3 ms·
I have a deadly, incurable medical condition for which an annual flu vax is routinely prescribed. I was diagnosed late in life, just before I turned 36. Doctors
by Mz 12y ago
I have a deadly, incurable medical condition for which an annual flu vax is routinely prescribed. I was diagnosed late in life, just before I turned 36. Doctors told me bluntly "People like you don't get well. Symptom management is the name of the game." But it is genetic, so I was born with it, so I felt strongly that now that we knew why I was always sickly, we should be able to do a better job of dealing with my health than the years before that when I knew something wasn't right but did not know what and doctors acted like I was a hypochondriac.
In part due to happenstance, in part because doctors were not really doing much for me, I sort of fell into a lot of alternative med stuff. I began getting gradually healthier, even though I had spent a year at death's door. All of the people who were actually helping me get stronger while doctors wrote me off for dead were very strongly anti-vax.
The first two or three years following my diagnosis, when I was prescribed the flu shot, my doctor said 'Sign here and roll up your sleeve." and gave it to me right then and there. Then one year my check-up was a few weeks before the vaccine was available, so he wrote me a prescription. By then, I was already seeing a lot of gains from the "crazy" alternative med stuff I was doing. It was easy enough to just not get that prescription filled. I haven't had another vaccine since then.
Fourteen years ago, I nearly died and spent 3.5 years in bed. Now, I walk four or more hours a day and I am gradually getting my life back.
I am not on some campaign to convince people that vaccines are bad. I don't have strong feelings one way or the other. For complex reasons, I happen to be in a position where I can reasonably comfortably fence-sit on this issue and not develop a strong opinion. But, as things stand now, I don't plan to get any more flu shots. I think I am better off using other tactics to protect my health.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI would very much like to know what condition you have for which the treatment is regular, yearly flu shots.
- Mz 12y agoThat isn't "the treatment." It is just one component of standard care. I have a form of cystic fibrosis.
- pavel_lishin 12y agoI find it odd that you're rejecting vaccines in general because one of the things doctors suggested you get is the regular flu vaccine - which everyone else (in the United States, at least) is recommended. Did they recommend it to decrease your chances of getting the flu? If you have a medical condition, I would imagine that preventing other infections is kind of a no-brainer as the literally most basic step towards care. I don't want to make it sound like I'm jumping down your throat; I have no idea what your circumstances are, although I'm sure they're worse than mine.
- Mz 12y agoI find it odd that so many people here are painting me with such a broad brush and refusing to hear that I am not rejecting vaccines in general.
- danudey 12y agoFlu vaccines aren't about protecting your health, they're about protecting everyone's health. By not vaccinating, you're contributing to the elimination of herd immunity[1], ensuring that people who cannot vaccinate for whatever reasons (too young, compromised immune system, egg allergy, etc) are at a significantly higher risk of contracting the disease and putting their lives at risk. Unfortunately, this isn't one of those situations where you can fence-sit, because fence-sitting means you don't get vaccinated, which undermines public health and allows for the accelerated spread of diseases that can cripple or kill other people. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Herd_immunity
- Mz 12y agoCystic fibrosis patients are people who gradually die from antibiotic-resistant infections, something I no longer have. So I believe strongly that I am less of a health threat to others now than I was under conventional treatment of my condition. I have a compromised immune system. So it seems to me that by your own logic, I am someone entitled to not vaccinate.
- krschultz 12y agoArguably you are the person that everyone else should be protecting with herd immunity. I'm surprised that you are ended up on the anti-vaccine side. I also have a (milder) set of incurable health problems that have led to hospitalizations and several surgeries. The anti-vaccine crowd drive me crazy because they literally lead to people like me and you ending up dead when preventable diseases get passed around. You don't have a great feeling with the doctors because they don't have all the answers for you, and it took along time to diagnosis your condition. I also had to deal with that 'why is this happening to me?' moment, and the doctor just shrugged. They don't have all the answers. But for the things that we do have answers for, not using those answers is crazy.
- Mz 12y agoI'm surprised that stating one is "moderately anti-vax" and has chosen to forego the flu vaccine for themselves turns into such a train wreck on a discussion forum that prides itself on being logical. You and others here are behaving in a strongly reactionary fashion to very tame statements.
- civilian 12y agoCool. I downvoted your original comment but this is a good explanation of where you're at. I suspect that alternative medicine is better at symptom management, giving quality of life, and uplifting spirits. Doctors often have a too mechanical view of humans. Nevertheless, I suspect that your disease weakens your immune system, and _for that specific symptom_ the flu vaccine was prescribed. The flu vaccine was not meant as a general quality of life improvement. And along these lines, vaccines and alternative medicine are not mutually exclusive. They solve different things. Here's something to try: Get your flu vaccine while continuing your alternative medicine? My hypothesis is that there will be no downside except for pissing off your alternative medicine doctorfolk. You should also read up on how vaccines are made and what are contained in them, and then get into a discussion about vaccines with your alternative medicine people. You'll be astounded at their ignorance. Last year I was at an engagement party with an anti-vax crowd in Olympia, WA. They don't even know the first basics. But maybe I should check my B.S in Biochemistry privilege.
- Mz 12y agoCool. I downvoted your original comment but this is a good explanation of where you're at. Thank you.
- Retric 12y agoI also have a genetic issue that's incurable and left me vary sick last year. I currently feel fine. No lifestyle changes, no alternative medicine, just the ebb and flow of life. Plenty of people wanted me to try 'alternative' medicine and if I had it would have seemed useful, but sometimes doing nothing works and 'alternative' medicine often gets creadit for a lot of situations when doing nothing would have worked just as well.
- Mz 12y agoYou know, I have been doing this for 14 years. It gets extremely tiresome to be told that years and years of steady forward progress is absolutely not any evidence that I have any idea of what I am doing or what I am talking about and wilder coincidences have happened.
- Retric 12y agoThis is going to sound worse than I mean it. But, sample sizes of one are almost meaningless when it comes to health issues. The issue is there is way to many things going on at the same time. Often alternative medicine suggests a diet change and that can be far more useful than you might think. Could be the new diet adds stuff your missing or you old diet included things that where bad for you. In the second case they could suggest you eat pizza and donuts which actually helps. Many things are stress related so a little hope and a better mindset can be extremely useful. Other times it's an environmental hazard that goes away because some plaint up river changed their process and stopped dumping XYZ. The point of all that is clinical trials are necessary. But, at an individual level trying random crap can be useful.
- SamReidHughes 12y agoOn the other hand, in the past I've had a piece of medical advice by Mz to be quite helpful to me.
- Mz 12y agoIf you don't mind, please write to me (email in my profile) and let me know what it was we discussed. I have no memory of this and I relatively rarely hear back from people on HN where I have replied in public discussion about health things. Thanks!
- mc32 12y agoI'd like think that under circumstances where vaccinations were detrimental to my health for specific genetic reasons, that never the less I would support vaccinations as principle, even if I could not partake. There is no morality or hypocrisy involved. You're not out to deceive anyone. So, I understand your circumstance, I don't quite get people who oppose vaccinations ideologically.
- Mz 12y agoAs I said: I am on the fence on the issue. I am on the fence because doctors wrote me off for dead and had no goal at all of actually getting me well. They were content to watch me slowly die and blame my genetic disorder (in other words, conveniently wash their hands of all responsibility). The people who were actually helping me were extremely strongly anti-vax, and it wasn't an "ideology." They were actively involved in treating people with serious issues whom they believed had been harmed by vaccines (as just one of the underlying causes of the problems these people had). Some of them had impressive credentials, like PhDs. One was a former RN who had studied multiple alternative medicine modalities to keep her children alive, children who were anaphylactic to antibiotics. These were not "crazies" nor were they ideologues. They were people who were helping me save my life after doctors wrote me off for dead and found me annoying for not wanting to politely die so that they could feel like they knew everything. These people who were so strongly anti-vax were people who earned my deepest respect. I never studied the issue and never came to a particular conclusion about vaccines generally. But these people who earned my respect and saved my life planted the seeds of doubt. Furthermore, the people who claim to have science on their side and claim that vaccines are absolutely proven beyond a shadow of a doubt are generally not behaving rationally nor respectfully when they drag my name through the mud for expressing doubt. They generally aren't behaving in a manner that earns my respect and paints them as truly logical and informed. They are the ones that come across to me as ideologues with closed minds, much more so than the intelligent, knowledgeable people who caused me to decide to skip my flu shot and see if that made any difference.