3 ms·
These academics are awful! Before doing an experiment that involves a third party, normal ethical standards are to get consent, which they clearly did not do.
by chris_wot 12y ago
These academics are awful!
Before doing an experiment that involves a third party, normal ethical standards are to get consent, which they clearly did not do. It sounds like the Uni of Cologne forced them into taking down the spambot - probably for a number of reasons, including but not limited to: possibility of civil action being undertaken against the University (you might want to look up the Tort of Passing Off to start with, then perhaps defamation), the terrible publicity this was getting (largely caused by the smugness of the three academics, especially Dan O'Mara who contradicted himself a number of times and appears to have taken the position that their actions were the fault of Jon Ronson) and the unethical way the project was being conducted.
There are conflicting views of the @jon_ronson bot in the Guardian article - a few people are saying it was created as a parody account to satirise Jon, yet it was being done by an automated bot that apparently had algorithms that took information (fairly badly) from Wikipedia. That's not satire, and it's not parody - and besides, the bot for some reason got confused quite often and there were clearly a number of unrepresentative comments made about Jon. I'd be very interested in seeing the code though - if this was for academic interest, then the academics should publish these algorithms for review because they appear to be faulty.
It's remarkable that one of the academics wrote a response on The Guardian stating that they were trying to show the world the tyranny of how we are all being manipulated by the power of algorithms. Which they have done by targeting Jon Ronson to manipulate him to prove their point. That would be credible had their experiment been conducted in a more open, transparent and ethical way - and involved consent!
It appears though that you are related to the academics - what exactly is your relationship to them?
- waterlesscloud 12y agoIt's worth keeping in mind that the interview is heavily edited and Ronson is being a bit disingenuous at several points, pretending to not understand things that he almost certainly must. David Bausola isn't so much an academic as some sort of artist/marketer combo. He's done some interesting Twitter bot things in the past. Strange and odd, but interesting. I've followed him and his experiments for years now, and it's just one of his things. I think he, at least, is genuinely interested in online identities and how people present themselves through Twitter and other social media. I don't believe at all he's a troll, though I do think his fascination with Ronson's responses is rather cold and clinical, and a bit more empathy would be appropriate. Having said all that, obviously they should have taken down the bot when Ronson was upset by it. My suspicion is they saw an opportunity to talk about what they do and get an audience for it, and they exploited that. Which is, of course, the wrong thing to do.
- chris_wot 12y agoWhat sort of things were you thinking of? I didn't really see any point he was being disingenuous...