3 ms·
> The actual show did not compel Monty with any rules on opening doors. He had free rein to do whatever he wanted. He could reveal an incorrect guess right away
by mcphage 12y ago
> The actual show did not compel Monty with any rules on opening doors. He had free rein to do whatever he wanted. He could reveal an incorrect guess right away with no opportunity to switch. He could and would offer the contestant cash to switch or not switch. Monty could try anything to trick or bluff or deceive the contestant, all for the sake of producing entertaining television.
And really, the thing is, none of that matters. Maybe in this version he could reveal an incorrect guess! Maybe in this version he could reveal the door that the contestant picked! That's not what happened in the situation you're asked to analyze. All that matters is that the host picked a door that (a) was not the door the contestant picked, and (b) contains a goat. Nothing beyond that is part of this problem, and nothing beyond that is necessary to solve it. You're given a very specific situation, and asked what the best decision to make is.