6 ms·
I know in theory you can do so, but representing yourself is often code for "I was unable to find a lawyer willing to agree with my crazy legal theory". Droppin
by tedunangst 12y ago
I know in theory you can do so, but representing yourself is often code for "I was unable to find a lawyer willing to agree with my crazy legal theory". Dropping phrases like "convert chattel" makes me think that's even more likely, because even lawyers don't talk to the press like that.
- rwmj 12y agoMore likely, he has no money and the UK has recently massively reduced the availability of legal aid.
- arethuza 12y agoWell, if he has no money at all then he definitely will qualify for legal aid: https://www.gov.uk/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing https://www.gov.uk/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing [Edit: I got this wrong - this is a civil case!]
- DanBC 12y agoThat's for criminal trial. His petition is not a criminal trial. He's trying to use civil law to get his equipment back. The civil rules are much stricter. https://www.gov.uk/civil-legal-aid-means-testing https://www.gov.uk/civil-legal-aid-means-testing
- hurin 12y agoModern law is effectively a cartel. There is no reason that an educated, intelligent man shouldn't be able to represent himself in most cases with fair preparation - so the bulk of modern law consists of creating obscure procedures and technicalities to make the former especially difficult, thus allowing the elite and privileged class to have an all-together different experience and preferable outcomes within the law which is only theoretically supposed to be applied in equal measure to all.
- tptacek 12y agoFairness and simplicity are in tension with each other.
- s_q_b 12y agoA fair justice system is by necessity complex, and a complex system necessarily requires guidance from an expert.
- hurin 12y agoWhat does it mean to be an expert? The cartel-aspect is that it's not good enough to know the relevant law (it's not any harder to read legal documents than manuals) or to be able to emphasize it's relevance and logical coherence relative to the case. This is precisely the kind of mystical nonsense notion that I was referring to. In their view a qualified defense must be made by a lawyer precisely for the sake of it being made by a lawyer, and for preserving the power-structure of the institution.
- s_q_b 12y agoNo. A qualified defense must be made by someone with requisite legal knowledge, and while not everyone with that knowledge must necessarily be an attorney, of course the courts use a law degree and the bar exam as heuristics. The simple fact that you think legal documents are no more difficult to understand than manuals is a perfect example of how woefully unprepared for the legal arena certain members of the general public are. It takes a long time to learn statutory law, case law, common law, constitutional law, regulatory law, and their interconnections about even a single subject, and it is assumed throughout that you will have knowledge of legal concepts that aren't contained in those documents. Is it possible to represent yourself and win? Yes. If you really know the law that well, you won't have a problem, even pro se. The issue is that many pro se litigants are like you. They hubristically believe the law is like an IKEA instruction booklet, advance wildly incorrect theories due to lack of foundational knowledge, end up wasting vast amounts of the court's time at taxpayer expense, and then bitterly complain that the judge didn't follow the law when they lose.