3 ms·
> Barrangou and his colleagues found that the bacteria had stuffed DNA fragments from the two viruses into their spacer Sounds almost Lamarckian, doesn't it?
by davidw 12y ago
> Barrangou and his colleagues found that the bacteria had stuffed DNA fragments from the two viruses into their spacer
Sounds almost Lamarckian, doesn't it?
- mirimir 12y agoYes, it is. From a text box in the article: Did this mean that CRISPR meets the requirements for Lamarckian inheritance? “In my humble opinion, it does,” said Koonin.
- davidw 12y agoOh, cool, I hadn't made it quite that far, I've been slowly reading the whole thing. It's fascinating stuff, and the article seems to be nicely written, in a way that doesn't feel dumbed down, but is accessible to someone not familiar with the field.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoNote that we do have a whole field of epigenetics which deals with Lamarckian stuff.
- klmr 12y agoLamarckism isn’t about epigenetics, nor vice-versa. Some people are calling epigenetic inheritance Lamarckism, but many (in my experience, most) colleagues reject this label as inaccurate. For one thing, although epigenetic inheritance on the single-cell level is a simple fact, and amply demonstrated, it hasn’t been shown to contribute to evolution in any way, and trans-generational epigenetic inheritance in multi-cellular organisms is a difficult concept to demonstrate (there are papers which claim that, but these are contentious, since they fail to demonstrate a persistent effect across several generations). The claims of epigenetic-inheritance-as-Lamarckism are on par with saying that a person’s nationality is Lamarckian: If I emigrate and take on a new nationality, there’s a high chance I’ll confer this nationality to my offspring, simply by raising them in that country. Yet no evolutionary biologist would claim that nationality is in any way part of my genetic heritage. Here’s a more detailed treatment of these claims: http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/7338/82 http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/7338/82
- klmr 12y agoIn a way, all mutations in single-celled organisms that are inherited by daughter cells are acquired during the mother’s life-time, so they’d all meet some definition of Lamarckism. CRISPR isn’t that special in this regard. Many evolutionary biologists also prefer not to call this Lamarckism – not because it would be entirely wrong, but because it is misleading to many lay people, who imagine that this would somehow be in conflict with Darwinian evolutionary theory of evolution by natural selection (it’s a hobby of many creationists to search for press releases mentioning Lamarckism to crow “ha! Darwin is refuted again!”). This choice isn’t a problem in practice because Lamarckism – unlike neo-Darwinism – doesn’t offer explanatory models which are essential to understand and reason about these processes.
- davidw 12y ago> Many evolutionary biologists also prefer not to call this Lamarckism Maybe that's why I got downvoted for - as it turns out - writing the exact thing the scientist said. It was just something that popped into my head.
- klmr 12y agoYeah, don’t understand the downvotes. It’s an interesting question, and the whole subject of Lamarckism is far from trivially obsolete. Richard Dawkins’ The Blind Watchmaker contains a coherent and convincing argument why Lamarckism is actually wrong as an evolutionary explanation (in a nutshell, Lamarckism fundamentally cannot explain increase in complexity, as Darwinian evolution can, and it additionally doesn’t explain how adaptations of complex traits could possibly be acquired from scratch) – and this is a fundamental, epistemological objection which no amount of evidence could overturn. But few people refer to this reasoning when claiming that Lamarckism is “wrong”.