3 ms·
Wow, the OP opens with the longest side-anecdote I can recall from such an essay...it should be an essay in itself...though it doesn't really add much to the ov
by danso 12y ago
Wow, the OP opens with the longest side-anecdote I can recall from such an essay...it should be an essay in itself...though it doesn't really add much to the overall message of the piece. The public shaming that he instigated/felt happiness with was of a whole different magnitude than the kind Lindsey Stone underwent.
The academics as portrayed by OP are insufferable...they did write a kind of mea culpa afterwards (including claiming that they weren't behind the bot http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/mar/30/how-bots-are-taking-over-the-world http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/mar/30/how-bot...)...actually, OP's reaction to the spambot seemed a little over-the-top, though I'm only saying that in the context of Twitter abuse that people face today.
Edit: Maybe I shouldn't think of the headline as being the full representation of what this essay (book excerpt actually) is meant to cover...I'm surprised no one has discussed the Hacker News mention in the OP, specifically relating to the "dongle incident" at PyCon (maybe because most of us stopped reading after the comical description of what Reputation.com claims to do?)...I've always felt bad for Adria Richards, but equally bad for "Hank"...Richards did what those thousands of Lindsey-Stone haters did...make a snap judgement off of a seconds-long observation of someone much more complex than just his race, gender, and snarky jokes. And she nearly ruined his life. Let's not forget that...The harassment that happened to Richards is unconscionable, and I have no doubt that it ruined her life...but what she did also wrecked someone else's life...the fact that he was in a position to be able to recoup and stay anonymous (Richards waived that right when she tweeted to her followers) doesn't change that he, too, was unfairly punished by the Internet mob.
It's terrible what happened to Richards but she comes off extremely poorly in this article, like a caricature drawn by the stereotypical mens-rights-anti-feminist advocate.
> “Maybe it was [Hank] who started all of this,” Adria told me in the cafe at San Francisco airport. “No one would have known he got fired until he complained... Maybe he’s to blame for complaining that he got fired. Maybe he secretly seeded the hate groups. Right?”...Adria replied that she was happy to hear that Hank “wasn’t active in driving their interests to mount the raid attack”, but that she held him responsible for it anyway. It was “his own actions that resulted in his own firing, yet he framed it in a way to blame me… If I had a spouse and two kids to support, I certainly would not be telling ‘jokes’ like he was doing at a conference. Oh, but wait, I have compassion, empathy, morals and ethics to guide my daily life choices. I often wonder how people like Hank make it through life seemingly unaware of how ‘the other’ lives in the same world he does, but with countless fewer opportunities.”
I empathize with Richards as she thinks she was standing up against oppressive effects at a tech conference...but just because someone's a white guy with more privilege doesn't make them less human.
- droithomme 12y agoI personally don't think his reply was over the top. The academics didn't just use his name, they used his PHOTOGRAPH as well for their spambot. That makes it a personal attack on his good name and not just some generic thing. Reasonable people are going to think that the spam bot was him. The vibe I got was that he started with that anecdote because he wanted to disclose straight out the time he publicly shamed some people and what the exact circumstances were. If he had not done so, people would have referred to that incident in the comments and he'd be on the defensive at that point. So he dealt with it instead as the lead, laying it all out. Another author writing a similar story who had not been in such a situation would not have to have that lead.
- Zak 12y agoI find Richards considerably less sympathetic after reading this. My memory of that incident was that everyone involved regretted that it escalated to the point of people losing their jobs, but she shows no regret about the fact that her posts led to someone losing his job here. It really seems to me that both employers are the real bad guys in that incident. In both cases, the most that should have happened to anyone was a reprimand.