6 ms·
I love the idea, and the execution, but just one nit -- you say "no hidden fees", but I think bundling the fee into the total price is the definition of a hidde
by zaroth 12y ago
I love the idea, and the execution, but just one nit -- you say "no hidden fees", but I think bundling the fee into the total price is the definition of a hidden fee. If your examples itemized the fee it would be a different story. Other comments here express a similar anxiety, e.g. how much [extra] am I actually paying for this?
Also, I know you're busy, but FYI CA state law requires you have a Privacy Policy. I would like to know how long you retain records and who you are sharing them with before doing business with you!
- noblethrasher 12y agoThe price that they quote you is the only fee. It's up to you to decide if it is worth it.
- aaronem 12y agoWhen you're using a concierge service is not the time to pinch pennies. Corollary: When you're pinching pennies is not the time to use a concierge service. The whole point of a concierge service, such as this, is to have someone on call to whom you may say "Here is my problem. Make it go away." Such services generally come at a much higher rate than Magic appear to be charging.
- octatoan 12y agoI think there's a fallacy here . . .
- aaronem 12y agoIs there, though? Sure, it'd be preferable to have a full fee schedule available, for cases where it's needed. But, given that using a concierge service is perhaps the definitive case of spending money to conserve time; given also that this is a side project which has suddenly blown up in its creators' faces; and given finally that said creators appear to be working unbelievably hard to scale it up and out to meet the demand they've discovered -- given all that, I think it's pretty unreasonable to shit on the people who've made concierge service cheaper and more accessible than ever before because, in scrambling to meet unexpected demand, they have yet to get around to polish. Give them a month or two to get everything shaken out, and if they still haven't put up any fee information, then go after them. Until then, calm yourself; you are, after all, free not to use their service, if it fails to meet your requirements.
- cpkpad 12y agoI hope their business model is to provide sane-cost concierge.
- bo1024 12y agoAlthough after thinking about it I disagree with your post, I had the same initial impression. I think it is because the wording of the texts make it seem like they are quoting the price of the service you are requesting, but the quote actually includes their fee. There's nothing wrong with that, but for some reason I didn't realize it on first read -- maybe a small wording change can make this more clear.
- colechristensen 12y agoI take "hidden fees" to mean asterisks. That is, offering something for $10 and adding 7% for tax, a $1 service charge, 10¢ convenience fee, 5¢ concierge vetting fee... you get the picture.
- ozi 12y agoThey could make everyone happy by switching "hidden" to "extra"
- colechristensen 12y agoI think "extra" means wrong things though. Perhaps it should be something along the lines of "final price exactly as quoted including tip, nothing more" the key being that they aren't one of those services (like so many others) that advertise one price and charge you another. "no hidden fees" is a recognizable meme though, and being pedantically correct is perhaps – and this is a pedantic concern – not as valuable as the phycological grab of that phrase.
- SilasX 12y agoWell, they're showing Magic being used for a lot of delivery services where the deliverer will expect a tip, so it seems like there is a hidden fee in the same sense... Unless they're working out something with the provider where the third party will not expect a tip, which would be a miracle. Edit: I stand corrected. Someone quotes the site as having: > It's completely free to chat with Magic. When you order something, we'll let you know the total price so you can confim it before you are billed. There are no hidden fees, and tip is included.
- danellis 12y ago> CA state law requires you have a Privacy Policy Who does that apply to? Companies based in CA? Companies doing business with anyone in CA?
- zaroth 12y agoBoth of course! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Privacy_Protection_Act http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_Privacy_Protection_Act
- danellis 12y agoInteresting. I'm not sure I understand how California can make laws regulating companies in any part of the world.
- cookiecaper 12y agoThey can't, but if you make CA mad and they decide to sue you, you'll be out much more than it would've cost to just copy and paste a boilerplate privacy policy. A great deal of legal mechanics work this way -- sure, someone can't technically make that kind of mandate, but since it costs a lot of money and time to have a court case where that kind of thing gets proven, you're better off just making sure no one even tries. Pretty much any civil action is similar. Unless it's on a massive scale, ask a lawyer what you should do when someone appears intent on pushing a frivolous copyright suit on you. Sure, you have every right to use that content, but do you have the tens of thousands of dollars (minimum) and months or years in court to prove it? It's practically always easier to just accept that you've been bullied out of exercising your rights and replace the contested content with something that the claimant won't launch a frivolous suit over. Lawsuits are only worthwhile when the workaround is more expensive, which is often a hard standard to meet -- that's why most cases end in settlement.
- cpkpad 12y agoBad idea: Giving legal advice without a license. Worse idea: giving incorrect legal advice without a license. Jurisdiction is complex. With the Internet, you do not need to have a physical location somewhere to do business there.
- freehunter 12y agoWell it's not hidden because they tell you up front, before the order is placed, how much it will cost. If they told you $20 and asked for $25 when they got there, that would be a hidden fee. Like AT&T saying you can get cable for $20/mo, but your cable bill always ends up being $32.88.
- avn2109 12y agoGetting someone to push back on ATT bill errors would be an amazing feature if Magic could make it work.
- bgodlove88 12y agoWe're happy to call ATT on your behalf :) Try us out!
- zaroth 12y agoI would love to see a report on how this, or something like this went. That really would be a valued service. Whether the value is set high enough is a very good question. Transaction costs are very low so that provides more leeway.
- nezumi 12y agoThe last time I had a problem with ATT I had to make multiple calls and spent over an hour in total on hold. How would you charge for that? I'd have gladly paid for someone to take that pain away. There's probably a viable business model in there somewhere if someone can independently put a competent customer service layer in front of companies like ATT.
- ollysb 12y agoThis would actually make a lot of sense if you could detect when a call came off hold. A small pool of operators could deal with calls as soon as the operator on the other end becomes available.
- mzuvella 12y agoA magician never reveals their secrets...1st rule of magic.
- anon012012 12y agoWhen you pay at the restaurant you don't know about the extra of putting it together, and so I don't think they're morally obligated, but it's certainly controversial and something to think about.