7 ms·
Staffing costs and salaries are why I'd think long and hard about starting up in San Fran with my CTO hat on. I am a long-term open-source and commercial dev,
by peteretep 12y ago
Staffing costs and salaries are why I'd think long and hard about starting up in San Fran with my CTO hat on.
I am a long-term open-source and commercial dev, former serial CTO, with an additional specialization in recruitment software, but I also work as a recruiter. Recruitment in SF sounds like a nightmare for everyone involved. Agency fees are relatively low (10%ish, compared with 15-20% in the UK), but the service the candidate gets (incessant LinkedIn spam for inappropriate roles) is poor, the service the employer gets (scatter-gun approach, loads of shitty CVs, very little value-add from the recruiter, other than they'll spam LinkedIn for you) ...
I'm guessing it's a combination of the generally slightly immature state of the US agency recruitment market (compared to Europe; not meant as a judgement, just a fact), insane competition for candidates, very small take-up of and limited competition in job-boards/channels, and the big competition with corporate recruiters against FB, Google, and so on.
Every so often I wonder about trying to break in to the SF market (rather than London, which is where I put 90% of my time), but I wonder if the effort would be worth it, given what feels like the dire state of the market.
All the recruitment startups I can see are trying to build a better ATS to remove the agency recruiter (Lever.co, Greenhouse.io, SmartRecruiters.com, TheResumator.com, and even ZipRecruiter (an ATS disguised as a multi-poster)), yet no-one seems to be trying to fix agency recruitment.
Sorry for the slightly rambling post - happy to give free advice to anyone trying to recruit (see my profile), but it sounds like a real uphill battle in the Bay Area...
- joshAg 12y agoThe other side, though, is that it might be much easier to raise the necessary capital (taking into account changing costs due to location) in san francisco or the bay area in general than other places. It might also be easier to find qualified people in the bay area. Certainly they'll cost more than just about any other place, but how important is it to you to find say 5 people within the next month or two instead of the next say 6 to 24 months? I've never needed to actually do either of those two things, so I might just not know what I'm talking about, but for a startup that isn't bootstrapped I'd think that getting a long runway (for wherever you are) and advisers/investors who are knowledgable about your company's market are more important than the raw monthly expense figure, and that quickly getting qualified people working on the product might be more important than saving, say, $75,000 in salary per employee per year.
- peteretep 12y ago> but how important is it to you to find say 5 people > within the next month or two instead of the next say 6 > to 24 months. YMMV but generally: really important. If you are at the point where you are looking for five heads, you likely have competition and investor pressure. If you're bootstrapped or have a significant moat, maybe less so, but when I've been in charge of tech at companies, ability to grow my team quickly has been a major KPI, and a reasonable one. While I am led to believe that the easiest money is in SF, and there are some awesome investment partners, don't assume the best advisers are necessarily there; it's not been true for any of the three industries I've worked in, namely high-end fashion, recruitment software, and news/PR analysis. Digging specifically in to recruitment, the fact that every recruitment startup appears to be another ATS (Applicant Tracking System) - by far the most competitive space, also the one where the established players will be some of your hardest to displace (the reasons are dull but real (ATSs have long tendrils in to all sorts of business processes)) - seems testament to my hunch that "fixing hiring" companies are being guided by advisers with little in the way of recruitment experience. Possibly I'm wrong, and disruption needs to happen from outside, but the prevailing view that the expertise in tech in SF translates to expertise in every thing seems suspect to me.
- joshAg 12y agoThat's pretty much exactly what I was thinking, but I didn't want to overstate how much better 5 people starting NOW at a higher rate is than 5 people starting soonish for a lesser rate. I'm not surprised at all that there are probably better advisers outside of Si Valley for many industries. I'm a little surprised about recruitment, but not shocked at all for fashion or news. SF doesn't really have much in the way of those industries.
- peteretep 12y agoAmerica does almost everything exceptionally well, but my understanding is that recruitment can be added to the list of: cellphone service; airlines; consumer banking; Internet provision; justice system... (ironic for the country that gave us such marvels as the iPhone, Boeing, Wall Stret, the Internet, and the U.S. constitution)
- smikhanov 12y ago> immature state of the US agency > recruitment market compared to Europe You really have no idea about mature recruitment markets. The UK recruitment industry you represent needs to be replaced with a number of short Bash scripts, so that people like you (yes, you) will lose their jobs and suffer. The sooner it will happen, the better for everyone. I'm a Russian living in London and always mention Russian recruitment industry as an example of smoothly-functioning market with most inefficiencies resolved in a way you would expect in a modern economy. In short, agencies in Russia only deal with hiring top-level execs, equivalent to someone on £200K+ salary in the UK (i.e. less than 0.1% of the country's labour force). The rest is handled directly by companies directly through two of the largest websites -- job.ru and hh.ru (it actually feels weird to describe this on a forum that talks about disrupting something all the time!) The traffic on those websites is enormous, the number of applicants for any vacancy is much higher than any recruiter I used in the UK ever brought in. It costs the company a fraction of recruiter costs; it shows the applicant the company name immediately so he or she can do their own due diligence without listening to things like "top-tier investment bank" that you and your colleagues have invented. It's better for everyone. Compared to that, UK recruitment looks like car boot sale compared to eBay. Best companies like Yandex normally also advertise on their websites with few questions dropped into a vacancy to filter out non-qualified people (see, for example http://company.yandex.com/general_info/jobs/develop_cpp.xml http://company.yandex.com/general_info/jobs/develop_cpp.xml). Now, please, tell me about the added value recruiters in the UK bring anyone.
- _random_ 12y agoYes, unfortunately in London either: 1) recruiter effectively steals a percent of your starting salary; 2) company is so cheap they cannot afford a recruiter; 3) big tech companies are paying extremely low in comparison to the primary sector - finance (and the most interesting stuff will still be developed in USA).
- walshemj 12y agore 1 Its illegal for recruiters to charge the employee in the UK re 3 is mainly related to the poor social standing of STEM employees in the UK