2 ms·
> Perhaps science would be better served by a decreased emphasis on the individuals carrying out scientific research and increased emphasis on the results thems
by threeseed 12y ago
> Perhaps science would be better served by a decreased emphasis on the individuals carrying out scientific research and increased emphasis on the results themselves.
No thanks.
One of the worst aspects of modern day science right now is that the media et al seems to think it is okay to allow anyone to present counter arguments regardless of their scientific background. This causes problems for the laymen who has no ability to even comprehend let alone compare results from different individuals. And it is laymen who ultimately determines what science gets funded and what happens to the results of the science e.g. political action.
- protonfish 12y agoThe results of one study could mean anything and I agree it should not be emphasized to the public. However, the term "scientific consensus" makes truth sound like a popularity contest and worse - a popularity contest by people who claim they are better than you. This appeals to the authoritarian nature of people, not their critical nature. It is basically telling the public they aren't allowed to think. It's not only a jerk thing to do, it discourages scientific literacy outside of scientific professionals. Another problem with the "scientific consensus" is due to its political influence and nebulous definition it is rife for abuse. If there is no rigorous methodology to determine it in an accurate and replicable manner, then it can be whatever someone says it is. I agree that we need some sort of way of determining scientific validity by taking into account many tests, theory and perpectives, but "Scientific consensus" (whatever that is) is not it.
- rpedroso 12y agoI agree that armchair "expert opinion" is a significant problem at this time (see Harry Collins, "Are we all scientific experts now?"). However, I'm not sure I see how a social emphasis on evidence over authority would invite more of this. Collins, for instance, traces this problem to misplaced feelings of expertise. He believes we should "elevate science to a special position in our society." I mean to suggest that if we focus less on authority ("x says this, x is an expert, x is true") and more on science ("experiment y is evidence that z"), then this kind of layperson interjection would be excluded from social discourse.