3 ms·
How the organizer chose the door matters.
by dllthomas 12y ago
How the organizer chose the door matters.
- mcphage 12y agoIf you didn't know how the organizer chose the door (which you do, the original problem clearly states it), then your decision needs to be made independently of how the organizer chose it. All you can use are the facts in front of you: you chose a door, the organizer chose a different door, that contained a goat, and offered you the chance to choose. You need to make the best decision you can with the facts that you have.
- dllthomas 12y agoMy point was that your listing of things that happened in the past omitted an important piece of it. I actually don't agree that "the original problem clearly states it." Fully cognizent of the issues at hand, and with space for reflection entirely outside of the context of trying to solve the problem, I agree that it is clear that this is what the statement of the problem was trying to get at (particularly with the note that Monty knows which door has what) but it strictly does not say that that informs his choice (or how).