4 ms·
In reverse order... > please, tell me about the added value recruiters in the UK bring anyone Sure. Firstly, the last 5 candidates I've placed were not l
by peteretep 12y ago
In reverse order...
> please, tell me about the added value recruiters in the UK bring anyone
Sure.
Firstly, the last 5 candidates I've placed were not looking for jobs. Each was in a role where they were slightly unhappy, but inertia was keeping them put. Having chatted to them, I was able to find them roles they enjoyed more, with a significant pay rise. You could see this as introducing liquidity to the market. A job-board would not have found them.
Secondly, of the last job ads I've posted to job-boards, fully 50% of the applicants came from a single non-European company, and the applicants had no right to work in the UK. Of the remaining 50%, almost all were totally unqualified by CV alone. Of the handful who were qualified, a very quick technical chat on the phone weeded out approximately half again. Then the ones whose salary expectations were out of line with the hiring company needed filtering out too. When you're in a position to actually hire people, you'll get a feel for how time-consuming it can be to hire a single role. When you have 5 to fill, it can become a full-time job.
Thirdly, as an immigrant to the UK (welcome!), you'll be well-acquainted with the foibles of the UK immigration system. Candidate A's wife is on a Tier II inter-company transfer visa, and he wants to get a role; does the hiring company need to be on the UK BA list or can you just hire him? What if it's a subsidiary company of a larger company that is on the UK BA list, but it doesn't have its own registration? Is the candidate worth pursuing? What if the candidate applied for ILR four weeks ago? Is it safe to make him a job offer?
Fourthly, as you point out, the UK job-board market is not centralised, and it's not a monopoly. Where should you post a Python job? LinkedIn? Monster? CV Library? Twitter? Reed? Jobsite? Facebook? Jobserve? Any number of the scammy Python-specific job-boards? As a direct employer, your media cost is £200 a pop. Filling out each form take half an hour. Each of these systems has a different way to get the candidates and format them. As a recruiter, however, I'm using a multi-poster, and I'm paying ~£10 for the media cost, and I have the time and motivation to post the job to a wide-range of channels, but I also have a pretty good feel for where my return on investment will be.
Fifthly: What's a reasonable salary for a Ruby developer in London? What if you need them hired in the next four weeks, urgently? What about a contractor? You've probably got a gut feeling, but look, all the job ads show a range, and not an actual salary. How much would you pay for a superstar? How much for a junior? Are you paying more or less than the competition? Two types of people have access to salary data across the industry: HR people, who aren't allowed to share it, and recruiters, who share it as part of their value-add.
There are sixthly, seventhly, eighthly and ninthly here, but who reads long comments anyway?
> Russian recruitment industry as an example of smoothly-
> functioning market ... through two of the largest
> websites
So, to summarize, the Russian way is better because there is a duopoly in the job-board market, rather than meaningful competition. I can't tell if you're making a very clever ironic comment on economic centralization and its effects on the Russian economy, or you're just not thinking through the implications of what you write...
> that people like you (yes, you) will lose their jobs and
> suffer
You should consider re-reading the HN guidelines.
- smikhanov 12y ago> who reads long comments anyway? I do! It's great that someone is able to see through an emotional response and explicitly address most of the points. I'll try doing the same (and also in reverse order). > the Russian way is better because there is a duopoly > in the job-board market, rather than meaningful competition The Russian way is better because the marketplace is more efficient for both sides. If I'm a candidate, I have direct access to more real, existing, non-anonymized vacancies. If I'm a hiring company I have the way to target those looking for jobs. You cover the positive results of that with negative wording ("monopoly"), but in reality it's much less one-sided. Would someone willing to purchase some goods prefer to deal on the phone with people with limited inventories or go directly to something like eBay? Is eBay a monopoly in this case? Answer for both: of course not. > Fourthly, ... Where should you post a Python job? You are describing the very root of the problem and make it sound as if it's something to be proud of. As a hiring company, I can also use a multi-poster too. But now think about a candidate. Where would they go to search for a Python job? Aston Carter? Oxygen Recruitment? Any other scammy-looking firm harvesting their CVs? > Thirdly, ... Is it safe to make him a job offer? Sorry, but for this sort of advice, I'll call my lawyer and my lawyer only. We hired a company specializing in legal services for startups the day we raised funding. > Secondly, ... you'll get a feel for how time-consuming it can be to hire > a single role. When you have 5 to fill, it can become a full-time job. I did it, so I know. You are right, it's a very time-consuming process. When my company grew to four people, subsequent hires were driven by an in-house hiring consultant (former recruiter now doing consulting) working one day a week. Would you argue that a person sitting next to you, being able to talk to hiring person (me) in case of any doubt, speaking on behalf of your company (emailing candidates from @company-mail.com, not @recruiter-company-mail.com) and costing fraction of recruiter cost is better than a recruiter from an outside firm? > Firstly, ... You could see this as introducing > liquidity to the market. Market liquidity is not a good thing in itself. Its only purpose is to reduce spread between bid and ask prices, but by introducing your fee for a bidder you actually increased the spread. You surely can argue that you did a universal good thing for those applicants but you definitely don't bring more efficiency into the market. I understand this conversation is a bit meaningless. It's as if someone would talk to me saying that programming profession is outdated and needs to be replaced with something else. I would refuse to believe that, of course.