2 ms·
I have a dream, that someday a science editor will read an article in which the word "average" appears and then suggest that the word "median" should also appea
by jessaustin 12y ago
I have a dream, that someday a science editor will read an article in which the word "average" appears and then suggest that the word "median" should also appear.
TFA: "Today's tiniest sea critter is less than 10 times smaller than its Cambrian counterpart, measured in terms of volume; both are minuscule crustaceans."
Presumably we're talking about Stygotantulus stocki, which is 94 µm long. That's already smaller than a lot of bacteria, so I'm not sure how much more it could possibly shrink? There is an effective lower bound here.
TFA: "But at the other end of the scale, the mighty blue whale is more than 100,000 times the size of the largest animal the Cambrian could offer: another crustacean with a clam-like, hinged shell."
Leaving aside the apples-to-rutabagas comparison of clams and mammals, is there any physical reason why whales are the largest animal we could imagine? They're big, but so is the ocean. There is no effective upper bound in sight.
Average is not a meaningful statistic in this case.
- mrec 12y agoAlso, does "less than 10 times smaller" mean e.g. 9 times smaller, or e.g. 11 times smaller? From context I'd guess that TFA intended the latter, but it's horrible writing.
- remarkEon 12y agoI think it means 9 times...I think. Sometimes reading statistical comparisons in the news is just insufferable.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThe only thing that I could imagine is what also limits the size of ground animals - the ability to remove heat from the body. Volume grows with cube of radius, while surface area (and thus heat exchange area) grows only with square of radius - so the bigger you get, the more efficient your heat management mechanisms must be.
- Lavery 12y agoCurrent large whales need enormous amounts of insulation (a big part of why they were hunted a hundred years ago) to maintain their body heat. While there is no doubt a point where heat becomes an issue for sea creatures, it's a ways away. Given the degree of overfishing we've seen in much of the world and depletion of the fish stocks, I think a more realistic upper bound would be the ability to consume enough mass. Although on an evolutionary time scale maybe fishing policy isn't as much a problem.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]