10 ms·
Summary: > In short, the finance sector lures away high-skilled workers from other industries. The finance sector then lends the money to businesses, but tends
by bhouston 12y ago
Summary:
> In short, the finance sector lures away high-skilled workers from other industries. The finance sector then lends the money to businesses, but tends to favour those firms that have collateral they can pledge against the loan. This usually means builders and property developers. Businessmen are lured into this sector rather than into riskier projects that require high R&D spending and have less collateral to pledge.
> A property boom then develops. But property is not a sector marked by high productivity growth; it can lead to the misallocation of capital in the form of empty Miami condos or Spanish apartments.
> R&D-intensive industries - aircraft, computing and the like - will be disproportionately harmed when the financial sector grows quickly. By contrast, industries such as textiles or iron and steel, which have low R&D intensity, should not be adversely affected
- badloginagain 12y agoCan't say I agree with these statements. I would wager that the scale of money a rapidly growing finance sector is using is more important than an unsubstantiated claim of industry brain-drain.
- Kalium 12y agoIndustry brain drain is a known phenomenon in other circumstances, such as the natural resources trap. It's plausible that it could occur here.
- cynicalkane 12y agoBrains are part of the real economy. Money is just money, and large amounts of it flows through institutions of various brain quality without being "eaten".
- nickbauman 12y agoTotally agree. When the finance sector grows, demands for return interest on capital investment intensifies, acting as a gravity-well for capital away from development. Firms like Goldman make every investment require higher and higher returns at a greater and greater scale. Money chasing money. Casino economy. Instead of opening a new line of business, your profits must be funneled into paying back on that loan at higher and higher rate.
- PaulHoule 12y agoTake a look at the allergy to investment in broadband in the US. The economics for Fiber Optics looks good in almost all situations in the US if you look at a ten year horizon. In the short term, however, Verizon can make more money by building an LTE infrastructure that costs more and does less and will be thrown away in five years and has 15x the OPEX of an optic fiber network. Today interest rates are crazy low and you'd think a company like Frontier would do this and know that that they won't be overbuilt in the flyover states and will pay a great dividend year after year for decades, but they don't. But just watch, once interest rates are crazy high you'll see companies scramble to get money.
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoFrontier's home city of Rochester had to redeploy fiber for all their trunk lines after a disastrous ice storm in the 90's. You'd still be lucky to get 4Mbit DSL from them. They are bottom feeders only out to milk a dying cow. Improving infrastructure is cost center that doesn't pad the execs wallets so it gets ignored.
- Retric 12y agoReturns are relative. Using the US example there has been a continious downward trend in post inflation returns over the last 100 years, but investment keeps growing.
- this_user 12y agoThe finance sector does more than lend/invest capital themselves. Large investment banks provide a wide range of services for companies (e.g. bond issues, IPOs, secondary offerings, working out M&A deals, brokerage services, ...). The biggest problem with the finance sector is that it is extremely opaque and almost no one outside the industry understands what financial institutions actually do. Yet, everyone seems to know that banks are bad. Which is better: a bright graduate working on making a large web company's advertising algorithms slightly more efficient or the same person working for an investment bank on a bond deal that helps a biotech company raise more money for future R&D?
- S4M 12y ago> R&D-intensive industries - aircraft, computing and the like - will be disproportionately harmed when the financial sector grows quickly. By contrast, industries such as textiles or iron and steel, which have low R&D intensity, should not be adversely affected So, buy barrier puts on those R&D intensive industries that is activated by a high growth of the companies in the financial sectors (bank...). As someone who used to do pricing, I find it pretty ironic that I can get investment tips from an article criticizing finance - I am not working in finance anymore and tend to agree with the article, though.
- skylan_q 12y agoSounds like the ABCT to me. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Austrian_business_cycle_theory Sounds to me like printing money and pumping it into finance leads to an unsustainible economy.
- nhaehnle 12y agoSince there is an obvious political slant to the message, it should be pointed out that it is the finance industry itself that is "printing money". So take that into account while thinking through the political implications, if skylan_q's premise is actually true.
- zo1 12y agoAnd it should also be pointed out that only governments can grant the power to print state-approved money. If you don't have permission, you will go to jail. There are countless movie plots dedicated to this simple topic, it should already be pounded into most peoples' minds already.
- dmfdmf 12y agoThat's what it sounds like to me too. Unfortunately, most people don't want to hear the truth so they downvote you. Big news for the ostriches; we never paid for the 2008/9 mortgage bust and those chickens are coming home to roost -- fattened up by the Feds ZIRP, TARP and continued credit creation. The mortgage bust was papered over by the Fed printing $4B+ and that is what they admit. It wouldn't surprise me if they printed double that to secretly loan to US and foreign banks and governments. Actions have consequences and soon we will see what von Mises meant by the crack up boom.
- LiweiZ 12y agoAustrian school economics seems unheard for many. After skimming books by Mises, I believe Austrian school is on the right track. But the tool for it has not ready at that time. When I learned about complexity systems. I think it can supply the right tool. And just this week, I'm reading papers by W. Brian Arthur. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Brian_Arthur http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/W._Brian_Arthur) Quite fascinating experience. Another issue with economics is it has very tight connection with financial and political systems. Until some players could take advantage with those more advanced theories, a new wave of mind-sets would not emerge and widely accepted by the public. Money, power, information, control, it sounds like crazy words. When things become closer to those, you have to think harder to get closer to the reality, if you do care about it.
- pkaye 12y agoI thought that the finance sector taking on too much risk is what led to the 2007 financial crisis? They would invest in things with less or no collateral to pledge.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- notahacker 12y agoThe problem with the finance sector was actually largely the opposite: financiers were so confident the collateral would hold its value that they were happy holding loans made to people with little or no skin-in-the-game or ability to make regular payments. They assumption was that even if significant numbers of loans in a portfolio failed, the repossessed houses could be sold on, perhaps even at a profit, Unfortunately the value of that collateral didn't hold up when a glut of repossessed houses appeared on the market and many prospective housebuyers suddenly found they couldn't borrow quite so easily any more.
- MaysonL 12y agoThe banks and mortgage brokers making all those "liars loans" knew that the loans weren't going to be repaid, but they didn't give an effing eff. They knew that they would be able to sell the mortgages in RMBSs and pay their loan officers and executives handsome bonuses for all those massive phony profits. They would blacklist appraiser who wouldn't give them appraisals to fit the loan they wanted to make.
- branchless 12y agoSpot on. Other responses are naive. They speak of "the banks". There are two entities here: 1. companies 2. individuals working for companies who get commission for selling loans whether they get paid or not Plus there are many many other problems with banking other than sub-prime which boil down to the above. That's why we need to start putting individuals in jail.
- gaius 12y agoIn short, the finance sector lures away high-skilled workers from other industries LOL. When other industries aren't run by chinless public schoolboys where engineers are second class citizens, call me.
- robrenaud 12y agoWhat's your number?
- Bjartr 12y agoWhat is meant by "public schoolboys" exactly? I'm struggling to grok the intended message.
- bhayden 12y agoI believe he is saying it's run by people of weak moral fiber and character.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoIn England Public School is where the "upper class" send their children for a private education. Chinless wonders is a derogatory term for less than intelligent children from those schools (in-breeding amounget limited aristocratic gene pool lead UK to have royalty with unusually small jaw lines for a while) And jobs in finance were considered till mid century to be available only to those people who knew each other, went to the same schools and used same networks. In short - an industry run by in-bred, unintelligent, privately educated with a small and elite job network.
- crdb 12y agoAlthough the other comments covered the gist of it, you might be wondering why Britain's best private schools are called "public": http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Schools_Act_1868 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Schools_Act_1868 FWIW all the schools have relatively extensive scholarship programs whose breadth and funding is cyclical and dependent on the views of the Headmaster and Board. Amusing anecdote: I attended Westminster (on a scholarship) under Tristram Jones-Parry who was known for both keeping the school at the top of the UK ranking for the duration of his tenure, and for expanding the scholarship programs. He was the quintessential "close to the troops" manager, he chatted with all pupils regularly, cornering them in the yard or the street to ask them their thoughts, and occasionally barging into a maths class and teaching it (incredibly well). When he retired and wanted to spend a bit of time teaching disadvantaged kids in state-run schools, his application was rejected by the government because he did not hold the appropriate teaching qualification. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristram_Jones-Parry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tristram_Jones-Parry
- dredmorbius 12y agoSee also: Dutch Disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_disease (Also from The Economist initially)
- wycx 12y agosee also: the present Australian economy. Our future is not bright...
- 1stop 12y agoSeems an odd statement. Australian economy is awesome, transitioning from resource to service long before it needs to... Which part of the future isn't bright?
- wycx 12y agoExactly what about it is awe-inspiring? In what services does Australia have an intrinsic advantage, or an advantage that will remain for the medium to long term? Why is a service economy a good thing? Australia went through the entire commodities boom without posting a current account surplus. Australia has been a net debtor every year since 1973. Australia has no money to invest in itself because its population is too busy borrowing money from overseas to speculate in real estate such that shitty brick veneer houses built in the 1960s are worth 1 million dollars. Our economy is so dependent on borrowing from overseas for "growth", that if we stopped borrowing and started paying back, then our economy would shrink, due to all the interest going overseas. Unlike Japan, for instance, Australian private debt is ultimately owed overseas, in another currency. If that borrowing had been directed towards productivity rather than real estate speculation things might be better. As it stands, the really expensive real estate is nothing more than a massive overhead for the economy. I challenge someone to argue how it aids Australia's productivity and competitiveness.
- 1stop 12y agoIf GDP is increasing, there is no reason to get account surplus, but instead to manage debt/growth ratio. Admittedly Australia hasn't done too well on this recently, but it's still in a good position (~30% of GDP). Unless you subscribe to the "Countries should be run like households" school of economics. Service based economies are desirable because they are human resourced (i.e they are renewable), and given Australia was resource based, there was a significant risk it could just sit on that and fall apart when it runs out. I'm not sure what you are talking about with "Intrinsic advantage"... Are their states with service based intrinsic advantages? The awe-inspiring part: The economy has done nothing but grow (in recent years, and has been one of the only ones to do so). Is it perfect? not at all. But seriously, you've got to have pretty massive global blinders on to say its future is not bright.
- smorrow 12y agoI didn't RTFA, but I have a question. > the finance sector lures away high-skilled workers I only just recently learned that doing finance is something people want to get into. And I still don't understand why, so that's my question. See, I've always thought of it as this thing that people only do because they thought they were supposed to. I'm in a maths degree right now, so I really know this feeling of not being qualified for anything real. Other than being a teacher, which is the thing I want, being an office boy in an insurance company is like the only other option I've ever been given. So I always thought finance people were only in it for that same reason. Not having a choice. What's the appeal? I'm still learning.
- ImprovedSilence 12y agoMoney. The amount of Money one can make in finance is the appeal. I graduated with my engineering degree ~8 years ago, if I knew in college what I know today about what any "real world" work environment/income levels are, I would have gone into the finance sector, hands down. Its's not too late for you. Sell out, cash in.