3 ms·
Note that it can depend on the wording of the question. Monty must know that he's revealing a goat for it to work out 2-to-1. If he picks randomly, your odds
by dllthomas 12y ago
Note that it can depend on the wording of the question. Monty must know that he's revealing a goat for it to work out 2-to-1. If he picks randomly, your odds are 1-to-1 after he's revealed the goat.
- JohnTHaller 12y agoMonty knows he's revealing either a goat or the modest prize. If you pick the goat, he reveals the modest prize. If you pick the modest prize, he reveals the goat. If you pick the big prize, he could reveal either the goat or the modest prize, but IIRC, he would reveal the goat.
- dllthomas 12y agoI agree that that was the intended formulation of the original question. That doesn't mean it's fair to assume it's what everyone should understand from every (possibly flawed) attempt at restating it. I don't know whether I've seen the precise wording of the version that sparked the controversy, so I don't know how clear it was on the point.