6 ms·
Accused British hacker, wanted for crimes in US, won’t give up crypto keys
- smtddr 12y agoSome advice for the accused; not that I condone your actions(based on the article, you seem guilty) but if you get the devices back you should probably assumed they've been compromised. You should just destroy them complelety. Or maybe investigate and document any tampering. But please don't login to any sensitive accounts on them. Don't decrypt the files on those devices either. Mount the filesystems and copy the files to a known trustworthy device.
- pavel_lishin 12y ago> Mount the filesystems and copy the files to a known trustworthy device. At this point, can we even be certain that that's safe? If the hard drives themselves have been compromised, what's to prevent them from copying out arbitrary data?
- c22 12y agoPerhaps nothing, but at that point you'll be able to tell if the data is arbitrary by attempting to decrypt it without having to entrust your keys to a potentially compromised device.
- bigiain 12y agoI guess it depends on value (to him) of retrieving the data and the sophistication of your adversary (and if his reported/alleged boasting on irc is to be believed, and collusion/cooperation between the UK's NCA and the US, you'd need to assume the most sophisticated of adversaries is a distinct possibility). It's too late to keep encrypted copies of the data out of his adversary's hands - they'll have imaged everything as their first step - so presumably he's either doing this because there's data there he wants, or he's just being a pain in the ass over a few hundred bucks (or pounds) worth of hardware (and more power to him if that's what's really gong on!). If _I_ needed data off those drives, I'd get a "burner" computer that's not connected to the internet or any sort of local network, plug the drives into that and decrypt them, then get those files off the machine in the least technical way possible - transcribe them by hand, take photos of the screen, print to a usb connected (burner) printer, if the data is too big for those sort of options (or binary blobs) I'd use a serial port connection to a second trusted machine. Then I'd melt down the drives and the burner machine. But mostly, I'd avoid becoming a target of the NSA's attention in the first place - if I were him I'd be suspicious of any hardware known or suspected by the NSA to be used by him ever. I'd assume supply chain exploitation of any new hardware with deeply embedded firmware/hardware layer exploits. I'd only ever use (for "private" purposes) 2nd hand hardware bought for cash from strangers... If you can get "targeted" for surveillance and exploitation just for occasionally using PGP and working at the wrong company (like the Gemalto guy from Thailand), how much scrutiny would you have to expect to live under if the US military thought you'd rooted their internal networks? Glad I'm not him...
- bigiain 12y agoAnd, in a late update: http://www.wired.com/2015/02/nsa-firmware-hacking/ http://www.wired.com/2015/02/nsa-firmware-hacking/ I don't know if he's considered worth this much to "the authorities", but how'd you like _that_ done to your disks? (If I'm reading that right, by non network connected burner machine would _probably_ be safe against that, but it's clearly half decade old NSA tech. Assuming their capability hasn't improve beyond that is ... foolish...)
- shit_parade 12y ago>(based on the article, you seem guilty) what utter nonsense, is being charged with a crime the same as guilt now? The article makes a point of repeatedly using the word alleged and citing that all the claims are from the prosecutor. It is extremely pernicious of you to use such language.
- tedunangst 12y agoWhat utter nonsense. Is seeming guilty the same as guilt now? The comment makes a point of using the word seem and citing that all interpretation is based on the article.
- tedunangst 12y agoI know in theory you can do so, but representing yourself is often code for "I was unable to find a lawyer willing to agree with my crazy legal theory". Dropping phrases like "convert chattel" makes me think that's even more likely, because even lawyers don't talk to the press like that.
- rwmj 12y agoMore likely, he has no money and the UK has recently massively reduced the availability of legal aid.
- arethuza 12y agoWell, if he has no money at all then he definitely will qualify for legal aid: https://www.gov.uk/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing https://www.gov.uk/criminal-legal-aid-means-testing [Edit: I got this wrong - this is a civil case!]
- DanBC 12y agoThat's for criminal trial. His petition is not a criminal trial. He's trying to use civil law to get his equipment back. The civil rules are much stricter. https://www.gov.uk/civil-legal-aid-means-testing https://www.gov.uk/civil-legal-aid-means-testing
- hurin 12y agoModern law is effectively a cartel. There is no reason that an educated, intelligent man shouldn't be able to represent himself in most cases with fair preparation - so the bulk of modern law consists of creating obscure procedures and technicalities to make the former especially difficult, thus allowing the elite and privileged class to have an all-together different experience and preferable outcomes within the law which is only theoretically supposed to be applied in equal measure to all.
- tptacek 12y agoFairness and simplicity are in tension with each other.
- pjc50 12y agoThey could use the RIPA powers to compel decryption, but they haven't, possibly because of the extradition context. In which case I think this is just covered by PACE: https://www.gov.uk/police-and-criminal-evidence-act-1984-pace-codes-of-practice https://www.gov.uk/police-and-criminal-evidence-act-1984-pac... ; but that allows items to be retained so long as an investigation is ongoing. Which would be until the US give up trying to extradite him. Given the Gary McKinnon fiasco, that's about a decade and the intervention of several Home Secretaries.
- topynate 12y ago> They could use the RIPA powers to compel decryption, but they haven't, possibly because of the extradition context. We don't actually know that with certainty. The Act contains a provision whereby someone can be forbidden from revealing that he's received an order to disclose an encryption key.
- pavel_lishin 12y ago> He exploited similar types of vulnerabilities in sites that used ColdFusion, the Web application software whose full source code was recently found on a server operated by hackers. I have no idea why, but I always assumed that the ColdFusion source was as freely available as Apache's or PHP's.
- bigiain 12y agoI'd guess that the source for Cold Fusion is probably fairly well secured by Adobe, and was never available on any of the exploited servers, the same way that very few webservers actually have the Apache or PHP _source_ code lying around, just the complied binaries. What was probably found on "a server operated by hackers" would have been the web-app written to run on Cold Fusion, so in your analogy it's more like they exfiltrated the WordPress php source files. (assuming, perhaps foolishly, that a logical interpretation exists for the hints dropped by a journalist who either doesn't fully understand, or who strove to lower his wordcount as a higher priority that technical accuracy...)
- joncp 12y agoAfter your equipment has been in the hands of a government, wouldn't it be wise to simply abandon that hardware? Who knows what kind of crap they've installed on it that is nearly impossible to remove.
- SnacksOnAPlane 12y agoYou can likely just get the raw data from your drives without actually keeping anything executable. Text files and images are fine, but I'm sure there are some formats that you'd have to be extra-careful about.
- keeperofdakeys 12y agohttps://technet.microsoft.com/library/security/ms08-021 https://technet.microsoft.com/library/security/ms08-021 That is a code execution vulnerability that allows someone to take over your computer when you open an image, and it was inside windows itself.
- ncza 12y agoText and images can easily be tampered with to exploit. In fact, that's a common malware vector. If you have reason to not trust your files, then it's fairly black and white.
- biafra 12y agoThat is why you need to make sure you do not give them your decryption password for your file container. And hope they were not able to compromise your encrypted container in such a way.
- RexRollman 12y agoI know it hasn't been requested yet but I find it interesting that the US could seek extradition of a suspect for hacking into their systems while facing no repercusions for doing the same to Gemalto.
- shitlord 12y agoWas this guy affiliated with HTP? They were notorious for the ColdFusion exploit, for hacking Linode, and for hacking DARPA (or something like that). Edit: Some Googling turned up a pastebin result [1]. Also relevant are [2] and [3]. [1]: http://pastebin.com/d0ni33Hx http://pastebin.com/d0ni33Hx [2]: http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/zeekill/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/zeekill/ [3]: https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Zeekill https://encyclopediadramatica.se/Zeekill
- ryanlol 12y agoLauri wasn't involved with HTP, he was involved with a HTP member that gave him the CF exploit he used.
- aburan28 12y agoThey will decrypt it in time