot touch. Let's all work together to get everyone into this last category. It's easy to point to the fact that we're not there yet. Harder to make tangible progress towards this goal.
- littletimmy 12y agoThe problem with what you're saying is that the people who "do not draw a clear line between work and play" are not nearly as romantically satisfied with their work as you claim. Do you not see how this "passion for work" argument is often employed to make employees work the maximum they can? If you apply to work at Goldman Sachs, or McKinsey, or Google, the message is clear: it is not enough that you sell your time to us, you must sell your soul as well! You have to be "passionate" about investment banking, consulting, or software engineering to get a job at these places. Consequently, young grads who are looking for jobs now have to make a genuine effort to work ungodly hours in an effort to demonstrate their "passion" to these firms. Now maybe that is because some of them are genuinely interested in their work (although how you get a "passion" for excel modelling I do not know), but it is more likely that it is something these new workers feel they must do in order to be successful. What is the outcome? Elite companies can make talented young people work insane hours without compensating them for the extra profit that they create. The notion that Eric Schmidt is saying his workers should work round the clock out of sheer concern for their fulfilment is absolutely laughable. Btw, this form of thinking is quite uniquely American. Perhaps it springs from the puritan ideal of deriving meaning in your life from work. For the rest of the developed world (Western Europe, for example) the notion of working harder and harder because you have to be as "passionate" as everyone else sounds ridiculous. There is more to life than work. Truly. You are on earth. You can read fiction in your spare time, also hike, and perhaps volunteer to socialize feral cats for adoption. TL;DR: Please stop with your propaganda that it is a noble thing to find this mythical level of enjoyment with working to increase shareholder value. Leisure time is cool.
- fenomas 12y agoI'm not unsympathetic, but this article seems like a hodgepodge of gripes in search of a premise. "These tech elites are like bankers, in the sense that they make a lot of money, and in no other sense. Also they're mostly men. And they control capital, if, uh, they own corporate shares. Plus, Moore's Law." Huh?
- SandB0x 12y ago> hodgepodge of gripes in search of a premise Welcome to The Guardian's opinion pages, where everything is a source of outrage and the shadowy "1%" are always out to get you.
- gaius 12y agoThe ironic thing of course is that you can tell everything you need to know about the readers of a paper from the brands that advertise in it, and the readers of the Graun are second only to the FT in their opulence. They are the 1%.
- JonnieCache 12y agohttp://www.thedailymash.co.uk/news/society/guardian-ordered-to-destroy-bourgeois-lifestyle-articles-2013082278865 http://www.thedailymash.co.uk/news/society/guardian-ordered-...
- whyever 12y agoIt is undeniable that the gap between poor and rich is increasing, especially in the US.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoIs it undeniable? Last I heard there was a lot of noise from Picketty and Saez, which was based on fundamentally invalid and unsound scholarship. To put it in computing terms, it's on a par with benchmarking your software for performance improvements, but upgrading your laptop partway through and calling that a massive speedup. A one-time methodology change in the methodology of the census bureau's Current Population Survey (in 1992) is responsible for roughly a third of Picketty's claimed increase in the Gini coefficient. It's undeniable that this has been in the news and on the lips of many partisans. And there was some short-term increase in the aftermath of the latest recession, I suppose. That's not really controversial, though its durability has not yet been proven. (Also, I'm not sure the "especially in the US" label is necessarily deserved.) Really, the "undeniable" label is a tendentious one: it argues, more than it describes. Its purpose is to turn a little solid evidence for a small change into what seems like an ocean of evidence for an overwhelming change. I call it deceitful.
- jnbiche 12y agoWhile there's a lot of inflammatory, and frankly unfounded, accusations here, I do strongly agree with two major points: 1) Like Cameron, most SV tech workers are utterly convinced that they are doing "good", even if that means replacing jobs with machines. I don't necessarily have a problem with replacing jobs with machines, but we have to come up with some means of sustenance and stimulation to replace jobs for those affected (btw, these are not intractable problems: basic income could address the sustenance issue, and for the stimulation part, I believe that open source model has a lot to offer). That's urgent. Otherwise, no one is doing any good, we're just knocking middle class earners into poverty. 2) The tech "elite" (not fond of the term) are living in a parallel universe. This one is on display any time any economic article is posted on HN. It's clear that many (most?) commentators are convinced that the economic recovery is complete and everyone is happy. This is far from the truth. As well documented by respected economists, at least in the US, most of the economic gains since the great recession have gone to the top 1% of income earners [1]. The rest of this country's inhabitants are suffering still. By the way, to be specific about what in this article is "unfounded", it's calling tech workers in SV "elite" or "rich". Given extraordinarily high cost of living in SV, the average wage among SV workers is frankly not enough to support a middle class family at the level the middle class enjoys in the small towns and cities in middle America (I recently researched this in detail). The only reason the average tech workers has significant disposable income is that they are young and single or married with no children. Young people working professional jobs anywhere have disposable income (it's the only time in my life I had significant disposable income). 1. http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/28/upshot/gains-from-economic-recovery-still-limited-to-top-one-percent.html http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/28/upshot/gains-from-economic... Edit: small request for posterity: can the downvoters please indicate which part of my post you disagree with, since I have strong criticism for both the writer and for tech culture? A simple reply of "techie" or "lefty" would suffice. Thanks!
- eli_gottlieb 12y ago>1) Like Cameron, most SV tech workers are utterly convinced that they are doing "good", even if that means replacing jobs with machines. I'm not convinced! I'm an ideological accelerationist! I think that I need to push the automation process to act more quickly in order to bring about the severe contrasts between "now" and "then" that make human beings sit up, take notice, and actually make social change. I think if we let the process move too slowly, we risk winding up in a new Dark Age in which not only do we suffer severe inequality and oppression, but we rationalize and allow them through a publicly-endorsed ideology that explicitly structures society hierarchically. I want people to get shocked by exploitation and inequality, shocked into fighting them, before they get so damned used to it that they just allow themselves to be exploited and oppressed.
- jcfrei 12y agoI don't mind soaring returns for owners of tech companies as long as the state run redistribution of wealth allows everybody to live a life in dignity.
- imjustsaying 12y ago> as long as the state run redistribution of wealth allows everybody to live a life in dignity. I'm not really sure what you're proposing here.
- bjelkeman-again 12y agoSounds like what we try to do in Europe.
- buro9 12y agoMy view is that the industrial revolution devised machines which, whilst increasing the efficiency of production, helped to increase the efficiency by which states and key individuals were able to extract wealth from others. In that case, as time progressed, the people started to become aware of the inequality and the leaders and states started to see the result (in Russia and other countries) of this inequality being challenged. To protect themselves, the states and key individuals devised to funnel a portion of the benefits from the industrial revolution back down to the wider populace, to offer comfort through more spare time, better health, better living conditions. The industrial machine operated at only slightly below the potential level of efficiency it promised, but now the machine was able to sustain itself and ensure it's future. Where we are today is that the digital revolution has created machines that achieve an even greater efficiency. The "sharing economy" it has brought about is little more than an externalisation of corporation costs of production, allowing those corporations to reap greater benefits with very little cost. The inequality technology has brought about is staggering to behold. What I believe has yet to be achieved is a balancing of the externalisation of costs with the need to build a system that is able to sustain itself. For the current system to survive, those who have need to find ways to increase the comfort and conditions of those who have not.
- aragot 12y agoI'm worried about the form of the redistribution. In France, we have small taxes in many places. Just one example: We dealt with copyright issues by creating a tax on storage mediums, from a few cents to 20-40€ depending on the container, the size and the volatility - more than 40 different tax levels (see tables here [1]). Obviously they included the bureaucracy feature, where if you're a company you can send back a form and be reimbursed. I'm confident the same kind of insane level of tax compexity exists in pretty much any country and it implements revenue equality by squashing entrepreneurship at its root. Less innovation, less inequality ;) So let's go ahead: Which forms of redistribution would do you see? Your comment made me notice that taxes proportional to the number of ads already exist (the VAT) and doesn't help redistributing. We need to take into account the change of scale. Would it be a tax per number of available cars for car-sharing services, then a tax per node in the friend graph for social networks? Sounds insane, but is it what we're bound to implement? [1] http://www.culturecommunication.gouv.fr/Politiques-ministerielles/Propriete-litteraire-et-artistique/Commission-pour-la-remuneration-de-la-copie-privee/Questions-pratiques/Les-montants-de-la-Remuneration-pour-Copie-Privee http://www.culturecommunication.gouv.fr/Politiques-ministeri...
- fluxtemp 12y agoI was open minded when I saw the title of this piece, but now I still don't understand what it was trying so hard to say. The author seems to be mad at reality and is hard at work promoting envy. Inequality is a legitimate concern, but this sort of emotional agitation is helping no one.
- netheril96 12y agoMight I ask why your name appears green? I have seen some green names on HN, but never know what it means.
- hownottowrite 12y agoI'm not sure if the Naughton is trying to incite populist rage or evoke some sort of self-conscious shame. Maybe both? Either way it is ridiculous. Tech elites have always existed in a parallel universe. Careful tending to their needs and acceptance of their peculiarities has been part of the bargain with those in power.
- happyscrappy 12y agoIndeed, the look of horror from the Oracle suits at programmers in shorts and sandals when the other elevator broke.
- jdimov 12y agoI honestly don't understand why bitter, unaccomplished people believe that someone who creates wealth has an obligation to share that wealth with them. I believe that's commonly called "jealousy" and no, it doesn't give you a moral high ground, nor will it solve any of your problems and it will certainly not make you richer any time soon - quite the contrary, it ensures that you will remain miserable for the rest of your life.
- sz4kerto 12y agoThis would all be true if we could easily identify who's creating wealth. Hint: it does not completely equal with individuals who receive the money in the end. Over the couple of thousand years societies realized this, that's why the societies try to smoothen things out a little. It is nice to think that we, technologists in our 20s, 30s have figured it all out because we read Atlas Shrugged once, but reality is slightly more complex. :) (Disclaimer: I consider myself a libertarian, but I am already too old to think that a few simple rules could save the world.)
- Tycho 12y agoBut it seems totally uncontroversial and obvious to me that some people will generate vastly more wealth than others. Like think back to your class in high school. Some people were intelligent and industrious and went on to have creative jobs. Some people did just enough to get passing grades and went on to have repetitive, non-creative jobs. Extrapolate this differential in productivity over their entire working lives, what would you expect to happen? You cannot easily identify who created any given piece of wealth, but you can conduct thought experiments like the above that tell you something about the wealth generating process. Of course, the nice thing is, all of society gets the benefit of improved technology and scientific knowledge, regardless of how much they contributed in that direction.
- kbutler 12y ago> technology has certain characteristics (zero marginal returns, network effects and technological lock-in, to name just three) which confer colossal power Should be "zero marginal costs"...
- ukigumo 12y agoThe scary part is that Google and other companies that are on the forefront of the new digital age still operate under a strict post-industrialist mindset. The cult of the busy man and the hinderance of personal life outside of work is absolutely mind blowing to me. Aren't we supposed to work smart instead of working long hours? Aren't we supposed to improve ourselves spiritually and emotionally once we have reached a plateau of physical and social security?
- slowblood 12y agoHard for me to feel anything other than sympathy of anyone who has to ride a bus to work. "Elite" and "riding a bus" are two concepts that are "living in a parallel universe." Not the same one.
- whoisthemachine 12y agoI'm not sure what I just read - it seemed like a bunch of disparate points drawn together with a tinge of rage at something, for the sake of having rage at something.
- rwmj 12y agoI'm intrigued by what the alternative would be. Google can't stop developing better search / self-driving cars / etc because some other company would do it instead. It seems as if the author wants everyone to hold back on change voluntarily, a kind of digital Luddism.
- sixQuarks 12y agoHere's a wild idea: What if it were free (or cost pennies) to get any materialistic good besides food? Imagine owning a 300 foot yacht or a jumbo jet for a penny. And everyone in the world can have their own with unlimited supplies. I believe we're in the middle of an adjustment period that will take 15 to 25 years. At the end of this period, virtual reality will be a sufficient replacement for reality, and as affordable as a cellphone is today. When all goods (besides food) are virtual goods, all of a sudden the cost doesn't matter. The rich divide gets shattered. You could be living in a cardboard shack, but in VR, you're living in a mansion. I know it's a crazy idea, but I just don't see wealth being associated with real materialistic goods in the future which will change everything.
- Lambdanaut 12y agoI'm a futurist optimist and yet I REALLY don't see VR reasonably replacing reality in 15 to 25 years. There's too many sensory parts of reality to replicate. At best it'll be a shoddy ripoff for a long time. Not to mention the health benefits that come with interacting in the real world that you don't get from VR. You're not going to be soaking up those sun rays or enjoying that tuna you caught off the side of your yacht in Second Life VR. You'll be watching your avatar enjoy these things. At the end of the day you've still gotta log off and enjoy the real world, or you'll atrophy. VR might supplement reality just like watching TV does, but it'll be a long time before we're living our lives in VR.
- sixQuarks 12y agoI don't think VR needs to replicate reality perfectly. 80% of reality will be way more than sufficient when you consider the fact that you can do impossible things in VR (like flying, travelling instantly anywhere, etc). When you say "at the end of the day you've still gotta log off and enjoy the real world" - why? When VR is replicating the real world, why must you log off to "enjoy" it? You could essentially do anything in VR that you can do in "reality", with way more magical powers. Who would want to go back to "boring reality" anymore?
- 12y ago
- raldi 12y agopg jumped into a time machine and wrote a response to this piece eleven years before it was published: http://www.paulgraham.com/gap.html http://www.paulgraham.com/gap.html
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoThat's a lot of sour grapes. People doing great things and getting rewarded - means they are 'ivory tower' I guess. They have to be taken down a notch by a blistering cynical blogger. Blowhard.
- lscore720 12y agoReminds me of a prospective engineering candidate I tried to recruit from Google. When I politely pitched an opportunity, he insulted both me and the opportunity over e-mail, claiming how wildly successful he is. This is largely an exception to the rule: almost all other engineers have been kind & respectful!