4 ms·
> Cap-and-trade is basically the last chance to fix the economy of the valley, and frankly it's not looking for good right now. Cap-and-trade is intended to in
by anamax 17y ago
> Cap-and-trade is basically the last chance to fix the economy of the valley, and frankly it's not looking for good right now.
Cap-and-trade is intended to increase govt control and pass out goodies to well-connected folks. It's unclear how either of those will "fix the valley". (Yes, there are well-connected folks in the valley who will benefit, but ....)
- Alex3917 17y agoIt's unfortunate that it has proved impossible to get a bill through the house/senate without adding various handouts for specific industries or even companies. That being said, creating a system that assigns a monetary value to each ton of carbon will still create the biggest economic boom in US history. What's more, like the dotcom boom it will be one that anyone can participate in, not just those who are well connected to the government or whatever.
- protomyth 17y agoWhere does the money driving the boom come from? I am unclear how increasing the cost of production of good and energy will generate an economic boom.
- Alex3917 17y agoFirst, you're not increasing the cost of goods and energy, you're increasing the cost of carbon. The idea is that the money flows to whoever can create those goods and services using the least carbon. While the cost of goods does go up, the increase is minimal because the system is designed to find the least expensive solution. The money comes in because the entrepreneurs who are able to find the most cost-effective ways to reduce carbon will get billions of dollars. So tons of highly intelligent and competent people will flock to the valley in an attempt to make it rich, creating dozens of public companies and several million jobs in the process.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- perkoff 17y agoThese "tons of highly intelligent and competent people" will probably not sit down and roll their fingers in either case. Rather, programs like this drains brain power from other sectors of the economy. There is an alternative usage for most resources! ANY new program would not increase our wealth. Building pyramids, for example, is just a waste of resources. Even if it would "create" a great deal of jobs for construction engineers, it would take away resources from _useful_ production. The increased demand for carbon licenses does not come out of thin air. Someone does pay for it - while reducing other expenses!
- antonovka 17y agoEven if it would "create" a great deal of jobs for construction engineers, it would take away resources from _useful_ production. In the U.S., we have no shortage of "useful" production, and no shortage of not-very-useful production (see also: Cougartown). Reducing pollution is useful production. I appreciate the idea that we'll assign a cost to traditional externalities whose cost is usually foisted on society at large, at which point the market will be forced to find new ways to decrease those costs. The increased demand for carbon licenses does not come out of thin air. Someone does pay for it - while reducing other expenses! It will also force incumbent, stagnant industries to invest in research and development, and disperse wealth more broadly, both of which pay significant future dividends beyond simply a reduction carbon output.
- anamax 17y ago> It will also force incumbent, stagnant industries to invest in research and development, and disperse wealth more broadly, both of which pay significant future dividends beyond simply a reduction carbon output. "force to invest" concedes the argument that these "investments" don't make any economic sense absent artificial costs, aka a govt mandate. As a result, the resources used by these "investments" would have been better used elsewhere.
- perkoff 17y agoWell, you could explain _how_ this will happen. Many of us, including me, simply don't get the argument. What differs this from assigning a monetary value to, let's say, _any_ new government license? (e.g. for opening a restaurant, or virtually anything) Seems like a rehash of the broken window fallacy.
- Alex3917 17y ago"Seems like a rehash of the broken window fallacy." Unlike with the broken window fallacy, you're not just breaking a window and creating jobs to create that same window again. The jobs created are actually going to make an entirely different set of products that the market wasn't creating before due to a flaw in the way the market was designed by the people who set it up. That's also why assigning value to carbon is different than assigning value to restaurants. Because of the way the market was designed we have the roughly the right number of restaurants, but way too much carbon. The important thing to realize is that the market didn't just happen, it was designed by people, and it can be designed differently. In the same way that we don't allow people to, say, dumb garbage in a public park just because they may want to under some idealized market fantasy, we shouldn't allow people to dump unlimited carbon in the atmosphere either. The market is a tool, invented by people, as the most efficient way to distribute resources to those who value them the most. But as a tool, we need to understand how it works, where it breaks down, and how to apply it effectively to create the kind of society we want to live in. We can't just treat it as some kind of religious construct, where it's magically going to write the laws, vaccinate the children, clean up dogshit from the street, etc. That's why cap-and-trade is so good, because it uses the power of the market to create the kind of society we want to live in. (As opposed to those who argue that we should live in the kind of society the market wants to create, whatever this means, frankly I have no idea and I don't think the people who advocate it have thought it through enough to realize that it literally doesn't make any sense, it's just empty words.)
- yummyfajitas 17y agoIf we adopted broken windows as a policy (rather than a one-off surprise event), you'd be creating jobs making an entirely different set of products that the market wasn't creating before: unbreakable windows, windowless buildings and wall hangings of the outdoors (to make windowless buildings less depressing). So your argument (if valid) would seem to support equally well an economic benefit from a broken windows policy. It's possible that a carbon tax might stave off a future disaster, but that's vastly different from creating "the biggest economic boom in US history". That's nonsense. A carbon tax will harm our economy, though perhaps not as much as the predicted disaster to come. Similarly, a "no dumping garbage" law would also not create an economic boom, even if it is less harmful than garbage filled parks.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- anamax 17y ago> It's unfortunate that it has proved impossible to get a bill through the house/senate without adding various handouts for specific industries or even companies. Interestingly enough, I wasn't referring to the explicit graft, but now that you mention it.... > What's more, like the dotcom boom it will be one that anyone can participate in, not just those who are well connected to the government or whatever. Wrong. Read the damn thing. That's not how it works. That's not even how the theoretical best version works. Cap and trade is a bunch of folks wandering around saying "that's worth $" and "you owe $". The excuse is carbon, but there's no actual connection between carbon and where those folks utter those sentences and the dollar figures. Don't believe me? Notice that we're not charging immigrants. We're not charging parents. The accounting for agriculture is impossible.